Couple caught in 99-1 property deal sue salesperson, PropNex unit, law firm for S$367,405

PropNex says it is in process of obtaining legal advice; board intends to ‘vigorously defend the suit’

Summarise
Chong Xin Wei
Published Mon, Feb 2, 2026 · 06:31 PM
阅读简体中文版 (beta)
    • In their statement of claim filed in late January, the couple alleged that the salesperson in late 2021 presented them a two-step 99-1 arrangement.
    • In their statement of claim filed in late January, the couple alleged that the salesperson in late 2021 presented them a two-step 99-1 arrangement. PHOTO: CMG

    [SINGAPORE] A PropNex subsidiary, along with its salesperson and a law firm, have been sued over a “99-1” property transaction, by a married couple who allege a breach of duty by the three parties.

    Among other things, the couple are claiming a sum of S$367,405, the amount in additional tax and surcharge that the authority had asked them to pay, for having avoided paying the relevant stamp duty for their purchase of a condominium unit.

    Singapore permanent residents (PRs) Patil Prafulla Vasudeo and his wife, Patil Chitra Prafulla, are represented by WongPartnership’s Gavin Neo. They have named PropNex Realty salesperson Chin Ming Min and Anthony Law Corporation as defendants in the lawsuit.

    In a bourse filing on Monday (Feb 2), PropNex said it is in the process of obtaining legal advice and will take all such steps to defend the claims. It also said the board intends to “vigorously defend the suit”.

    PropNex added that it does not expect the suit to materially impact its financial performance for the financial year ending Dec 31, 2026.

    The Business Times has reached out to Anthony Law Corporation for its comments.

    The three defendants have yet to file their defences as at Feb 2. They have until Feb 20 to do so.

    Claims

    The couple claim that Chin told them that 99-1 deals were legitimate and legal, and that Anthony Law Corporation, which handled the transaction, failed to inform them that the arrangement was unlawful or could be viewed as an illegal act of avoiding stamp duty.

    In their statement of claim filed in late January, the pair alleged that Chin in late 2021 presented them a two-step 99-1 arrangement when they were discussing the purchase of a residential property in Singapore.

    At that time, Patil Prafulla Vasudeo was already an owner of an apartment in another condo development.

    In 2022, Chin introduced and marketed the Peak Residences development – located along Thomson Road – to the couple and, upon their expression of interest in a flat, allegedly suggested that they use the two-step 99-1 arrangement to purchase the unit.

    Singapore PRs buying their second residential property at that time were required to pay an additional buyer’s stamp duty (ABSD) of 25 per cent, while the applicable ABSD for PRs buying their first home was 5 per cent.

    Chin allegedly suggested that Patil Chitra Prafulla first buy 100 per cent of the property and pay the applicable 5 per cent ABSD on the purchase price as it will be her first residential property.

    She was then to sell 1 per cent of the property to Patil Prafulla Vasudeo, so that they would be able to use their joint salaries to qualify for a higher loan amount.

    Under this arrangement, Patil Prafulla Vasudeo would pay 25 per cent ABSD on only 1 per cent of the purchase price, since it was his second residential property.

    If the unit had been bought in the couple’s names from the start, he would have had to pay the 25 per cent ABSD on the full price of the unit.

    The claimants alleged that Chin told them that the two-step 99-1 arrangement was a legal and legitimate way to reduce the ABSD payable.

    Persuaded by the agent’s representations, Patil Chitra Prafulla bought the S$1.3 million unit on Jun 24, 2022, and then sold a 1 per cent stake to her husband 13 days later.

    In April 2023 – about nine months after they bought the unit – the couple read in the news about the taxman probing this method of tax avoidance.

    They checked with Chin, who allegedly reassured them that the arrangement was legal and legitimate, had been used by her other clients, and would only be pursued by the authority in cases occurring after the news article was published.

    In January 2026 – more than three years after their purchase – they received a notice from the Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore (Iras) informing them that their property transaction was a case of the illegal avoidance of stamp duty.

    They owed the taxman S$367,405. The sum comprised the 25 per cent ABSD liability of S$312,100, less S$67,163 for the 5 per cent ABSD already paid by Patil Chitra Prafulla and the stamp duty paid by the couple under the second step, and a 50 per cent surcharge of S$122,468.

    The claimants said Chin owed them a duty to ensure the truth and accuracy of any representations she made to them.

    They also said PropNex owed them a duty to ensure that Chin was well-versed in the law as an agent, and would not make false and untrue representations.

    They added that it was the agency’s duty to provide ongoing training to update agents on relevant property market developments, and to implement proper systems and processes to supervise agents in the discharge of their duties.

    The agency is also liable for Chin’s misrepresentations as well, the claimants argued.

    Further to this, the couple argued that the law firm also had a duty to ensure that the manner of the transaction was not an illegal avoidance of stamp duty, and to advise them that the two-step 99-1 arrangement could be construed as such.

    In December 2025 – about a month before they were served with notice by Iras – the couple received an e-mail from Timothy Tan, a lawyer from Anthony Law Corporation.

    The e-mail highlighted the potential stamp duty implications.

    Attached to the e-mail was also an indemnity document, which acknowledged that the tax authorities have full authority to investigate the arrangement and assess any attempt to reduce or avoid stamp duties, and that the couple agreed to indemnify Anthony Law Corporation against any liabilities, duties or surcharges arising from the arrangement.

    The claimants argued that the law firm’s belated attempt to advise them that the two-step 99-1 arrangement might be considered an illegal stamp duty avoidance arrangement constitutes an admission or acknowledgement that it had failed to provide such advice in 2022, at the time of the property purchase.