HOCK LOCK SIEW

Potential CapitaLand-Mapletree merger must be examined through an ESG lens

If a deal were to happen, it could create one of Asia’s largest real estate companies

Summarise
Kenneth Lim
Published Wed, Nov 12, 2025 · 07:44 PM
阅读简体中文版 (beta)
    • One of the aspects of a business combination that will have to be ironed out is the different ways that each entity approaches ESG.
    • One of the aspects of a business combination that will have to be ironed out is the different ways that each entity approaches ESG. PHOTO: BT FILE

    [SINGAPORE] A possible merger between two Temasek-linked real estate groups might require harmonising of environmental, social and governance (ESG) goals if a deal were to materialise.

    CapitaLand Investment (CLI), in which Temasek holds a majority stake, and Mapletree Investments (MIPL), a wholly owned Temasek subsidiary, are considering a possible merger, Dow Jones reported last week, adding that the plans are preliminary.

    In a statement, CLI declined to comment on rumours or speculation as a matter of policy, and said that it regularly explores and evaluates various investment opportunities that align with its strategic objectives. MIPL did not comment.

    If a deal were to happen, it could create one of Asia’s largest real estate companies, with more than S$200 billion of assets under management. CLI is the bigger entity, with S$136 billion of real estate assets under management and S$117 billion of funds under management as at end-2024. MIPL’s total assets under management stood at S$80.3 billion as at end-March.

    No merger at that scale is ever simple or straightforward, but one of the aspects of a business combination that will have to be ironed out is the different ways that each entity approaches ESG.

    For a start, while both companies aim to achieve net-zero emissions by 2050, they have different interim targets, with CLI’s 2030 goals being more clearly communicated.

    For example, CLI aims to reduce Scope 1 and 2 emissions by 46 per cent from 2019 levels by 2030. MIPL has a 2030 target of reducing landlord electricity consumption by 30 per cent from its FY2010 baseline, but only for its Singapore Commercial portfolio. MIPL’s sustainability disclosures mention 2030 targets for its China, India and US assets, but not the amount of reduction that it is aiming for.

    However, one of MIPL’s climate targets is to reduce embodied carbon by 30 per cent from an unspecified baseline by 2030. CLI does not address embodied carbon in its climate goals.

    The different targets will have to be addressed in any major merger or acquisition between CLI and MIPL, because both companies have sustainability-linked debt tied to those targets. Sustainability-linked structures vary the interest rate depending on the borrowers’ performance against sustainability targets.

    Because CLI and MIPL use different baseline years, merely imposing one entity’s targets onto the other might be challenging. For instance, MIPL might not even have 2019 emissions data for its portfolio, even though CLI’s targets are based on a 2019 baseline. MIPL’s embodied carbon baseline might not be applicable to CLI’s assets.

    As at end-2024, CLI had raised more than S$20.4 billion of sustainable finance since 2018, of which 57 per cent comprised sustainability-linked loans or bonds. Those borrowings are pegged variously to specific targets for reduction in carbon, energy and water intensities; performance ratings on global ESG indices; or minimum green building certification levels of their underlying portfolio.

    MIPL’s cumulative total green and sustainable financing secured was S$8 billion as at end-March 2025. It does not provide a breakdown of how much of that is sustainability-linked.

    The impact of the different targets goes beyond capital management, and could affect operations as well.

    One area is in the use of an internal carbon price. CLI applies an internal carbon price to its evaluations of new investments and capital expenditures, as well as a proprietary “return on sustainability” metric. The internal carbon price is based on the higher of the expected Singapore 2030 carbon tax or the relevant local carbon tax.

    MIPL does not formally apply carbon pricing in decision-making, although it incorporates local carbon taxes where available to assess climate risk. If MIPL were to adopt the same carbon pricing approach as CLI, that could affect its future decisions about investments.

    Both CLI and MIPL also incorporate ESG performance into remuneration for directors and executives, which could make it impractical to have different sets of ESG targets for different parts of a combined business.

    Boston Consulting Group (BCG) outlines three key ESG-related tasks in post-merger integration:

    • Mitigate ESG risks;
    • Integrate ESG practices and ensure continuity; and
    • Capture ESG opportunities.

    An important insight from BCG’s approach is that ESG integration can be a way to capture opportunities and strengthen ESG performance. For instance, MIPL has developed a methodology for modelling embodied carbon, which can benefit CLI.

    Done properly, post-merger ESG integration can be a net positive for both sides.

    This article first appeared in BT’s ESG Insights newsletter on Nov 7