Trade and trust between India and China are at odds

Published Thu, Aug 27, 2020 · 09:50 PM

THE trust deficit between India and China has been soaring to worrying heights. But New Delhi's chronic trade deficit with Beijing has declined sharply.

The two deficits are an oddity. After the ferocious border clashes between the two countries in June this year, the trust deficit worsened and had an immediate impact on bilateral economic relations as many Indian trade groups demanded a boycott of Chinese goods.

And as Indian demand for imports weakened and import restrictions on Chinese goods increased, Indian exports to China surged by 78 per cent in June, according to the rating agency Crisil. The rising exports have lowered the Indian deficit, which should spell good news for India, both economically and diplomatically.

Indian diplomats should be delighted as they have often raised concerns with their Chinese counterparts about the widening trade deficit, but it has been difficult to address the issue. Eventually, India's historic trade deficit with China has been reduced.

The bilateral trade still favours China, but the Indian trade deficit with China has been on a downward trend, falling to US$48.66 billion in fiscal year 2019-2020 from US$53.56 billion in 2018-2019, and US$63 billion a year earlier, according to Indian government data. In just one month, in June, India's monthly trade deficit with China halved to US$1.2 billion, from US$2.4 billion in May.

Why is the deficit so important to the larger economic relationship? After all, India's deficit with China is a big chunk of its overall trade deficit. Just prior to the deficit shrinking in June, India's monthly trade deficit with China was US$3.3 billion in February, a 13 per cent rise from the same period a year ago. By comparison, India's monthly overall trade deficit was US$9.8 billion in February this year, unchanged from a year ago.

There is, of course, a great deal of interdependence between the two countries. It is obvious that India is importing less of the goods that it used to buy from China such as engineering products, electronics and raw materials for pharmaceuticals and cars. The improvement in Indian exports was also caused by higher Chinese demand for Indian organic chemicals, mineral fuels, cotton, ores, plastic items, nuclear machinery, fish, salts, electrical machinery and iron and steel.

Given their interdependence, the trust deficit should be removed quickly so that both countries' economies can soldier through the current economic crisis.

It has been suggested that India can reduce its trade deficit with China by US$8.4 billion during fiscal year 2021-2022, which is equivalent to more than 17 per cent of the deficit with China, according to Acuité Ratings and Research. The proposal calls for Indian companies to manufacture some of the products the country has been importing from China.

It is not a smart long-term idea, because such import substitution strategies take us right back to the isolated Indian economy of the Cold War years. It may, however, produce significant results in the short term if the intention is to erase the trade deficit. Acuité Ratings argues that domestic Indian manufacturing plants should be able to substitute 25 per cent of the total imports from China.

One reason why imports from China have declined by around 15 per cent since 2018 is the imposition of anti-dumping duties on some products. Yet, the Indian economy remains highly dependent on Chinese imports. Nonetheless, sectors that may be able to reduce their dependence on imports are chemicals, car components, bicycles parts, drug formulations, cosmetics, consumer electronics and leather-based goods.

India has imposed anti-dumping duties on more than 370 Chinese products which are being dumped in the Indian market by China at below average prices, in order to safeguard domestic players from cheap imports. All of this could be taking a toll on the inflow of foreign investments as well.

The outlook for Chinese foreign direct investments in India looks increasingly bleak because in April this year, the Indian government tightened rules for investments from countries that share a land border with India - a measure that includes China. Under the new rules, investors from these countries would need prior approval for each project.

RECENT DECLINE

Foreign direct investment (FDI) inflows from China into India have been declining in the recent past. Chinese investments fell to US$163.78 million in 2019-20 from US$229 million in the previous fiscal year. According to Indian government data, China's FDI in India stands at US$2.38 billion, in sectors such as cars, metallurgy, electrical equipment, services, and electronics.

Another trend in India's trade is that its exports are rising to countries that have been successful in battling Covid-19 - such as China, Malaysia, Singapore, Vietnam, South Korea and Japan; and its exports are contracting to those countries that are still battling the pandemic such as the US, the UK, Germany and Brazil, according to the rating agency CSIRL.

At the same time, India's exports to Malaysia rose by 76 per cent in June this year, Vietnam by 43 per cent and Singapore by 37 per cent, as these countries had flattened the Covid curve.

In some sections of India, the prospects of trade with China have been dampened considerably since the India-China border clash in June. The Confederation of All India Traders (CAIT), an influential organisation of the traders' unions which represents 4,000 trade bodies, has planned to boycott Chinese goods worth about US$13 billion by December 2021.

CAIT has finalised a list of 3,000 items that were imported from China - including toys, gifts, consumer products, confectionery products, clothes and watches - because indigenously manufactured alternatives to these items are available in India. As a result, CAIT has emerged as a spearhead of a movement to boycott Chinese goods that aims to ensure that no Chinese products are imported during festivals. At two recent festivals, Raksha Bandhan and Ganesa Chaturthi, reportedly no rakhis or Ganesa idols were imported from China.

To return to the theme of the interdependence between India and China, it is hoped that both sides find a way to replace the trust deficit with confidence by resolving their border dispute. It is highly desirable that they also balance their trade equitably, so that one side is not left with a massive deficit. If all efforts fail, the two sides may need to invoke the Lord Ganesa to help clear the obstacles to restore normalcy in their trade relations.