MARK TO MARKET

Time for OCBC to offload Great Eastern

The breathing room Great Eastern and OCBC now have to address the insurer’s free float stretches beyond the likely dates of their upcoming AGMs

Summarise
Ben Paul
Published Mon, Jan 27, 2025 · 05:00 AM
    • Great Eastern said that it has been granted yet another extension of time by SGX to comply with the minimum free float rule.
    • Great Eastern said that it has been granted yet another extension of time by SGX to comply with the minimum free float rule. PHOTO: BT FILE

    WHEN Great Eastern announced late last Friday (Jan 24) that it had been granted yet another extension of time by the Singapore Exchange (SGX) to comply with the minimum free float rule, one of my colleagues joked: “Maybe two years from now, we’ll still be doing this.”

    Great Eastern said in its announcement that it has been assessing various options to comply with the relevant listing rules, and that it now intends to appoint a financial adviser to explore “possible additional options”.

    The insurer went on to say that it applied to SGX for more time as its 2024 annual report is likely to be published towards the end of March, and the information it contains could be useful in assessing the available options to comply with the minimum free float rule, including approaching OCBC for assistance.

    The latest extension of time granted by SGX is for a period of four months, longer than the previous extensions of approximately three months. It expires on May 25 – about two weeks past the first anniversary of OCBC’s announcement of its offer for Great Eastern.

    More importantly perhaps, the breathing room that Great Eastern and OCBC now have stretches beyond the likely dates of their upcoming annual general meetings (AGMs). Under Section 175 of the Companies Act, public-listed companies are required to hold their AGMs within four months of the end of their financial year.

    This could result in shareholders who attend those AGMs not getting substantive answers to questions about OCBC’s ownership of Great Eastern, or how the insurer’s non-compliance with the minimum free float rule will be addressed.

    Great Eastern previously made two announcements about SGX granting it extensions of time to restore its public float – on Aug 2, 2024, and on Oct 21, 2024.

    On both occasions, it cited uncertainty about OCBC’s final shareholding as a reason for needing the extensions.

    OCBC was at the time allowing Great Eastern’s non-assenting shareholders the opportunity to exercise their right under Section 215(3) of the Companies Act, which required the banking group to acquire their shares within three months at the same offer price.

    OCBC unveiled an offer on May 10, 2024, for the 11.56 per cent of Great Eastern it did not already own at S$25.60 per share. When the offer closed on Jul 12, 2024, OCBC’s stake in its insurance arm had risen from 88.44 per cent to 93.32 per cent.

    The Section 215(3) effort did little to further expand OCBC’s interest in Great Eastern, though. On Nov 8 last year, the banking group said it held 93.72 per cent of Great Eastern’s shares.

    Will SGX grant Great Eastern more extensions of time to restore its free float in the months ahead? Or will this matter be quickly resolved? What should investors do?

    Another offer?

    On the face of it, OCBC does not appear to have given up on the idea of fully acquiring Great Eastern in order to resolve the insurer’s free float problem.

    Bloomberg reported last week that the banking group’s chief executive Helen Wong recently met some of the insurer’s key minority shareholders, including Wong Hong Sun and representatives of Lee Thor Seng and his family.

    This has some market watchers speculating about whether another offer might be in the works, and what role these longstanding shareholders might play in such a deal.

    A fresh offer would naturally draw comparisons with last year’s deal, though. It might also invite some awkward questions about the manner in which the transaction was handled.

    Notably, there is the question of why OCBC decided to not revise its offer even after the independent financial adviser (IFA) appointed by Great Eastern determined that it was “not fair but reasonable”.

    Given that Great Eastern already had a very narrow free float, this meant there was a high chance its shares would be suspended from trading; and minority shareholders who did not accept the offer would be left in limbo – as is now the case.

    Under the circumstances, the only way the offer could have led to a clean delisting is if OCBC had obtained a high enough level of acceptances to be able to compulsorily acquire the insurer’s remaining shares.

    Yet, OCBC’s offer price of S$25.60 per share valued Great Eastern at a 30 per cent discount to its embedded value. OCBC’s previous offer for Great Eastern back in 2006 valued the insurer at a more than 50 per cent premium to its embedded value.

    Why did OCBC’s board think long-term investors such as Wong and Lee would be prepared to accept its offer last year after refusing a far superior offer in 2006? And, should Great Eastern’s board have recommended its shareholders accept an offer that was “not fair but reasonable”?

    The Financial Times reported earlier this month that UK activist investor Palliser Capital had complained to SGX and the Monetary Authority of Singapore that minority shareholders of Great Eastern had been treated unfairly by OCBC, and that Great Eastern’s board had been “highly complacent” in recommending the offer.

    Great Eastern seemed to obliquely refer to the FT and Bloomberg reports in its announcement last week. It noted that it had complied with the rules and regulations applicable to the offer, and that its independent directors had recommended that shareholders accept the offer on the advice of the IFA.

    The company also stated that its management regularly engages with analysts, fund managers and shareholders on material developments relating to its business and financial results. “However, the company will not comment on or discuss any price-sensitive matters outside the appropriate disclosure channels and/or manner of disclosure,” it added.

    Take a new approach

    The way I see it, OCBC did not offer to pay more for Great Eastern because it simply did not want to justify doing so to its own shareholders. The insurer’s shares were, after all, trading at very depressed levels before the offer.

    This does not mean that Great Eastern’s shares did not have the potential to garner a better market valuation under the right conditions. In fact, OCBC’s offer for Great Eastern last year came after a group of minority shareholders attempted to put forward three resolutions at the insurer’s AGM to address its weak share price.

    The leader of that group of investors, a former remisier named Ong Chin Woo, is now planning to table a resolution at OCBC’s upcoming AGM for the banking group to distribute all its shares in the insurer.

    The move – which would result in OCBC shareholders receiving approximately 98 Great Eastern shares for every 1,000 OCBC shares they own – would naturally resolve the insurer’s free float problem and potentially improve the market valuation of OCBC’s shares too.

    OCBC has already said it is not in favour of this proposal, and that having Great Eastern in its fold is integral to its overall strategy.

    Yet, it is not clear to me that shareholders of OCBC would be any worse off if Great Eastern were offloaded. Even with almost full ownership of the insurance unit, OCBC’s return on equity for the first nine months of 2024 came in at 14.4 per cent – not much better than UOB’s 13.9 per cent and well behind DBS’ 18.8 per cent.

    In any case, there is no reason OCBC could not maintain exclusive bancassurance ties with Great Eastern after distributing its stake in the insurer to its own shareholders.

    As Great Eastern works with its financial adviser to comply with the minimum free float requirement, perhaps the time has come for OCBC to take a different approach with its insurance unit.

    The writer owns shares in Great Eastern as well as OCBC