When governments intervene
INTERVENTIONS by governments are increasingly having an impact on businesses. Developing countries, including some in our region, are usually perceived as facing a higher risk of this. But now governments in the United States and other countries are acting with fewer constraints, and for new reasons.
The pandemic re-emphasised concerns about security and scarcity. Citizens expect governments to respond in times of real and urgent need. Moreover, slogans of narrow “me first” nationalism have been re-energised following Donald Trump’s presidency. National champions and state-owned enterprises can find favour to the detriment of others.
Every intervention may seem different in purpose. Yet they support a broader conclusion: officials around the world today are more ready to intervene in what was previously left to market competition. Why is this the case, and what can companies do?
Good reasons, mixed results
Often, good reasons are given for government intervention. Yet these can disguise unfairness and even mixed motives.
Consider the Biden administration’s ambitious push for climate action. As a key part of the wider Inflation Reduction Act passed last year, some US$369 billion will be provided to incentivise green efforts across economic sectors and across the different states.
Much of this is pro-American. Electric vehicles, for instance, only qualify if critical mineral and battery components are US-made. Exceptions are made for markets with which the US has free trade agreements.
The European Union is not one of these. Its leaders believe that the American tax and other measures create unfair market distortions. They have promised to respond with “action to rebalance the playing field”.
Of course, the US government is not the only one to intervene like this. Indonesia, for instance, is trying to leverage its rich deposits of nickel to ensure that companies manufacture batteries inside the country, rather than exporting the mineral elsewhere. This is not without reason, but is akin to what the Americans are doing.
China too has intervened in high-profile ways against some of the largest technology companies. While one might expect such actions by an officially Communist and state-centric system, past policies had given much leeway for the private sector to grow.
With China’s new cabinet to be appointed shortly, many will be watching for signals on how Beijing will govern the markets, going forward.
What can be done
Controversies over government interventions are not new. In the past, however, there could be reference to international rules and the World Trade Organization (WTO). The latter’s dispute settlement mechanism and Appellate Body, while not without flaws, could adjudicate between right and wrong and discipline government interventions.
No longer. Over the last few years, the US – despite opposition from most other governments – has actively undermined the WTO by blocking new appointments to replace retiring Appellate Body members. The system currently lacks finality and there is little recourse. Most just try not to cross the US or China.
Some companies lobby for exceptions and carve outs. For instance, in the American chip legislation, temporary exceptions have been given to a number of companies, including Samsung from South Korea and TSMC of Taiwan.
Another approach taken by some companies is to simply to avoid the interventionist country. But if the market potential is great or the country has essential resources, avoidance has a cost too.
Perhaps the essential response is to take a broader and further look ahead, to read the trends and anticipate possible shifts and emerging risks. This is especially when global conditions or governments change, ushering in new officials and possibly new policies.
In our region, more than a few key countries will see changes, with a new government in Malaysia and upcoming elections in Thailand, Taiwan and Indonesia. Changes of personnel in China and Vietnam also bear watching. These political changes can make a country more appealing and stable for foreign investors – or have the reverse effect.
Companies and investors will require greater awareness and new capabilities. Many are already putting a greater focus on government relations, to improve communication and interaction with regulators. Some companies also turn to external parties – advisory boards, political risk firms and think-tanks – to review wider trends and to help them think through their strategies.
Companies must help governments have the fullest appreciation of the policy impacts of their actions, and to balance between legitimate policy priorities and negative business impacts. To better advocate for their interests, rather than working alone, corporations would do well to develop links within their sector even with commercial competitors, and across their supply chains.
As more governments assert themselves more often, companies are waking up to how politics are having a direct impact on businesses. The best companies will look to develop new insights and capabilities to protect their interests and also as a competitive advantage.
The writer is chairman of the Singapore Institute of International Affairs (SIIA). This is an occasional SIIA column on The Politics that Matter to Business.
TRENDING NOW
Ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang carried a secret for more than a year. It led to his downfall
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Jensen Huang discusses comeback as Nvidia CEO with allies: report