Oxytocin, Britain and the limits of cooperation
FOR years, historians and social scientists have been studying the political, economic and cultural causes for the extension of social trust and cooperation that could explain why smaller units, starting with extended families and tribes, have expanded into larger political units, including nation-states and empires.
The liberal model that has been popular among Western elites since the end of World War II, and especially in the aftermath of the Cold War and the rise of globalisation, has assumed that our civilisation was progressing slowly but steadily towards more cooperation. The lines separating nations, ethnicities and races are being blurred; and immigration, international trade, multilateral regimes, and rising literacy and education weaken the power of nation-states and facilitate the formation of larger political units, like the European Union, and create the foundation for a new international community.
The most recent research conducted by neuroscientists and evolutionary psychologists has raised the possibility that a neural hormone called oxytocin - synthesised in a region in the base of the brain known as the hypothalamus and from there distributed to the body - may have played a role in the course of evolution by reducing the distrust we feel towards strangers and creating a sense of solidarity and social cohesion.
But as scientist Nicholas Wade explains in his recently published A Troublesome Inheritance: Genes, Race and Human History, the trust promoted by oxytocin "is not of the brotherhood of man variety - it's strictly local". Oxytocin doesn't simply promote general feelings of trust between individuals, but heightens the individual's trust in the members of his community - while increasing her distrust of outsiders.
Hence, increasing the brain's production of oxytocin would likely make you more willing to protect members of your in-group but also to heighten your suspicion of those who don't belong to it.
Mr Wade and other scientists speculate that through natural selection, humans' neurons were able to acquire more and stronger oxytocin receptors as rising levels of oxytocin helped boost trust between individuals and assisted in the formation of larger units of political cooperation - from the extended family to the tribe to the village to the town and city and the nation-state - allowing for social and economic collaboration like trade and other forms of exchange.
But the question is at what point the effect of oxytocin ceases to be compatible with the size of a community. Or, to put it another way, when does the community become so large and diverse that the oxytocin gene doesn't ignite the human propensity to trust other individuals and to collaborate with them, and the individual doesn't feel any sense of affinity with the additional members and, in fact, wants to see the community shrink in size?
To judge from the results of the recent election in Britain, that may be how the citizens of the United Kingdom are feeling now, demonstrating that the reigning liberal model that envisions a never-ending progress towards greater cooperation and unity is crumbling.
If anything, the UK may be devolving into smaller communities, with more Scots seeking political independence from the UK, while the English people are expressing their growing desire for a Little England that could eventually secede from the EU.
No one is expecting the eruption of a civil war in Great Britain, but it's becoming clear that the people of England and Scotland (and probably Wales) feel a sense of distrust towards each other and would probably not be able to preserve the current unit of cooperation - following the footsteps of the Czechs and the Slovaks, the Serbs, Croats and Bosnians, and Kosovars, and leading to similar scenarios elsewhere in Europe (Spaniards, Basques, and Catalonians).
Similarly, the possibility that Britain would quit the EU seems to fit into the larger trend of political backlash against the Germans' dominant position in Europe that is alienating other national communities, especially in southern Europe.
At the same time, the growing immigration of Muslims into France, Germany and other European countries has failed to create a sense of trust between them and the natives.
Even more dramatic have been the collapse of the entire nation-state in the Middle East and the return of the traditional political units of the religious sect and the ancient tribe around which individuals are coalescing while those who don't belong to these clans are regarded as outsiders that cannot be trusted. Indeed, it seems that the level of oxytocin isn't going to rise among them anytime soon.
TRENDING NOW
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Peter Kwee’s Ridley Park bungalow on the market with S$100 million asking price
Beyond the greenback, Vietnam’s big borrowers turn to Asian-currency bonds