Formula 1's race to net-zero
As F1 accelerates efforts to slash its carbon footprint, the motorsport will see some major changes in the coming years.
HIGH-SPEED racing returns to the heart of the city this September, with Singapore renewing its contract with Formula 1 (F1) to host the Grand Prix for another 7 years until 2028.
But upcoming editions will have one key difference from past events: the Singapore Grand Prix will adopt more climate-friendly initiatives, in line with F1's - and the Republic's - broader efforts to cut carbon emissions.
F1 has set a target to achieve a net-zero carbon footprint by 2030, which includes developing carbon-neutral engines that run on sustainable fuel by 2025. The motorsport is also exploring other areas that will move the needle more significantly, such as requiring F1 buildings and team facilities to use fully renewable energy; studying ways to offset unavoidable emissions; and curbing emissions from logistics and travel.
The ambitious target means that F1 needs the buy-in from all stakeholders, including racing teams and host venues. For instance, the Canadian Grand Prix uses solar energy stored in solar panels to offset the energy needs for the event. By 2025, the plan is to have every race event on the calendar adopt a sustainability strategy. F1 teams such as Ferrari and Williams Racing have also kicked their sustainability efforts into high gear.
This year, a new rule requires teams to use E10 fuel - which consists of 10 per cent bioethanol - and is seen to be one of the most significant regulatory overhauls since 2014 when there was a switch to turbo hybrid engines.
Analysts say that F1's goal to deliver a more environmentally friendly race is an important one. "F1 creates a very heavy carbon footprint - from the cars themselves; the teams and 'circus' as it travels around the world to fulfil the global calendar; but also the fans flying in and travelling to the races," says James Walton, sports business group leader and chief sustainability officer for Deloitte (South-east Asia). "It is a very carbon intensive sport as a global touring motorsports event."
Another reason behind the sustainability drive is perhaps more self-serving. Walton highlights that F1's new owner, Liberty Media, is working on engaging more younger fans in the 18 to 40 year-old age bracket. "Sustainability is an issue of critical importance to these new fans," he adds.
Tracking outcomes, getting the message out
While F1's goal to achieve a carbon neutral footprint was first announced in 2019, it has charted out its path to getting there more clearly in recent years.
Alpesh Patel, partner at McKinsey & Company, pointed out that F1 was already making strides with green technologies in the past, but had not been entirely successful in getting the message out.
He says: "The hybrid engines used in F1 are the most efficient in the world, with a thermal efficiency of 50 per cent versus about 30 per cent for normal cars powered with internal combustion engines (ICE). This message wasn't clearly conveyed to the public, representing a missed opportunity."
Now, with 2030 targets "clearly established and communicated to the public", F1 is on par with big firms and other global sports such as the Olympic Games.
Still, there are admittedly some rather unique challenges, Patel goes on to say: "How to use cutting-edge R&D to ideate and manufacture cars; the need to operate hybrid engines rather than battery-electric ones, and the need to setup over 20 races around the world each year."
According to a study previously carried out by F1, the motorsports' carbon dioxide equivalent emissions stood at 256,551 tonnes for the 2019 season. And while the cars may instinctively be thought of as gas guzzlers, surprisingly, a mere 0.7 per cent comes from the engines across all teams throughout the entire season.
Instead, the key contributor to emissions is actually logistics (45 per cent), stemming from the movement of team equipment and cars from venue to venue.
Meanwhile, business travel accounted for another 27.7 per cent, covering air and ground transportation as well as the hotel impact for employees of all F1 teams and key event partners.
The 2019 study showed that the other big contributor to F1's carbon footprint are factories and facilities (19.3 per cent) - namely all the owned or operated offices, factories or facilities linked to F1.
With the global pandemic resulting in some races being called off as well as reduced travel from the F1 fraternity and fans alike, carbon emissions linked to the F1 season would have declined in recent years due to Covid. And as nations start to ease restrictions in a transition to endemic living, it is possible that this trend could reverse.
Patel says: "With calendar expansion from 21 races in 2019 to 23 in 2022, and perhaps 25 in the near future, we will naturally see an increase in the carbon footprint, until some of the logistics optimisation measures being implemented by F1 kick in."
"Cutting emissions (from fan attendance) will require work at the transportation level, which is partly manageable by the race venues when it comes to last-mile, but is otherwise largely outside of the control of F1."
Still, certain initiatives rolled out at the height of the pandemic, such as a "remote operations" broadcasting strategy, are expected to become permanent fixtures.
Prior to the pandemic, every race location needed a broadcast centre - a transportable facility which houses over 470 pieces of equipment - to beam the race live to viewers.
Its remote technical centre (RTC) is now located in Kent in the United Kingdom, where some 165 employees, such as engineers and producers, are based over race weekend.
Meanwhile, the broadcast centre at every race has been halved in size to become an event technical centre, sending content, data and feed back to the RTC in the UK. According to F1, this has slashed the number of travelling staff by 36 per cent and freight by 70 tonnes, or about 33 per cent.
It is also working on reducing emissions from its broadcast operations, using the British Grand Prix as a test bed. Initiatives in place at Silverstone in 2021 include replacing some 7,500 litres of traditional diesel with hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) fuel in the generators, as well as introducing zero emission vehicles for circuit operations.
Addressing the impact of logistics and travel
Walton says: "Two of the biggest steps for F1 still to address are how to make the logistics and travel of the global Grand Prix community more efficient as they move venue-to-venue. They are taking steps, such as replacing their Boeing 747 fleet with Boeing 777s; and how to encourage fans to use more environmentally-friendly ways to reach the events, or to offset if they can't."
According to DHL's global head of brand marketing, Arjan Sissing, logistics planning for the F1 usually begins over a year before each championship. As part of its cleaner logistics options, DHL has F1-dedicated trucks kitted out with new, low-emission units.
He says: "The GPS upload allows the team to monitor fuel consumption, routes and ensure best practices - and it helps to reduce emissions." Non-critical cargo, such as catering and hospitality equipment, is transported via sea freight so as to avoid air freight where possible. There is also duplicated equipment stored at different venues worldwide.
In addition, DHL is testing out new solutions, such as a biofuel-powered truck which made the 1,100 km trek for the back-to-back, Belgium-Netherlands-Italy races that took place in August and September last year.
Sissing says: "We learned that we can reduce our emissions by approximately 70 per cent, compared to a regular diesel truck. The technology is fully functional and viable on long distances, but the challenge is that the fastest route did not have sufficient gas stations providing biofuel options."
For future races, F1 will also be measuring event waste reuse and recycling, as well as studying data on how fans get to the race, whether by public transport, bicycle or electric vehicles.
"While this may be harder for developing nations, F1 has stated a goal to only host at circuits that promote well-being and biodiversity and present a 'balanced scorecard' for their local communities," Walton adds.
Auditing the Singapore Grand Prix
Closer to home, race promoter Singapore GP (SGP), the Singapore Tourism Board (STB) and F1 are putting sustainability high on the agenda for upcoming races.
A spokesperson for SGP says: "A full sustainability audit will be undertaken for the Singapore Grand Prix 2022 and provide a baseline which will guide the development of other green initiatives that will be implemented for the rest of the new term."
SGP will appoint an accredited body to conduct the audit soon, and plans to work towards achieving sustainability certifications as well.
According to Deloitte's Walton, a sustainability audit could set key performance indicators (KPIs) such as emission data; use, reuse and recycling of materials; energy and water efficiency; as well as health and safety data.
And releasing the assurance statement together with a sustainability report would boost "public confidence in the sustainability performance of the Singapore Grand Prix", he reckons.
In January, the government and SGP announced that the Singapore Grand Prix is on track to return this year (Sep 30-Oct 2) after Covid scuppered plans to host the last 2 editions in 2020 and 2021. This time round, Singapore has committed to a longer-than-usual running contract of 7 years.
Keith Tan, chief executive of the STB, says: "The 7-year extension gives us a longer runway to capture pent-up demand as leisure travel recovers and gives us the opportunity to test-bed innovative ideas and concepts to further differentiate the Singapore race."
Pointing out that the F1 night race has generated "significant economic benefits and global branding value" for Singapore, Tan emphasises that the STB is confident that these benefits can be sustained for the longer term.
The Singapore Grand Prix has generated over S$1.5 billion in incremental tourism receipts and attracted over 550,000 unique international visitors since its debut. Past editions of the race have cost some S$135 million annually to host, with the government funding 60 per cent of the expenses, and SGP - backed by hotelier Ong Beng Seng - the rest.
Still, with the pandemic in its third year, safe management measures will have to be put in place to ensure the safety of spectators and employees, which suggests there could be fewer spectators vis-a-vis past editions.
The STB will be working together with the race promoter and the Ministry of Health to ascertain the "most appropriate safe management measures". It also remains to be seen how many tourists will fly in for the street race this year. Some 268,000 spectators attended the last race in 2019, of whom over 40 per cent were from overseas.
The Singapore race's most unique selling point is arguably that it takes place at night, with floodlights specially crafted by an Italian company to illuminate the 5.063 km-circuit uniformly as drivers whizz around the street circuit with the Singapore skyline as a glittering backdrop.
At 4 times brighter than your typical sports stadium, there are 2 chief considerations when it comes to lighting: the safety of drivers and marshals as well as meeting high definition television broadcast standards as the race is beamed around the world to F1 fans.
For the 2023 Singapore Grand Prix, the race promoter will replace the existing track lighting with more energy-efficient LED lights. Other initiatives include reducing carbon emissions by minimising the use of diesel generators in favour of bio-fuels, and opting for electric and/or hybrid support vehicles, where possible, as well as switching over to cleaner energy sources to power certain amenities within the Circuit Park.
SGP has also earmarked ways to boost recycling efforts and use more sustainable materials, such as reducing the use of single-use plastics and food packaging. And from 2024, its corporate hospitality suites, which offer the well-heeled a glitzier experience complete with artisanal meals, will scale up the use of food digesters to convert food waste into organic compost.
The cost barrier
But will F1's efforts to go green invariably end up tacking on costs for teams and venues alike?
Walton expects costs to go up in the short run as investments are made towards new innovations and technologies - which admittedly may or may not pay off - although costs could come down in the long run.
He says: "In the longer term, the hope is that these innovations will in turn lead to further efficiencies and savings. For example, it will take time and money to develop new engine technologies or new fuels; but if it results in a more efficient fuel usage, this could ultimately save money."
Patel says: "The push towards synthetic fuels and higher electrification of high-power hybrid engines will have a ripple effect across the automotive and transportation industry, as they can significantly contribute to a reduction of emissions from ICE engines."
In this respect, F1 - perhaps unlike other sports - is in pole position to help the world tackle the climate crisis, Patel adds.
TRENDING NOW
Higher rates, weaker spending: Is the Philippines entering stagflation?
Singapore’s deep-tech startups tap China for scale, set sights on the US for higher margins
Who are some of the longest-serving CEOs among Singapore’s blue-chip companies?
Grit built in the genes: Malaysia’s Lee Yeow Seng drives IOI’s bold Singapore push