THE BROAD VIEW

Workplace mental health and psychological safety

    • Is there an environment of “trust” and “psychological safety” for employees to share, speak candidly and openly about their mental health struggles with their managers and bosses?
    • Is there an environment of “trust” and “psychological safety” for employees to share, speak candidly and openly about their mental health struggles with their managers and bosses? ILLUSTRATION: PIXABAY
    Published Sat, Oct 14, 2023 · 05:00 AM

    IN 2022, the European Union agency for occupational safety and health (EU-OSHA) conducted its Flash Eurobarometer – OSH Pulse survey, interviewing over 27,000 employed workers across all EU member states and two non-EU nations, Iceland and Norway. The focus was on the mental and physical health stressors workers face at their workplace.

    More than four out of ten workers surveyed said their work stress has increased because of the pandemic, contributing negatively to occupational safety and health in post-pandemic workplaces.

    Interestingly, the survey also revealed that talking about mental health in the workplace is no longer a taboo.

    About half of the workers interviewed said the pandemic has made it easier to talk about mental health at work. But not all of them feel comfortable talking about how they feel on a personal level. While 59 per cent said they were not uneasy about speaking to their manager or supervisor about their mental health, 50 per cent worry that disclosing a mental health condition could have a negative impact on their career. This latter statistic points to the lack of an environment of psychological safety in the workplace.

    Closer to home, a recent survey conducted by mental health organisation Calm Collective Asia and South-east Asia consumer research firm Milieu Insight found that 45 per cent of employees in South-east Asia felt that psychological safety is poor or does not exist at their workplace.

    The Mental Health at The Workplace study sought to understand the mental health needs of employees in South-east Asia. Across the region, four in 10 respondents indicated that they were not comfortable sharing their mental health challenges with their managers. For Singapore-based employees, the number was higher – more than six in 10 reflected this sentiment, making them the least comfortable about being open about mental health challenges with their managers across the region.

    Reservations about sharing one’s mental health challenges with superiors include a “fear of being judged or discriminated against” (37 per cent), being perceived as “weak/unproductive/lazy” (36 per cent) and “concerns over confidentiality” (30 per cent).

    Country and corporate perspectives

    Mental health at the workplace is foundational to everything a business does. In determining the appropriate approach, it is instructive for businesses to look at what governments are doing, as that reflects what is clearly on the mind of the larger society. Taking governments’ lead help businesses answer questions about what their executive teams and boards should be thinking about concerning this topic. Put simply, the issue of mental health at the workplace ultimately impacts a key asset of an organisation – its human talent.

    Singapore launched last Thursday (Oct 5) a National Mental Health and Well-Being Strategy, led by an interagency taskforce. A key tenet of the Singapore healthcare system is to recognise that physical, emotional and mental health are mutually reinforcing, and one cannot do without the other, the government said.

    The Strategy outlines the country’s approach where individuals with mental health needs can seek help early without stigma and will receive help readily for their recovery. From this, one can make the case that corporates and business leaders in the workplace also have a key role to play.

    Psychological safety – What can businesses do?

    There is a myriad of practical steps that organisations can take to promote mental health. These can range from focusing on prevention and early intervention, to promoting individual and collective thriving, and tapping into the knowledge base of the people in one’s corporation. That will support the creation of a competitive advantage for one’s organisation by ensuring that employees are in the best frame of mind to contribute fully at the workplace.

    The thrust of this article is not to list the dos and don’ts for improving mental health in a company – from avoiding late-night e-mails and limiting working on weekends, to having an empty inbox and “lightning-quick” response times.

    Rather, the intention is more provocative.

    What responsibilities do leaders at the workplace have in designing and formulating appropriate mental health support system in an organisation to provide the needed psychological safety for employees to talk about their mental health challenges with their managers?

    We know that the experience (positive or negative) of many in the workplace is based on their interaction and relationship with their immediate manager or supervisor.

    Essentially, how is that relationship playing out daily? Is there an environment of “trust” and “psychological safety” for employees to share, speak candidly and openly about their mental health struggles with their managers and bosses? Or is there a wall that separates one’s mental health (which is highly personal and should never be shared in the workplace) from one’s work performance and abilities? Does mixing the two result in a potentially career-limiting “cocktail” that could come up at some point, when a bigger job or promotion opportunity arises?

    To cite an example – a new work rhythm has been introduced post-Covid, whether at home or in returning to the workplace. People are also adjusting to changes outside of work such as different childcare arrangements and homeschooling. If someone needs time off work to attend to a personal matter, the ability to raise this with one’s manager, as well as the manager’s response, would be a key indicator of an organisation’s culture.

    A friend in the US related her return-to-work experience: She had a panic attack on a flight while travelling for work. It was one of her first trips after a long pause due to the pandemic. She had another trip coming up in just a few days. In contemplating the upcoming trip, she felt like she was facing an impossible dilemma: Should she prioritise her mental health or her job? For context, my friend works for a non-profit dedicated to reducing stigma around mental health, especially in the workplace. One would have thought that such an issue would not exist for employees such as my friend, but it did.

    As she tried to sort through her options, she started to second-guess herself, thinking: “I can totally power through this, it’s just one more trip”. It wrestling with this, it became clear that she had to take a step back, prioritise her mental health, and advocate for herself. She mustered up the confidence and courage to call her manager. And thankfully, she was met with complete understanding – it was without a doubt the right decision, and she felt supported then and in the weeks that followed.

    My friend was blessed to have been able to have an open and vulnerable discussion with her boss and to find such empathy and connection. Probably the nature of the organisation she worked for helped. However, the doubts she felt made her realise how difficult and frightening these conversations can be for employees.

    The question of whether there is a sense of psychological safety to express one’s mental health challenges in the workplace is a very real one. It is probably true that psychological safety at work – to raise and discuss one’s mental health issues with one’s manager – is neither the default nor the norm at most workplaces.

    When it comes to normalising mental health conversations in the workplace, leadership needs to start at the top. Probably the single biggest influencer in the success of the mental well-being of a company is the level of engagement from senior leaders and managers.

    Tone from the top

    In the July 2023 issue of Australia’s Company Director magazine, an article headlined Crash and Burn touched on the mental and physical health of directors and chairs of Australian boards, and how this can have a wider application across organisations.

    Boards are usually composed of high-performing individuals who often “put on a game face” and are good at hiding their personal health conditions, often to their detriment.

    While boards have stated rules and terms of reference on issues such as conflicts of interest or financial disclosure requirements, when it comes to determining when and how to disclose information about a board member’s health, or to have a plan of action in place in the event of an emergency or diagnosis, it is not always clear-cut. This becomes even more challenging when it touches on a board member’s mental health.

    Issues surrounding the careful managing of privacy obligations of one’s mental health challenges (particularly at the board level) require a good measure of discretion and sensitivity, as highlighted by Sally Maitlis, professor of organisational behavior and leadership at the University of Oxford’s Said Business School.

    The magazine article also highlighted the story of Gerry Doyle, CEO of Tonkin Consulting, which is instructive.

    Doyle was first diagnosed with depression and anxiety at the age of 16. He has lived with chronic depression since, with ideas of suicide now and then, but did not share about his problems until he was in a very senior position, for fear of being judged.

    Doyle’s condition was well managed by maintaining a routine, taking medication, attending medical appointments, consciously connecting with a small group of friends and attending to his physical health.

    However, in 2015, his deteriorating mental health led to a two-week hospitalisation. It was then he discovered how strongly the stigma and a general lack of understanding of mental health conditions still persisted at the board level.

    Although Doyle received the all-clear from his psychiatrist to leave the hospital and take a few days of rest before returning to work, he received a formal letter from his board stating that he was not allowed to do so until the board spoke to his psychiatrist.

    Legally, it was not allowed to do so without his permission.

    Doyle wrote back to say that he would indeed be returning to work on the date he stated, and reminded the board that he had not provided permission for the board to discuss his condition with his doctor or anyone else.

    To the credit of Doyle’s current board chair and other directors, they have been understanding of his mental health challenges. Doyle recognises that his situation of relative psychological safety is not common in many workplaces.

    What’s next?

    Increasingly, many people accept that mental illness and challenges are prevalent in society. Nevertheless, it is a massive learning curve that businesses need to go through in terms of how to embrace someone (at the workplace) in a supportive way so that they can contribute to the fullest of their abilities.

    Both the stories above are from outside of Singapore. I am not aware of a local story that is like the two.

    However, I do know of a story about a good friend’s sister who was diagnosed with breast cancer, and needed a mastectomy. As a re-engaged contract teacher in her seventies, she resolved to confide her cancer surgery with her school principal (her manager). To further “leverage” the psychological safety, she arranged for the surgery to be done over the mid-year school break of four weeks – allowing her absence to not be noticed and return to school after the holidays (and surgery) to resume her teaching duties.

    I applaud the courage of my friend’s sister in sharing her physical health challenge with her principal. However, I wonder if this was applied to a mental health challenge, and whether the psychological safety net would still apply.

    Here’s a question for leaders of corporations: How can we build psychologically safe environments for our teams?

    I don’t have the answer, but my reflections on this topic have led me to consider a few key elements.

    Sharing about one’s mental health requires courage. But the truth is, the most courageous people I know qualify not because of what they do in public, but what they are able to endure and rise above in private. This is especially true of people who struggle every day with mental health illness and challenges.

    The details and daily drama of these struggles usually remain highly private and hidden from the public eye.

    So, the big question for leaders is: What can we do to design an environment for greater psychological safety in the workplace – where mental health issues and challenges can be shared openly (but confidentially) and supported without bias or prejudice?

    To answer it, we will need to work collaboratively and collectively to discover the path forward for an inclusive community.

    The writer is the group general counsel and chief sustainability officer of Jardine Cycle & Carriage, a member of the Jardine Matheson Group. He is also CEO of mental health charity Jardine Mindset and a member of the board advisory panel of mental health platform Talk Your Heart Out. He also serves on the boards of the Singapore International Chamber of Commerce, Mind Forward Alliance Singapore and the Global Guiding Council of One Mind At Work.