Will stocks still deliver Magnificent returns?
One lesson from the Nifty Fifty is that growth stocks are often worth more than what Wall Street deems reasonable – if you have a long investment horizon
Ben Paul
THE most significant piece of news for many investors this past week was that inflation in the United States continued to ease in October.
The headlines triggered a plunge in US Treasury bond yields, a sell-off in the US dollar, and a nearly 2 per cent jump in the S&P 500 index on Tuesday (Nov 14).
We may have seen this movie before, though. The market has been underestimating the strength of the US economy as well as the US Federal Reserve’s resolve to bring inflation back down to 2 per cent over the last two years.
Even after sliding down to 4.4 per cent at the end of last week – from a peak of 5 per cent only a few weeks ago – 10-year US Treasury bond yields are still at levels not seen since 2007, before the onset of the global financial crisis.
Some market watchers have also pointed out that the recovery in US stocks over the past year has been driven by a narrow group of very large technology-oriented stocks – the so-called Magnificent Seven, comprising Alphabet, Amazon, Apple, Meta Platforms, Microsoft, Nvidia and Tesla.
These seven stocks have a combined market capitalisation of nearly US$11.8 trillion, and now account for about 28 per cent of the S&P 500 Index. With seemingly unshakeable confidence in their ability to deliver strong earnings for years to come, these mega-cap stocks have risen by an average of 104.6 per cent this year.
The S&P 500 index is up 17.6 per cent this year. The S&P 500 Equal Weight Index – which ameliorates the impact of the mega-cap stocks – is up only 2.7 per cent this year.
After their strong run, some of these heavyweight stocks are now vulnerable to any hint of bad news. For instance, Alphabet suffered a sell-off last month after reporting earnings that missed expectations.
Tesla also took a beating after an earnings miss last month, and concerns raised by its management about the possible effect of high interest rates on car sales in the months ahead.
On the other hand, Microsoft reported earnings that topped estimates; and its rising stock has helped keep the faith in the capacity of the Magnificent Seven to continue driving the market higher.
My own view is that investors ought to tread carefully over the next few months – despite the progress that has been made curbing inflation. While stocks may well end the year on a strong note, there could be more attractive buying opportunities for investors in 2024.
Easing inflation, softening growth
The US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) said last week that the headline consumer price index (CPI) for October was up 3.2 per cent over the preceding 12 months. This marked a significant improvement from the corresponding increases for September and August of 3.7 per cent.
One reason for subdued US inflation in October was that the volatile energy component of the CPI fell 2.5 per cent against the previous month, after rising 1.5 per cent in September and 5.6 per cent in August.
Headline CPI was unchanged in October, on a month-on-month basis, after rising 0.4 per cent in September and 0.6 per cent in August.
Core CPI inflation in the US also appears to be moderating. The all-items-less-food-and-energy index for October was up 4 per cent over the preceding 12 months, lower than the corresponding increase of 4.1 per cent in September and 4.3 per cent in August.
While these inflation numbers suggest that the Fed has hiked rates sufficiently, maintaining this tight monetary stance to reduce inflation to 2 per cent might result in slower economic activity and weaker corporate earnings in the months ahead.
This already appears to be happening. The BLS said on Nov 3 that total non-farm payroll employment increased by 150,000 in October – below the average monthly gain of 258,000 over the prior 12 months.
The rate of unemployment in October ticked up to 3.9 per cent, from 3.8 per cent in the preceding two months.
US unemployment was as low as 3.4 per cent earlier this year – a level that reportedly had not been seen since 1969.
Nifty Fifty redux
Some market watchers have likened the current market environment to the late 1960s and early 1970s – when investors were enamoured by the so-called Nifty Fifty group of stocks.
Much like the Magnificent Seven of today, the Nifty Fifty were large-capitalisation, growth-oriented companies that inspired great confidence among investors. They were sometimes described as “one-decision” stocks, because investors had only to decide to buy them and never sell.
Not surprisingly, these stocks traded at relatively high valuations. Even less surprisingly, these stocks suffered a nasty sell-off during the recession and bear market of 1973-74.
To be clear, I am not suggesting that the US is headed for a recession or that the Magnificent Seven are overvalued, but that investors should be prepared to weather a period of volatility ahead.
In fact, one study by Wharton School professor Jeremy Siegel in 1998 found that an equal-weighted portfolio of Nifty Fifty stocks purchased in December 1972 would have chalked up an annualised return of 12.5 per cent over the 25 years that followed. This was not much lower than the broader S&P 500’s annualised return of 12.7 per cent during the same period.
This was despite the Nifty Fifty trading at an average price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of 41.9 times in 1972, versus the S&P 500’s 18.9 times.
There were pockets of overvaluation within the Nifty Fifty group, of course. Siegel found that the 25 stocks with the highest P/E ratios in 1972 yielded only about half the subsequent returns of the 25 stocks with the lowest P/E ratios.
Specifically, stocks such as IBM, Xerox and Polaroid were overvalued in 1972, but stocks such as Coca-Cola, PepsiCo and Philip Morris were undervalued.
The conclusions Siegel drew from his study were that good growth stocks are often worth more than what Wall Street considers to be a “reasonable” price.
Yet, investors should not lose sight of the fact that high valuations offset future returns.
Most importantly, investors should be diversified. “No one stock or single industry is guaranteed to succeed,” Siegel said in his 1998 study.
As an ageing investor without the luxury of a 25-year horizon, I am inclined to emphasise Siegel’s warning about not paying too much. Now that it is possible to earn more than 3 per cent a year simply holding cash, I would need to be very certain of a magnificent return before jumping into the market.