Midterm results and your portfolio

Published Mon, Nov 5, 2018 · 09:50 PM

CONCERNED about how the upcoming midterm elections in the United States will impact your investment portfolio?

MOST LIKELY: DEMOCRATS TAKE THE HOUSE

The most likely outcome is the Democrats will take control of the House of Representatives from the Republicans while the GOP retains the Senate.

This is in line with current market expectations: Prediction exchanges now price a 70 per cent likelihood of the Democrats winning the House and an 85 per cent likelihood that the Republicans will control the Senate.

History also supports this outcome, as the party with the presidency has historically lost seats during the midterm elections. This has occurred in 90 per cent of all midterms since the Civil War, with notable exceptions being 1998 (backlash to Bill Clinton's impeachment) and 2002 (reaction to 9/11).

One key implication of a divided Congress under this outcome is that the prospects of additional fiscal stimulus (including major infrastructure packages or Tax Reform 2.0), which already appear unlikely, will be further diminished. It will be difficult for both parties to compromise on major spending, and the Democrats will also be reluctant to boost the economy and consequently the Republicans' chances in the 2020 presidential election.

Because this outcome is widely anticipated and therefore largely priced into markets, we can expect market reactions to this result to be fairly neutral.

DARK HORSE OUTCOME OF GOP SWEEP

Given the populist under-currents in the US political backdrop, however, the dark horse outcome of a Republican sweep of Congress must not be ruled out. Memories of Donald Trump's historic 2016 win, which defied almost every forecasting model at that time, are still fresh in investors' minds.

A Republican-controlled Congress would translate to marginally higher chances for more fiscal stimulus versus the base case, and would drive the market to price incremental strength in the US economy. In this scenario, we could see knee-jerk reactions in terms of a stronger dollar and also a rise in long-term treasury yields in the aftermath of the result.

MARKETS TEND TO RISE AFTER MIDTERMS

Markets have historically suffered from higher volatility before the midterms as policy uncertainties weigh on investors.

After the midterm results, however, equities tend to rally; the median performance of the S&P 500 index in the fourth quarter of midterm election years is 8 per cent, which is significantly above the 4 per cent median in non-election years.

That said, it is more difficult to ascertain if the historical trend of a post-election rally would repeat this year. While we did see a dramatic market correction in October, it was largely attributed to concerns about rising rates and peak growth, rather than midterm elections jitters.

NO BALM FOR SINO-US TRADE WAR

Regardless of the outcome, we do not see these midterm elections being a positive catalyst for the US-Sino trade war. President Trump wields broad unilateral powers over trade, and his China trade agenda is one that enjoys rare bipartisan support. With this in mind, a weaker-than-expected showing in the US midterms would not dissuade the White House from its aggressive trade stance.

That said, while any positive breakthrough on Sino-US trade before the midterm was unlikely, as the Chinese would want to see how the US political dice falls, some engagement could begin again after the elections.

A Xi-Trump meeting is on the cards during the G20 meeting in late November, and there will be more opportunities for both superpowers to reassess their respective positions, especially for the Chinese whose macroeconomic outlook has further deteriorated in recent months with signs of consumption slowdown and investment sluggishness.

Mr Trump has also indicated he is open to a "great deal" with China, failing which he would impose tariffs on the remaining US$267 billion of Chinese imports. From the man who wrote The Art of the Deal: a classic carrot-and-stick setup for negotiation.