Time to do away with virtual-only AGMs
FROM a corporate governance viewpoint, it is disappointing to see that although almost all restrictions on group sizes have been lifted, most companies which have a Mar 31 year-end will not be hosting fully physical annual general meetings (AGMs) in July. Even more disappointing is that a few will still be holding electronic-only AGMs, instead of the hybrid format which is allowed.
This has to change. With the Covid crisis having stabilised, all sectors of the economy have been fully opened, normal overseas travel has resumed and with Singapore enjoying a high vaccination rate, contagion risk is now minimal. The authorities should therefore revert to physical meetings, or at the very least, do away with the virtual-only option.
Virtual meetings were introduced in April 2020 in response to the onset of the pandemic when the danger of virus contagion in large gatherings was clearly present. Legislation was passed to allow companies the choice of replacing the in-person AGM with one that was either fully virtual or a hybrid option, which allowed some shareholders to be physically present and the rest attending online.
At the time, the benefits of online meetings were, apart from eliminating the risks of viral spread from physical interaction, said to be that companies could save money by not having to rent expensive venues while shareholders could save time and cost by not having to travel to and from meetings. It was claimed that this would translate to higher attendance and increased efficiency, since all parties could then focus on the issues that mattered without having to deal with peripheral tasks relating to logistics and travel.
In practice, however, it was found that virtual meetings lacked the spontaneity of physical meetings, and many AGMs were reported to be boring, sterile affairs with no vigorous discussions of pressing issues. The requirement that questions had to be submitted in advance did not help – companies could then pick and choose which they wanted to answer, whilst ignoring those that were more difficult or controversial. Moreover, some meetings were fraught with technical issues, which made logging in a frustrating experience. Meanwhile, online voting has also not been a seamless process.
In short, virtual meetings whilst holding much promise on paper, have not been as successful as might have been previously thought. They may be the preferred option of companies, but some studies have found that attendances at virtual meetings have actually been lower than before, which suggest that they are not popular with shareholders. The authorities should therefore revisit the fundamental purpose of AGMs, which is to give investors a once-a-year opportunity to interact meaningfully with their company managements and to extract answers to questions they may have about their investments.
Some observers have also pointed out that there is no real substitute for face-to-face encounters which enable shareholders to engage with boards and managements and to observe the latter’s body language when fielding queries and draw conclusions from the impressions thus derived.
However, given that virtual meetings do offer some advantages in terms of cost savings, the best compromise would be to alter the choices from fully virtual or hybrid, to fully physical or hybrid. As governance advocates agree, the hybrid model that allows some shareholders to attend physically represents the best of both worlds. The faster this is done, the better.
TRENDING NOW
Motoring tycoon Peter Kwee is back in court: Here are his previous legal battles
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Beyond the greenback, Vietnam’s big borrowers turn to Asian-currency bonds
Nvidia’s outlook cut to stable by Moody’s on governance concerns