Retirement investing in a crisis: Keep calm and carry on
Adopt a rational, systematic exercise as an emotional state can wreak havoc on long-term intentions
AT A time of sharp volatility as we're seeing in markets today, investing can be a fearful experience. But it can also be a rational, systematic exercise.
Retirement investing in particular may be fraught with minefields. One, your emotional state can wreak havoc on long-term intentions. Two, a sudden change in circumstances - the loss of employment, for example - could necessitate withdrawals from your portfolio at a time when its value is down. And three, if you are already a retiree, regular withdrawals for spending at this time when market values are down could prematurely deplete the value of your portfolio.
There are approaches, however, that can help lift the anxiety from retirement investing. We've gathered some insights from financial advisers and strategists.
If you are older, however, the ideal time to begin to dial down on risk is when markets are high. "We have found that with the decade-long bull market, it was harder to convince people to de-risk their portfolios. This is another example of emotions at play." There are a few other levers you can control, she says, such as reining in spending, saving more, or delaying retirement.
Samuel Rhee, chief investment officer of digital investment adviser Endowus, says the good news is that bear markets though painful tend to be short, and bull markets tend to be much longer than you think. "Typical bear markets last one year. The person who retires at 65 will still have assets to invest for another 25 years on average which is ... long enough to achieve success in gaining the long-term positive returns growth assets like equities provide."
With a long horizon it is also important to keep investment costs low. This reduces the drag on returns.
"Recent volatility has made it even more difficult, if not impossible, to avoid the worst days and benefit from the best...If you miss even a handful of the big rebound days, you will really damage your long-term returns. So, especially in volatile times, it's better to stay invested than try to time the markets," she says.
Endowus advocates a passive, strategic long-term asset allocation into broad-based market exposures, at a low cost. Mr Rhee says: "We're not trying to generate outsized alpha by trying to 'beat' the market like many active investors do, but instead we want to capture the long- term market returns which is good enough for most investors to build wealth over the long term." The portfolios, which are invested in the lower-cost institutional share classes of diversified funds such as those of Dimensional Fund Advisors and Pimco, will be exposed to market volatility.
"We cannot hedge away this volatility effectively. The only successful hedge is time. So we try to help investors choose the portfolios that are appropriate for their risk and be patient, long-term investors."
Financial advisory firm Providend mitigates this by putting clients' savings in buckets which anticipate withdrawal needs as well as the longer term need for growth assets. It calls its system RetireWell. The nearest term bucket from which the client draws a current income is invested in very liquid assets. The longest term bucket will be invested in growth assets that generate a higher rate of return.
Even with this systematic approach, there are challenges. One is the very low yields in the market today. Referring to the nearest-term bucket, Providend chief executive Christopher Tan says: "Even if yields or interest is low, we still have to do it this way for a retiree, as reliability of income is more important than return on investment at this stage in their lives. To compensate for the lower yield, a retiree might need to set aside a larger capital if they are to fund their lifestyle, or accept a lower monthly income."
A client's spending rate is part of regular reviews. "In our yearly reviews, clients have many other considerations beyond just market performance to decide how much they want to spend for that year," he says.
Ms Appleton points out that a potential challenge that occurs in market drawdowns is "dollar cost ravaging", where a combination of market losses and portfolio withdrawals early in retirement can cause a nest egg to deplete, even if the portfolio performs well overall. One way to mitigate this is to spend or withdraw less.
"This matters for people just prior to or just after retirement when wealth is typically greatest and at greatest risk... Drawing your spending back can be really helpful in preserving your portfolio. You can also consider investing in strategies to make your portfolio more broadly diversified."
The higher rates of return in the SA and Retirement Accounts, however, are a different story. Mr Rhee argues that balances in SA and RA should be left to earn CPF's higher interest rates.
Providend's Mr Tan says: "Regardless of whether there is a crisis or whether interest rates are high or low, we have always maintained that monies in the SA should not be invested. In fact one should top it up using cash or from the CPF-OA as soon as possible in one's accumulation years." CPF Life, he adds, is the best annuity programme. Hence, topping up the SA makes sense as it is ultimately used to fund CPF Life. On investing the OA he advocates using cash first. "... we always use monies from a lower interest bearing account to invest first, before using a higher interest (account)."