Technology can be harnessed to serve the unbanked in Asean

Published Wed, Oct 26, 2016 · 09:50 PM

DIGITAL financial services can be crucial for overcoming the tyranny of geography in South-east Asia, where traditional financial institutions have found it difficult to build out their footprint in remote areas and across many islands. The expansion of digital financial services throughout Asean in recent years has been impressive. Consider the numbers. Between 2011 and 2014 alone, the share of adults in Asean with a bank account grew from 42 per cent to 50 per cent of the population.

While this should be celebrated, we still have a long way to go to achieve universal and deep financial inclusion in Asean. Only 36 per cent of adults in rural areas have a bank account. In addition, usage remains a key issue. Only 15 per cent of adults in Asean are actively using a debit card. Also, 39 million micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs) have no or insufficient access to credit, with a total funding gap of US$175 billion. The size of the prize from increased financial inclusion is significant. McKinsey Global Institute (MGI) estimates that digital finance could raise the level of GDP of emerging economies by a total of 6 per cent by 2025.

AlphaBeta recently worked with the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) to understand how to achieve universal and deep financial inclusion. Five of the lessons from this work are highly applicable to Asean.

1. Digital financial services are not just a central bank issue

Much of the existing approaches has centred on the role of central banks (and also telecoms and competition regulators) in promoting digital financial services. Our research has shown that over 60 per cent of the potential policy intervention areas for national governments to promote digital financial inclusion are outside the traditional remit of the central bank and telecoms regulators.

These areas include opportunities to digitise existing government cash payments (both G2P, such as welfare payments, and P2G, such as utility bill payments), payment of civil servant salaries, as well as broader enablers such as fraud prevention and building a digital national ID infrastructure.

2. Build trust

Low trust in formal financial service providers and of digital accounts, in particular, is a major challenge. Some governments and financial institutions have tackled this by leveraging informal networks to build trust. Papua New Guinea's Nationwide Microbank, for example, recruits women who actively use MiCash to engage women from villages without accounts or with inactive accounts.

3. Look broadly for opportunities to convert cash payments to digital form

There is a large array of opportunities to convert payments into digital form. Over 70 per cent of adults in Asean still receive their wage payments in cash; 69 per cent of adults in Asean receiving government transfers do so in cash; and 89 per cent of adults in Asean pay their utility bills in cash. There are a number of innovative global examples of how to digitise many of these cash payments. Dialog, a Sri Lankan Mobile Network Operator (MNO), introduced "eZ cash", a mobile money payment service, to pay utility bills. This electronic payment service has reduced both travel time and costs for users - especially those in the rural areas.

The Kenyan government is exploring digital payments for purchase of bus tickets and also providing insurance for inter-city bus transport. There are also opportunities to think about digitising payments that don't yet exist. Consider carbon offsets. Juma Sustainable Development Reserve in Brazil aims to avoid the degradation of 366,000 hectares of rainforest and the emission of 210 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent into the atmosphere by 2050. Local forest communities are rewarded for committing to avoid clearing primary forest and avoid burning vegetation through digital payments (as part of a global carbon offset programme).

4. Don't forget about merchants

Some of the received wisdom is that merchants will be keen to support digital mobile transactions since this reduces their security risks and alleviates cash flow issues. And hence, there is no role for government in promoting digital person to merchant payments. The reality is very different. Merchants often only see the downside of a shift to digital payment solutions. The transparency brings them into the tax system, and this can be compounded by the high transaction costs and the uncertainty involved in making the shift.

To include merchants in the digital payments space, some governments are exploring the possibility of "tax holidays" for merchants that sign up, as well as exploring low- cost transaction models, and looking to leverage the peer network to build acceptance. Juntos in Tanzania, for example, collected mobile money usage stories from merchants to share with other merchants and users in order to build trust in digital payments. This resulted in an over 26 per cent increase in digital payments.

5. "Nudge" consumer behaviour towards greater account usage

There is often an assumed path dependency of digital payments - once individuals use their basic accounts, they will naturally progress to using more sophisticated digital financial services. The reality is that a large share of accounts are emptied as soon as money is transferred. For example, less than 40 per cent of adults in Asean use a financial institution for saving money. A starting point to tackle this is to reduce the number of limited purpose instrument accounts which constrain the options of users.

Behavioural "nudges" can also be useful to encourage usage of different financial products. A randomised control trial in Morocco found that labelling a government cash transfer against a goal (eg, education) increases the likelihood that the transfer will be spent on that goal.