MARK TO MARKET

SIA faces short-term pain of MCB redemptions, losses in India amid post-pandemic recovery

As demand and supply in the aviation sector normalise, SIA’s currently elevated profitability is likely to be eroded by competition

Ben Paul
Published Mon, Dec 12, 2022 · 05:50 AM
    • SIA said its quarterly revenue per available seat-kilometre hit a record high for the three months to Sep 30
    • SIA said its quarterly revenue per available seat-kilometre hit a record high for the three months to Sep 30 BT FILE

    CHRISTMAS has come early for shareholders of Singapore Airlines (SIA).

    Shares in the national carrier are up 12.7 per cent since the beginning of the year, well ahead of the Straits Times Index’s gain of 3.9 per cent. On top of that, shareholders on record as of today (Dec 12) will receive an interim dividend of 10 cents per share on Dec 22.

    China has also now abruptly shifted its stance on protecting its citizens from Covid-19, and appears to be preparing to roll back restrictions that prevented people from travelling freely. This might enable SIA to add back flight capacity at a quicker-than-expected pace, and maintain its currently elevated levels of profitability into next year.

    As it is, SIA seems well on its way to delivering a big turnaround for its financial year to Mar 30, 2023. For the six months to Sep 30, it reported a nearly 200 per cent jump in revenue to more than S$8.4 billion. Net profit for the six months came in at S$927 million compared with a loss of S$837 million for the same period last year.

    This was achieved by SIA carrying more passengers on more flights as Singapore fully reopened to vaccinated travellers in April and border restrictions around the world eased. Even as SIA’s capacity expanded 118.7 per cent, its passenger load factor rose 66.8 percentage points to 83.0 per cent.

    The carrier’s passengers were also evidently paying up for their tickets. SIA achieved record operating profit for the six-month and three-month periods to Sep 30, even though its passenger capacity was averaging 68 per cent of pre-pandemic levels during the three months to Sep 30.

    The group said its quarterly revenue per available seat-kilometre hit the highest level in its history during the three months to Sep 30.

    With this sharp improvement in its fortunes, SIA has now begun redeeming the mandatory convertible bonds (MCBs) that were issued in 2020 and 2021 to sustain itself through the pandemic. On Oct 25, SIA said it would redeem the S$3.5 billion tranche of MCBs issued in 2020. The accreted principal value of S$3.9 billion was paid to holders of the MCBs on Dec 8.

    Looking into 2023 and beyond, investors should be wary of market sentiment towards SIA being clouded by expectations of further redemptions of its MCBs and other cash-draining initiatives.

    Redeeming its MCBs

    It is hard to overstate how crucial the MCBs were to sustaining SIA through the Covid crisis. These 10-year, zero-coupon instruments are treated as equity in SIA’s books but are mandatorily convertible into new shares only in June 2030.

    They are redeemable at the option of SIA, at prices calculated to deliver an annual yield-to-call of 4-6 per cent per annum.

    The S$9.7 billion worth of MCBs SIA issued during the pandemic, along with the S$5.3 billion it raised through the issue of new shares, made it one of the best capitalised airlines in the world during what has been perhaps the worst crisis ever for the aviation industry.

    SIA had shareholders’ equity of S$23.2 billion, as at Sep 30, and cash balances of S$17.5 billion versus total debt balances of S$15.8 billion. It also had access to S$2.2 billion of committed lines of credit, all of which were undrawn.

    As SIA now begins redeeming its MCBs, it is effectively shrinking its capital base even as the demand for air travel is surging. Yet, SIA should redeem its MCBs sooner rather than later.

    While the dilutive impact of the MCBs is still more than seven years away, the cost of redeeming these MCBs will rise over time. The yield they offer will step up from 4 per cent to 5 per cent after the 4th year, and up to 6 per cent after the 7th year.

    More importantly, SIA’s profitability is unlikely to remain as elevated as over the past six months. As demand and supply in the aviation sector normalises over time, profitability is likely to be constrained by competition.

    This column noted back in 2020 that SIA’s earnings amounted to less than 3.9 per cent of its revenue during the decade leading up to the pandemic. Over the same period, its annual return on equity averaged less than 4.6 per cent.

    Merger in India

    The poor investment fundamentals of airlines has not stopped SIA from investing in other players in the sector, though. Case in point: SIA teamed up with Tata Sons in 2013 to form a full-service carrier in India called Vistara.

    On Nov 29, SIA said Vistara will be merged with Air India. Under the terms of the deal, SIA will exchange its 49 per cent stake in Vistara plus 20.6 billion rupees (about S$360 million) for a 25.1 per cent stake in the enlarged Air India.

    SIA and Tata have also agreed to provide the enlarged Air India with additional capital injections to fund its growth. SIA said its share of these capital injections will be 50.2 billion rupees (about S$880 million).

    It said Tata completed the acquisition of Air India earlier this year, and expressed its desire to run its airline business “on a single platform”. SIA said it had two choices given its agreements with Tata in relation to Vistara – either join the merger or sell its stake in Vistara to Tata.

    What does all this mean for investors? Whatever the strategic benefits of the merger, both Air India and Vistara are in the red. In fact, the value of Vistara had been written down to zero in SIA’s books.

    Analysts are expecting SIA to book a one-time accounting gain of S$1.1 billion when the merger of Vistara and Air India takes place in FY2024. But they expect SIA’s recurring earnings to be weighed down in FY2024 and FY2025 by its share of the enlarged Air India’s losses.

    This doesn’t mean there is no upside to the merger for investors. On the contrary, the deal could hold long-term advantages for shareholders of SIA.

    The enlarged Air India would have a much stronger market presence than Vistara, and would probably be better positioned to cope with competition. In addition, Air India has slots and air traffic rights at domestic and international airports that are not available to Vistara.

    SIA also pointed out that Air India is the only airline group in India with full-service and low-cost offerings. This will enable it to optimise its route network and resource allocation, capture demand across market segments, and tap a larger base of customers to boost its loyalty programme.

    Yet, until Air India begins generating earnings and stops requiring infusions of cash from its owners, it seems unlikely to me that investors will give SIA much credit for its initiatives in India.

    If anything, the merger of Vistara and Air India, like SIA’s redemption of its MCBs, is likely to detract from excitement about the post-pandemic recovery in demand for air travel.