Why your credit score matters
Do you know your credit score? There is no question that financial literacy – for personal budgeting and investing responsibly – is crucial, especially as fears of a recession mount. But what about credit literacy?
AFTER nearly five years of renting, Samuel Low was excited to finally leave the rental game and own a home with his wife. They had been saving up for a Housing and Development Board (HDB) resale flat, and were certain the process would be fairly smooth-sailing.
That was until they discovered that the home loan they were given was much lower than anticipated. An appeal was filed, but the couple encountered another roadblock: since Low did not own a credit card – he thought it was a “financially prudent” way of limiting his spending – he had no credit history, making it difficult for banks to assess his creditworthiness.
The appeal eventually went through, with the bank using other factors to determine whether the couple’s home loan could be increased, but the 30-year-old believes the process took a longer time because of it. “We thought we would not be able to get the loan,” he adds.
Low is not alone. Like him, many working adults in Singapore are completely unaware of their credit score – or what a credit score even is – until it is time to apply for a mortgage.
The good news is that credit scores in the city-state have remained stable in the past five years, with experts noticing fairly healthy credit behaviour among consumers.
An informal online poll of working adults in Singapore aged 21 and up, conducted by The Business Times (BT), found that of the 58 respondents who owned credit cards, most (82.8 per cent) did not know their credit scores. Some 12 per cent of them also did not think credit scores were important at all.
Meanwhile, of the 16 respondents who did not own a credit card, a majority at 68.8 per cent thought credit scores were only somewhat important.
During the polling process, some respondents had asked what a credit score was and how they could check for theirs. A few believed that credit scores were “only a thing” in countries such as the United States.
A credit score is a four-digit number in a person’s credit report that lenders use to judge the creditworthiness of borrowers. This is calculated by the Credit Bureau of Singapore (CBS) using past credit information to predict future payment performance.
Those scoring 1,000 have the highest likelihood of defaulting on a payment, while those scoring 2,000 have the lowest chance of reaching delinquency status. Some influencing factors include the amount of credit owed or used, the number of open or active accounts available for credit, credit account history, and number of credit enquiries, which show how hungry a person is for debt.
Generally, the higher your score, the better interest rate you will get when opening a credit card account or taking out a loan.
Under the Monetary Authority of Singapore’s guidelines on fit and proper criteria, employers carrying out any activity regulated by the MAS are also recommended to include credit report checks as part of their background screening process to assess pre-hires or existing candidates’ overall credit health and financial stability.
According to Lorna Tan, head of financial planning literacy at DBS Bank, this is done by some employers, particularly financial institutions. “As such, your credit reputation may influence the hirer’s decision to employ you,” she says.
Still, UOB’s head of group personal financial services, Jacquelyn Tan, points out that credit score, as a term, is “probably not unfamiliar to most” since there are regular talks, programmes and workshops on financial education and literacy. These programmes usually emphasise the importance of good credit behaviour, such as paying bills punctually and not overextending yourself when taking out loans, she says.
A spokesperson for CBS notes that consumers today are “a lot more knowledgeable” about their credit bureau reports and scores than before. Consumers are eligible to obtain a complimentary credit report from CBS within 30 calendar days of their credit application.
Figures from the bureau showed that an average of 34,793 consumers accessed their credit reports every month in the first half of 2023. This number was 31,092 in 2022 and 28,130 in 2021. In March 2016, the average was at around 11,000 a month.
Joseph Wong, OCBC managing director for consumer credit risk management, believes that this may be related to the recent increase in consumer spending as borders reopened post-pandemic.
CBS statistics show that the average credit score of consumers nationwide remained fairly consistent between 2018 and 2022, ranging from a risk grade of AA to BB.
An AA risk grade indicates the lowest risk of a consumer defaulting on a loan, with a probability of just 0.27 per cent or less. An HH risk grade shows the highest probability of default at 3.48 per cent or more. For BB risk grades, the probability of default is between 0.27 per cent and 0.67 per cent.
The biggest change was seen in older consumers, aged 50 and up, with their average monthly credit score growing by 5 points in those five years, albeit still remaining within the AA band – from a score of 1,915 to 1,920 for those aged 50 to 54, and from 1,922 to 1,927 for those aged 54 and up.
In the same period, consumers aged 30 to 34 saw their average monthly credit score rise from 1,897 to 1901; this was a slight increase of 1,902 to 1,904 for those aged 35 to 39. Both remained within the BB band.
For consumers aged 45 to 49, the average monthly credit score climbed from 1,913 to 1,917, within the AA band.
Meanwhile, the average monthly credit score of consumers aged 21 to 29 dipped from 1,874 to 1,871, within the BB band, and that of those aged 40 to 44 remained flat at 1910 in the BB band.
Consumers in older age groups generally have a higher credit score compared with those who are younger, likely because of a longer established credit history, CBS says.
Credit where credit is due
A DBS study on consumers’ financial health, published in July, finds that even though credit card usage increased in 2023, credit card debt still seems “manageable”, with most paying their bills on time to avoid high interest charges on credit card debt.
“We observe that the growth in revolving-balances (interest-bearing credit card balances) remains manageable at 3 per cent, which is well below that of non-revolving balances (non-interest-bearing credit card balances) at 23.6 per cent,” it says.
“Second, the proportion of revolving balances against total outstanding balance narrowed from 52.3 per cent in May 2022 to 47.4 per cent in May 2023, which implies a much lower and prudent use of interest-bearing balances over the year.”
DBS notes that those who may be more vulnerable to credit card stress are those earning S$2,500 to S$4,999 a month and Generation Z, aged 26 and below. Both groups saw sharp increases in their outstanding card and revolving balances, compared with those in other income brackets or age groups.
For instance, those earning S$2,500 to S$4,999 a month saw their revolving balance increase by 9.8 per cent year on year – more than three times the median year-on-year growth of 3 per cent.
The other groups presumably have more financial experience or capacity, based on age and income, says DBS. This is evidenced by Generation X customers, aged 43 to 58, and those earning more than S$7,500 a month, which saw milder increases in their outstanding balances.
The same study showed that the household balance sheet in Singapore has “generally” remained healthy. Data from the Department of Statistics (SingStat) shows that household liabilities-to-assets ratios as at the first quarter of this year were “healthy” at 0.12 times, below the historical average of 0.17 times, notes DBS.
This figure remained roughly the same at 0.118 in the second quarter of 2022, as household net worth grew and liabilities fell further.
“Our findings are consistent with Singstat’s data, wherein we have observed that the average DBS customer’s assets (savings, investments) and liabilities (credit cards, mortgages) remain healthy,” says the bank.
Some misconceptions
While knowledge on credit scores and healthy credit behaviour has grown in recent years, CBS highlights that there are still some common misconceptions among consumers.
First, some consumers assume that they can appeal to the bureau if they face rejections for their bank loan applications.
That is false, says CBS: “The (credit) report is only one of the factors used in the lender’s decision-making process. Lenders also take into consideration other factors, such as the consumer’s income and banking relationship, during their review of a consumer’s application for new credit facilities.”
Another misconception is that consumers can write in to the bureau to remove negative records from their credit report, it says. The credit report is based on information submitted by CBS members, which include banks such as DBS, OCBC and UOB.
“CBS will only be able to rectify the data in accordance with the instructions given by the respective member who contributed the data,” it says. “However, consumers who disagree with any data or discover facilities that they never applied for may approach CBS and its members to investigate and rectify erroneous records.”
There is no quick fix for a damaged credit reputation. That takes time, with responsible use of credit and consistent good repayment records, CBS says.
TRENDING NOW
Ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang carried a secret for more than a year. It led to his downfall
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Jensen Huang discusses comeback as Nvidia CEO with allies: report