Banking will be shaken up - by tech giants, not fintech startups

The best fintechs now offer services to banks, which then buy them out. Banks must push the use of AI to stay relevant.

Published Thu, Feb 8, 2018 · 09:50 PM

    IN cash-abundant Silicon Valley, there is a myth that any college dropout with a hoodie and a half-baked idea can raise venture funding. They are young and limitless. They aren't biased by industry norms and so can freely reinvent the world as we know it.

    They are Steve Jobs. They are Mark Zuckerberg. They are Bill Gates. If we live in a world of accelerated change, they move at an accelerated pace.

    These seemingly small-scale innovators can sometimes be devastatingly dangerous: Netflix destroyed Blockbuster, BuzzFeed decimated Time, Uber threatened GM, and Amazon trampled BestBuy.

    Understandably, the financial sector has fallen victim to the fear of immediate disruption. According to a recent PwC study, more than 80 per cent of financial institutions believe their business to be at risk of disruption. Accordingly, 56 per cent of the respondents said they had put disruption at the heart of their strategy.

    And yet, a close examination of the life of a typical fintech startup paints a very different picture. At Credit Suisse, we sought to understand exit strategies in fintech. We discovered that the most common ones for startups were acquisitions or quick imitations by incumbent banks. When not being acquired, fintechs are expanding their reach into unrelated sectors that only seem tangentially financial.

    Ultimately, we expect most startups to end up turning into conventional financial institutes, like Zopa, the first peer-to-peer lender with the initial ambition to disrupt the established finance sector but that ended up paying for a banking licence to provide traditional banking services.

    All this is consistent with a broader trend: More companies have disappeared because of mergers and acquisitions than any other reason. Between 1978 and 2012, the number of companies less than a year old as a share of all businesses declined by 44 per cent.

    And in the financial sector, individual startups face additional hurdles beyond what others faced in the e-commerce Internet world.

    The theory of disruptive innovation, introduced by Harvard professor Clayton Christensen in 1995, has proved itself a powerful way of thinking about innovation-driven growth. The core principles of the theory are that successful disruptive technologies:

    As a precondition for disruption, incumbent players initially don't respond to the newcomers' efforts due to the low margins, but from the existing customers' perspective, the lower price of the offering does not compensate for its inferior performance.

    In this environment, disruptive innovators can develop their ideas and test their business model without major interference from established players and their demanding clientele.

    However, among the largest and most promising fintechs that Credit Suisse has investigated, there is little evidence that newcomers are targeting under-served customer segments. Instead, all startups in our sample have rolled out their initial offering to already-served banking clients, often targeting the incumbents' core customer base.

    This should not be too surprising. Technology-driven innovation requires a significant level of expertise, which is why most of the world's leading fintech startups are launched near talent pools with advanced technological know-how. Fintechs develop and offer services tailored predominantly to their own region, which is usually an economically mature, well-banked space (except China).

    So, when it comes to segmentation, fintechs don't have much choice but to enter an already-serviced space and fight for the customers of incumbent players - and the incumbents react fast. Before long, the startups are either acquired or face direct competition from these banks.

    Of all the breakthrough technologies applicable to finance, the explosion of machine learning and artificial intelligence (AI) seems the most promising. One of the most radical improvements in recent years has been how machines learn. For data scientists and machine-learning experts, March 2016 was a momentous month. AlphaGo, a computer program developed by Google, beat world champion Lee Sedol at the ancient Chinese board game of Go 4-1. Before AlphaGo played the board game Go against humans, Google researchers had been developing it to play video games: Space Invaders, Breakout, Pong, and others. Without the need for any specific programming, the general-purpose algorithm was able to master each game by trial and error, pressing different buttons randomly at first and then adjusting to maximise rewards.

    Game after game, the software proved to be cunningly versatile in figuring out an appropriate strategy and then applying it without making any mistakes. That's why AlphaGo represents not just a machine that can think - like IBM Watson - but also one that learns and strategises, all without direct supervision from humans.

    This general-purpose programming was made possible, thanks to a deep neural network of hardware and software that mimics the web of neurons in the human brain. Reinforcement learning occurs in humans when positive feedback triggers the production of the neurotransmitter dopamine as a reward signal for the brain, resulting in feelings of gratification and pleasure.

    Computers can be programmed to work similarly, and the positive rewards come in the form of scores when the algorithm achieves a desired outcome. Under this framework, AlphaGo writes its own instructions randomly through many instances of trial and error, replacing lower-scoring strategies with higher-scoring ones. That's how an algorithm teaches itself to play anything, not just Go.

    It is easy to imagine a world where self-taught algorithms play a much bigger role in coordinating economic transactions. At Credit Suisse, we can observe first-hand how intelligent computing has improved operational efficiency.

    One of the most complex areas where innovative technologies play a key role in improving operational efficiency and reducing risks is compliance. Credit Suisse's compliance department launched an initiative crucial from both business and regulatory perspectives. The project aimed to enable a holistic view of all its clients and consisted of designing and implementing a technology-based solution capable of consolidating client-related data from all regions into a single platform.

    The two key challenges were making data from different systems compatible and accessing it in real time to effectively mitigate potential risks. The project was launched with the initial scope of client data covering natural persons in our retail and international wealth management businesses booked out of Switzerland. Next, the team focused on improving the data quality, functionality and rolling out the technology globally.

    We are now able to assess client information significantly faster and simplify client relationships. More importantly, the system assigns each client a risk score to assist decision-making and to allow us to use advanced analytics.

    Still, this development of artificial intelligence is akin to the early phases of electricity, when it first arrived and replaced steam power in manufacturing. Interestingly, when manufacturers began to adopt electricity, engineers couldn't even fathom an alternative layout like the modern-day assembly line. It took almost another two decades before the manufacturers truly reaped the full benefits of electricity.

    Today, most incumbent banks tend to frame AI as a cost-cutting measure, substituting human labour in administrative processes. Though this is important, its biggest potential is likely to be so profound that it will transform financial institutions as we know them.

    The true disruptors won't be startups; rather, they will be deep-pocketed technology behemoths, spreading their tentacles into the world of finance as cross-boundary disruptors.

    Amazon's chief executive Jeff Bezos reportedly once said: "Your margin is my opportunity." The biggest threats to big banks are not fintech startups but rather Amazon or Google, who shift the industry value chain. These and other cross-boundary disruptors, including Alibaba in China, have been leveraging the existing data they have harvested through e-commerce and then specialising in new services targeting customers outside of big banks.

    Unlike a startup, which is forced to enter an existing space to gather customer information, these tech giants have already acquired huge volumes of data based on commercial activities outside of finance. Consequently, they naturally turn to new segments outside of traditional financial institutions. This doesn't mean that big banks will disappear. But if they aren't prepared, they could be reduced to utility companies: ubiquitous, reliable but certainly not key, with margins so low that they are hardly attractive to anyone, including investors. This is why all big banks must push AI to the next level, while time is still on their side.