Rising to South-east Asia’s energy insecurity challenge with FDI

    • Foreign direct investment could bring funding and talent development to areas in South-east Asia and nudge countries away from cheaper but dirtier fossil fuels for energy.
    • Foreign direct investment could bring funding and talent development to areas in South-east Asia and nudge countries away from cheaper but dirtier fossil fuels for energy. PHOTO: PIXABAY
    Published Mon, Sep 26, 2022 · 05:50 AM

    OVER the last two years, we have seen the global energy markets swing from one extreme to another, starting from significant oversupply in pandemic-stricken 2020 to critical undersupply due to recovering production and skyrocketing demand. This situation has been exacerbated by an evolving geopolitical landscape – most notably the ongoing Russia-Ukraine war and the potential re-entry of Iranian crude back into the marketplace. The complicated global energy landscape is further impacted by the growing worldwide imperative to address climate change, which has seen countries pledge to cut fossil fuel production.

    Solving the energy crisis is paramount for countries to preserve stability and remain on track to achieve political and economic outcomes, especially in energy-hungry Asia. According to the Foresight Economics Energy Sector FDI Attractiveness Index, the ongoing disruption of crude oil and natural gas supplies to Asia is expected to result in an inherent shift to locally sourced, dirtier but cheaper substitution fuels, which would have various ramifications for progress – especially where the environment is concerned.

    However, a silver lining is that this shortage has also generated greater momentum for a stronger push for investments into disruptive sustainable energy sources – particularly in Southeast Asia – to resolve energy volatility. What was originally thought of as the region’s “transition” from fossil fuels to greener alternatives may have accelerated into a straight “jump” out of pure necessity, and foreign direct investment (FDI) will play a critical role in this evolution.

    Addressing South-east Asia’s energy challenges

    The fallout from the energy scarcity has been especially pronounced in Asia, especially when compounded by the twin woes of surging commodity prices and falling regional currencies.

    In the face of record high temperatures from a severe heatwave and drought, China’s coal power generation is also approaching new highs to meet nationwide energy demands for air-conditioning. The heatwave-driven power crisis is also affecting India, where 100 unsustainable coal mines may be reopened to cope with the surging temperatures. Meanwhile, in Sri Lanka and Pakistan, political and economic turmoil have led to difficulty in securing more fuel sources, resulting in countrywide power cuts.

    South-east Asia has remained relatively untouched by the energy crisis, but it is by no means out of the woods. The International Energy Agency (IEA) notes that based on present-day policy settings, energy demand in the region is set to grow at a rapid 3 per cent a year until 2030. Three-quarters of that demand is expected to be met by fossil fuels, which the IEA has declared is a “significant vulnerability” in the region’s efforts to achieve energy security and meet carbon emissions goals.

    Yet what is the alternative? With the recent surges in the oil and oil-indexed gas prices, especially with the war in Europe, South-east Asian markets will face stiff price competition for fuel in the near term – especially for Liquified Natural Gas (LNG). If this persists, it is inevitable that cheaper and dirtier power options may remain on the table for longer, especially with many South-east Asian countries also being either or both major fossil fuel producers and still at a nascent state in green energy adoption.

    A stronger case for green energy

    With the evident vulnerabilities of long-term fossil fuel dependency and Europe outbidding Asia for cleaner but more expensive LNG vessels, South-east Asian countries may be incentivised to accelerate green energy development to meet rising energy needs and preserve energy security. The 10 member states of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (Asean) have already set 2025 targets to increase renewable energy to 23 per cent of total primary energy supply, as well as a 35 per cent share in installed power capacity. In fact, Indonesia, Thailand and Vietnam are set to make some of the largest renewable capacity expansions this year.

    However, South-east Asia requires a significant amount of support to achieve this green transition at speed. A 2021 report by Bain & Co, Microsoft and Temasek said that as much as US$2 trillion in infrastructure investments is needed over the next decade for the region to cut emissions – a sizeable jump from the US$9 billion that was spent on green assets in 2020. Concurrently, the Asian Development Bank estimates that roughly 40 per cent of infrastructure investments must come from the private sector. This is where FDI could make an important and necessary contribution.

    Traditional forms of financing, such as loans, may come with stringent conditions and high interest repayments that would be burdensome to emerging economies. In less developed capital markets, green energy-related loans may be difficult to get or justify given more immediate developmental priorities. FDI, however, represents capital inflow into a country, with foreign companies building new facilities (greenfield) or purchasing/leasing and repurposing existing facilities (brownfield). This results in a natural transfer of technological knowledge, the development of a more highly skilled labour force and improved infrastructure.

    Foresight Economics’ Energy Sector FDI Attractiveness Index found that as of 2019, Singapore was the most attractive destination in Asean for energy sector-focused greenfield FDI. This is primarily due to its openness to trade, lower tariffs and a freer flow of imports and goods. Brunei and Vietnam are the next South-east Asian countries on the list; in the case of Brunei, this attractiveness is attributed to a higher endowment of natural resources, which the country is well known for.

    While fossil fuels are included within this index analysis, it highlights the healthy interest in South-east Asia energy sector investment for investors. As the green energy movement gains global momentum, it is expected that there will be an increasing appetite from the private sector for low-carbon investments in the region, especially for solar and wind power. Initiatives such as the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership could also facilitate more investment, trade and transfer of green energy and technology, therefore fueling further green energy innovation and adoption as Asean states double down on net zero commitments and climate goals.

    Going where the FDI flows

    With fossil fuel dependency no longer sustainable in the long term, South-east Asian countries are in clear need of long-term energy security initiatives that are both environmentally and socially sustainable for them to remain competitive and progressive in an ever-changing landscape. Given the high amount of investment needed for them to innovate and implement these initiatives in timely fashion, we anticipate that FDI flows will be instrumental in helping them achieve their goals.

    As the world strives to establish a new dynamic equilibrium, particularly in the energy sector, we foresee that FDI geography will both change and drive change over the next few years. It will play a pivotal role in determining the future of the global geopolitical and energy landscape, and it will be interesting to see how that relationship plays out in South-east Asia.

    Kavilash Chawla is the founder of Foresight Economics.