Why Georgia state loss poses challenge to the Dems

Democrats, liberals and pundits thought it would be a win for Ossoff - and a centrist agenda for the party - but his loss now gives the left-leaning faction in the party the upper hand

Published Thu, Jun 22, 2017 · 09:50 PM

    Washington

    TO quote famed baseball player Yogi Berra, who was known for his witticism, "it was déjà vu all over again".

    When this week's election in the sixth Congressional district of the state of Georgia ended in a loss for the Democratic Party candidate, disheartened Democrats and liberals had the "I-cannot-believe-this-is-happening" feeling; America pollsters shook their heads; New York Times commentators had egg on their faces; CNN political pundits looked depressed; and young women who were expecting to celebrate their candidate's victory were instead weeping in front of the television cameras late on Tuesday night.

    Of course, no one would suggest that the special election in Georgia's sixth Congressional district was a momentous historic political event like the US presidential election last Nov 8.

    Most of these special elections aren't considered to be very, well, special. And the outcome of this one - held to fill the congressional seat vacated by Republican Tom Price who had been tapped by victorious President Donald Trump to serve as his Secretary of Health and Human Services and to lead the effort to repeal Obamacare - wasn't going to change the balance of power in the House of Representatives. The Republicans would still have continued to control that legislative body and would probably have had a better-than-50-per-cent chance to achieve that goal, even if their candidate had lost the race in Georgia.

    But everything in life, including in politics, is about timing. And, indeed, eight months after Democrat Hillary Clinton lost the presidential race, and with Republican President Trump having occupied the White House for five months, Democrats were feeling that they had a chance to change the direction of American politics and in the process to even make some history.

    Well, sort of.

    POLITICAL MOMENTUM?

    In fact, many Democrats were feeling that the political momentum was on their side: President Trump's favourability ratings in the opinion polls were continuing to sink, with the White House mired in a political scandal that threatened to force its occupant out of office.

    Indeed, Democrats were feeling that their so-called "Resistance" to President Trump and Trumpism was gaining pace, especially when it came to young voters, women, African-Americans and Hispanics, and even among educated and professional Republicans who felt embarrassed by the conduct of the political novice they had elected, and by his seeming out of his depth in his job.

    And then they thought that they could win the electoral lottery in Georgia with the candidate they had chosen to run in the Sixth Congressional district. Thirty-year-old Jon Ossoff has been compared to Canada's Justin Trudeau and France's Emmanuel Macron; he is young and attractive, cool and metrosexual - the one who would be able to energise his political base, given that he was up against the 55-year-old Karen Handel, a veteran member of the Republican political machine who would make even Mrs Clinton and British Prime Minister Theresa May come across as charismatic.

    But there was one big problem: The suburban Atlanta district, where the special election was held, has been controlled by the Republican Party for the last four decades, making it less likely that the Democrats could deliver an upset there on Tuesday night.

    There was, however, some good news for the Democrats. The demographic makeup of the Republican voters in the district didn't include those "angry white men" and blue-collar workers who had buoyed Candidate Trump to victory last year.

    In fact, President Trump had won the district by a narrower margin than he did in other "red" or Republican areas. Pollsters referred to the Republicans in the Atlanta district who supported him last year as "Reluctant Trump Voters". Most of them had college degrees and were not employed in manufacturing industries; they were middle-class and upper-middle-class Republican voters, conservative on fiscal policies, moderate on social-cultural issues - the kind of Republicans who would have preferred former Florida governor Jeb Bush to head the GOP presidential ticket, and who were probably alienated on some level by President Trump's angry rhetoric, not to mention his bad manners.

    But these Republicans were even more alienated by what they saw as a Democratic Party leaning to the political left, obsessed with identity politics and planning to raise taxes. And they certainly weren't excited by the Democratic presidential candidate. So they voted - reluctantly - for the Republican choice last November.

    To Mr Ossoff's credit, he recognised what made Republican voters in the district tick and adjusted his campaign to those electoral realities, which was not very difficult for him personally. A member of a well-to-do Jewish family, well-mannered, urban and urbane, he looked and sounded like the kind of young man you wish your daughter would marry.

    Moreover, Mr Ossoff - a centrist political Democrat - embraced a moderate political agenda, more like the one once promoted by President Bill Clinton; his agenda reflected commitment to responsible fiscal policies and mainstream social-cultural values.

    No, he wasn't a supporter of leftie and populist former presidential candidate, Vermont senator Bernie Sanders, but more like an American version of the politically middle-of-the-road Mr Macron, who, indeed, was able to win the presidential election in France by appealing to many conservative voters.

    And then there was the money, a lot of money, close to US$24 million raised by Mr Ossoff's campaign, mostly from out-of-state sources, including through fund-raising among traditional liberal Democratic contributors in New York, Hollywood and the Silicon Valley.

    Mrs Handel raised only US$4.5 million, mostly in Georgia, in what was the most expensive House race in American history.

    Like in the months leading to last November's presidential race, pollsters and pundits in the mainstream media seemed to buy into the political narrative promoted by the Democrats. The Special Election in Georgia was trumpeted as a "Referendum on Trump" and Mr Ossoff was celebrated as a young political innovator who would bring together Democrats and discontented Republicans, deliver a clear message to the White House, and, most importantly: His expected victory would presage the outcome of the 2018 mid-term election, which the Democrats would win, take control over the House and Senate, and start the process of impeaching President Trump.

    UNFULFILLED EXPECTATIONS

    But, like last November, the grand expectations weren't fulfilled. Not only did Mr Ossoff lose the race, Mrs Handel won by a comfortable victory, carrying the district by a margin wider than the one that allowed Candidate Trump to defeat his Democratic opponent.

    If even the Reluctant Trump Voter has voted again for President Trump at a time when he was under huge political pressure and playing defence, one cannot count on the Enthusiastic Trump Voter to desert him in 2018, especially if the economy continues to improve.

    The outcome of the Georgia race also poses a major challenge to the Democrats. A victory by Mr Ossoff would have strengthened the hands of the centrist wing of the party that has rejected calls by Senator Sanders' supporters to move the Democrats further to the political left.

    But members of the progressive wing of the party will now insist that the Democrats need to learn a lesson from the electoral success of the left-leaning Labour Party in Britain. Forget President Macron. We're talking about British Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn. But if the Democrats decide to follow that route, chances are that the Reluctant Trump Voters in the Sixth Congressional district of Georgia wouldn't be too reluctant to re-elect President Trump in 2020.