Hot learning experience while cooling off
SO there was just that chance that the first part of Drama Box's two-part presentation It Won't Be Too Long might not have run last Thursday, on Cooling-Off Day. After all, the topic and the consultative method of The Lesson could have been construed as political, even if no party logos were brandished.
The issue-based, community "theatre" was right in sync with the mood of the week, as Singaporeans prepared to go to vote in the 2015 General Election the next day. Which made the issue - what amenity would the estate trade, for a new MRT station? - all the more real, and it was good to see an engaged audience.
For instance, a group of young adults next to me in Drama Box's cool inflatable "theatre" seemed quite into the forum theatre format that I had to ask them if they represented any NGO or if they were regular Drama Box supporters. It turned out that besides the interesting topic, "it's one of the free events" of the Singapore International Festival of Arts (SIFA), which is why the mixed group of 6-8 registered (or so they said) - though it seemed more likely they had a friend participating as one of the residents.
For The Lesson, Drama Box drew a scenario of a housing estate which has rental flats, a public market, an old cinema which now only screens films for foreign workers, a columbarium, a hospice, a halfway house, and marshland. One of these has to give way to a new MRT station. That was the "rule of the game" or the parameters of the public debate, as the audience and a pre-selected group of 12 estate residents had to decide which one they wanted to "sacrifice" for the MRT station.
The estate's residents had first dibs to unanimously pick one amenity that could go, but if they failed to agree, then the public (aka the rest of Singapore) got to decide, and a ballot would be taken on their views. The residents would then have no choice but to go with the majority decision.
Before the decision was made, Drama Box facilitators like Kok Heng Luen, Li Xie, Jean Ng and Jalyn Han moderated a debate and discussion. They also invited two speakers, one of whom was social worker Jolovan Wham, to present an expert opinion on issues like migrant workers.
On the night the forum piece was held in English, there were a number of young ones, and the debate of what should go was confined to mainly the old cinema or the columbarium. Different viewpoints (some well argued, most not really) were bandied about and tended to revolve around what was most beneficial to the living.
Incredibly, there were some very uninformed arguments - coming from young people, no less - that the natural marsh could be sacrificed because it could be "re-created".
Overall, it was a thought-provoking process of "how a community goes through decision-making" - although on a very superficial level. The facilitators could have jazzed it up more by throwing more nuggets of information to spur the debate process. Hardly anyone asked more defining questions about the spaces which could have affected the outcome.
If anything, this could be a dangerous reflection of the decision-making and debate process in Singapore - in that debates happen in an information-poor context. Sometimes, one felt that the "residents" and the audience wanted to voice an opinion just for their own gratification.
That could be a result of the "rule of the game" itself in that, of course, everyone knew that the scenario (regardless of the fact that it's very real in Singapore) was just set up as a theatre piece rather than to really seek a solution. In any case, the audience voted for the columbarium to go.
It will be interesting to see how Drama Box takes this result to Bukit Brown, where it will continue its It Won't Be Too Long presentation in The Cemetery, in a sequel to The Lesson.
It Won't Be Too Long: The Cemetery will be held on Sept 18 and 19 at Bukit Brown (at 5.30am) and SOTA (at 8pm). For more information, see https://sifa.sg/sifa/show/the-cemetery/
Share with us your feedback on BT's products and services