MARK TO MARKET

Sabana saga: One key protagonist or another will soon end up embarrassed for being wrong

Many unitholders – even those inclined to get rid of the existing manager – may baulk at the risks of relying on the trustee to set up a new internal manager

Ben Paul
Published Mon, Aug 7, 2023 · 05:00 AM
    • Sabana Reit may garner a certain cachet if it were to successfully internalise its management function
    • Sabana Reit may garner a certain cachet if it were to successfully internalise its management function PHOTO: BT FILE

    THE extraordinary general meeting (EGM) today (Aug 7) to internalise the management function of Sabana Industrial Real Estate Investment Trust (Sabana Reit) may not immediately mark the conclusion of a story that has gripped investors in Singapore over the past two months.

    If the resolutions pass, Sabana Reit would be cast into uncharted territory as its trustee takes on the task of setting up an internal manager from scratch. The trustee has said this could take 12 months or longer, and that it expects to hold two or more additional EGMs to seek unitholder directions on specific matters.

    The fees, costs and expenses of engaging professional advisers to implement the internalisation will be reimbursed out of Sabana Reit’s assets.

    Sabana Reit’s existing manager – which is owned by Hong Kong-listed ESR Group – has said internalising the management function is an uncertain and potentially expensive process that could destroy value for unitholders. On top of that, Sabana Reit may end up in breach of its loan covenants.

    The manager has also raised the possibility of its staff abandoning their posts before the internalisation process is concluded.

    Quarz Capital, the activist investor that requisitioned the EGM, has been promoting a much more optimistic narrative. Last week, it said it believes “the entire internalisation process could potentially be streamlined to approximately six months”.

    Quarz has also rubbished concerns about Sabana Reit’s lenders demanding immediate repayment of their loans, and said that internalising the management function of Sabana Reit will ultimately improve returns for unitholders. More importantly, an internal manager would have no incentive to pursue acquisitions that are not value accretive to unitholders.

    Given the sharply different positions staked out by the key protagonists in this unfolding saga, one of them is going to suffer the embarrassment of being proven wrong in a very public way if the resolutions are passed at the EGM today.

    On the other hand, if the resolutions are not passed, the questions that have been raised by Quarz about the external-management model of Singapore-listed Reits will probably continue to echo in the market for some time. In particular, the question of what investors can do in practical terms to replace an external manager they no longer trust will remain unanswered.

    Proxy advisers’ views

    This column has previously said that Sabana Reit would garner a certain cachet if it were to successfully internalise its management function. In a market where every other Reit is externally managed, an internally managed Sabana Reit would stand out for offering possibly closer alignment of interests with investors.

    Yet, even unitholders of Sabana Reit who would like to be rid of the existing manager for attempting to push through a lopsided merger with ESR-Reit (now ESR-Logos Reit) in 2020 may baulk at the risks of relying on the trustee to set up a new internal manager.

    Proxy adviser Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) recommended last month that unitholders of Sabana Reit vote against the second resolution at today’s EGM – that is, the resolution to direct the Reit’s trustee to create a new internal manager.

    Besides noting the risks associated with setting up a new internal manager, ISS said Quarz has not explained how that internal manager would actually improve Sabana Reit’s performance and financial results. “The projections released by Quarz on the potential upside of the internalisation are generally based on the same strategy being implemented by (the existing manager),” ISS said in its report.

    Yet, ISS recommended that unitholders of Sabana Reit vote for the first resolution at the EGM – that is, the resolution to remove the existing manager. ISS justified its recommendation by pointing to the corporate governance issues Quarz had highlighted – such as the overlapping mandates of Sabana Reit and ESR-Logos Reit, and the recent appointment of a director despite strong resistance from minority unitholders.

    ISS also said Sabana Reit has fallen behind its peers in terms of performance and market valuation. It said that Sabana Reit’s revenue is up 11 per cent over the past five fiscal years, compared with a median increase of 85 per cent for its peers. Its net asset value (NAV) decreased by 1.5 per cent, versus a median increase of 25.5 per cent for its peers.

    “This poor performance is reflected in the discount to NAV, which would probably be worse if (its units were) not affected by the activist campaign and strategic investor purchases,” ISS said.

    Sabana Reit closed Friday (Aug 4) at S$0.405 – a 23.6 per cent discount to its NAV as at Jun 30 of S$0.53 per share.

    Glass Lewis, another proxy adviser, attributed Sabana Reit’s discount to NAV to its relatively small size, and pointed out that the Reit had actually delivered a higher total return than its peer average over the past one, two, three and five years (as at Jun 7).

    It also said Sabana Reit’s manager had provided detailed responses to Quarz’s concerns and made a “compelling case” that its proposals would not lead to a superior outcome for unitholders.

    Glass Lewis is recommending that unitholders vote against both resolutions at the EGM.

    Surprise twist?

    While a lot has been said about what Sabana Reit’s lenders may or may not do in the event unitholders pass the resolutions that Quarz has put forward, it might be more important to know what ESR Group plans to do.

    In a letter dated Jun 25, ESR Group said the value of its 20.6 per cent stake in Sabana Reit “far outweighs” the value of its investment in Sabana Reit’s manager. “There is no reason for ESR to prioritise and protect the value of our stake in the Sabana manager, at the expense of, or to the detriment of, Sabana Reit.”

    Responding to questions from the Securities Investors Association (Singapore), or Sias, on Aug 4, ESR Group said its interest in maintaining the external-management structure of Sabana Reit is simply because it believes the resolutions put forward by Quarz will lead to value destruction and a long period of uncertainty.

    It also said Sabana Reit’s existing external manager has delivered strong performance for unitholders and should not be replaced.

    However, Sabana Reit’s most recent annual report shows that it paid its sponsor group nearly S$7.3 million in fees in 2022. This was more than the S$6.9 million ESR Group would have received in distributions from Sabana Reit with respect to the 226.8 million units it owns.

    If unitholders of Sabana Reit vote to remove the manager, ESR Group would then plainly have no reason to protect or prioritise the value of its manager. And, if it genuinely believes the manager has delivered strong performance, it would arguably then have a strong incentive to offer it to Sabana Reit as a ready-made internal management platform for a nominal price.

    Quarz more or less suggested this when it responded on Aug 3 to questions from Sias. “If the current external manager is truly concerned about the interest of unitholders, it can recommend gifting (itself) to all unitholders once the external manager is removed,” it said.

    Of course, this surprise twist in the Sabana Reit story would be possible only if its unitholders take the very risky step of voting for change today.