Working out a solution: Pros and cons of an out-of-court workout 

    • For businesses facing financial distress, an out-of-court workout offers a restructuring option that is confidential, flexible and minimises disruption.
    • For businesses facing financial distress, an out-of-court workout offers a restructuring option that is confidential, flexible and minimises disruption. PHOTO: GIN TAY, ST
    Published Fri, Jun 2, 2023 · 05:50 AM

    A BUSINESS facing financial distress has several options – liquidate, commence insolvency proceedings, or undergo a form of judicial reorganisation to either exit the market or attempt to revive its fortune. These are formal processes that involve the courts in some way or another.

    Those who prefer a private agreement between parties can opt for a process known as an out-of-court workout. This is essentially a private process in which a debtor and its creditors reach – or as the name suggests, work out – an agreement that reduces the debtor’s debt burden and allows it to continue operating.

    The courts may still be involved in some kinds of workouts (that is, hybrid workouts), but this article will focus on agreements reached without any judicial interventions.

    A workout brings with it several advantages that make it attractive to businesses that need to restructure.

    First, it is flexible. There is generally no particular statutory requirement, procedural rule or time limit imposed on the debtor and its creditors during workout negotiations. But exceptions do exist. For example, in Japan, certain quasi-rules apply to workouts too.

    Second, it is confidential. A workout is a private process during which parties are effectively negotiating contractual terms. As such, they are generally spared the unfavourable publicity, media attention and public perception that some types of judicial reorganisation, such as judicial management, tend to attract.

    Third, it minimises business disruption and is more likely to offer a better return for both the debtor and its creditors. The general absence of statutory confinements on a workout means that the debtor and its creditors face less time pressure in terms of court deadlines and are free to tailor the terms of the workout agreement to their specific needs.

    For example, the needs of a debtor who operates several manufacturing plants will be very different from a debtor whose core business is to provide professional services. Further, the cost of a workout is also usually lower because of the lack of statutory requirements and formalities.

    Workouts not failproof

    Given these benefits that a workout seems to bring, why don’t all businesses that struggle financially turn to the process? Instead, news of judicial reorganisations or outright liquidations of companies still make news headlines. This is because workouts are not for everyone, and they do sometimes fail.

    A critically important foundation for any workout is that the debtor must have a viable underlying business that can be rescued. For example, if the debtor is primarily engaged in the manufacturing of typewriters which are rarely in use today, a workout will not be the suitable path to take. This is because, among other things, support from creditors is unlikely to be obtained. A doomed workout will render the entire process expensive and pointless.

    Even where a workout is the best course of action, there is no guarantee that an agreement can be reached during the process, or that the agreement reached will be successfully implemented. Unlike other forms of restructuring with a legislative bite, a workout requires unanimity or near-unanimity among participating creditors to reach any agreement.

    The diverse expectations or interests of creditors pose a challenge in canvassing such consensus. There needs to be only a single creditor who is unwilling to accept the proposed agreement in the workout to derail the whole process, usually known as the “hold-out creditor” or “hold-out problem”.

    Further, since not all creditors are compelled to participate in a workout, the non-participating ones are not bound by any agreement reached during that process, and may decide to destabilise the agreement reached (or even the negotiations) by taking or threatening to take separate enforcement actions.

    Maximise the chance of success

    So how can parties maximise the chance for a workout to succeed, so that an agreement can be reached during the workout and subsequently fully executed?

    As a first step, it is crucial for the debtor to alert creditors to the difficulties it is facing early. The debtor should provide full, honest and accurate information concerning its affairs to creditors, which may be particularly challenging in Asia due to the fear of “losing face”.

    However, early, transparent and honest identification and communication of financial distress, among others, serve to retain the confidence of creditors and other stakeholders in the debtor. Likewise, transparent reporting by the debtor during a workout helps to keep the line of communication smooth with creditors and other stakeholders, which can help to alleviate the hold-out problem mentioned above.

    Creditors should also show an initial attitude of support if the debtor’s woes stand a chance of being worked out. For example, if the debtor has a salvageable underlying business, its creditors should agree to a standstill and refrain from taking any unilateral action during the standstill period.

    These are some examples of the principles and practice tips enunciated in a free guide on how to conduct an out-of-court workout in Asia, recently published by the Asian Business Law Institute and the International Insolvency Institute. The guide aims to provide businesses that may need to conduct a workout with granular, practical and hands-on guidance on how to traverse the workout process to reach the optimal outcome for debtors and creditors alike.

    While a workout is not a one-size-fits-all approach, it is often the lowest-cost and least intrusive option if the debtor detects signs of financial trouble and engages with creditors early. Together with other available restructuring tools, workouts continue to be an important lifeboat to businesses in today’s climate.

    The writer is a senior manager at the Asian Business Law Institute, which studies the corporate restructuring landscape in Asia.