OUTLOOK 2024

Muted outlook for Singapore consumer sector as inflation prompts belt-tightening

Increased outbound travel is also expected to divert some demand

Paige Lim

Paige Lim

Published Wed, Dec 20, 2023 · 05:00 AM
    • Consumer spending may grow more slowly in 2024 as post-Covid exuberance dies out.
    • Consumer spending may grow more slowly in 2024 as post-Covid exuberance dies out. PHOTO: YEN MENG JIIN, BT

    SINGAPORE’S consumer spending growth may stay slow in 2024 as inflationary pressures prompt belt-tightening. Some might also spend overseas instead, said economists and industry players.

    The increase in outbound travel could be partly offset by increased visitor arrivals, which may, however, be limited by the strength of the Singapore dollar.

    Mastercard Economics Institute, for instance, expects Singapore’s real consumer spending to grow 2.8 per cent in 2024, down from 3.5 per cent in 2023.

    The gloomy outlook for 2024 follows a weak 2023. Retail sales disappointed in the second half with sluggish growth – or worse. In October, retail sales contracted a marginal 0.1 per cent year on year, ending an eight-month streak of expansion.

    Maybank Securities’ economist Brian Lee expects better retail sales growth in 2024, compared with his 2023 full-year forecast of 2.5 per cent, as consumer sentiment improves in tandem with “cooling inflation and a resilient job market”.

    Yet, this improved rate is expected to be just 3 per cent – with demand dampened by continued high prices and outbound travel.

    More broadly, consumer spending growth may slow as post-Covid exuberance dies out. Spending on hospitality, dining and entertainment may see more moderate growth in 2024 “as pent-up revenge spending and travel cools off”, he added.

    DBS economist Chua Han Teng and DBS analyst Andy Sim expect Singapore’s nominal retail sales growth to “stay resilient” in 2024, with a rate similar to 2023, though they did not provide specific figures.

    As Singapore’s labour market continues to soften, the resulting slower wage growth may temper domestic discretionary spending, they said in a joint reply to queries.

    “Consumer demand and sentiment could be restrained by bumpy inflation,” they said, noting that inflation will rise in early 2024 after the goods and services tax (GST) is raised to 9 per cent from Jan 1.

    This is even as they expect full-year headline inflation to ease to 3.5 per cent in 2024, from 2023’s 4.7 per cent.

    The impending GST hike could cause discretionary purchases such as apparel, furniture and appliances to spike before the year’s end and then soften, they added. Higher-end goods such as watches and jewellery could see a similar trend, though with the slump mitigated by tourist arrivals.

    Cutting back

    Some consumer businesses expect a further slowdown. Singapore Retailers Association (SRA) treasurer Pang Fu Wei noted weaker discretionary spending in the last quarter of 2023.

    He sees this weakness extending into 2024, even as rising business costs erode profits. “We anticipate 2024 to be weaker than 2023,” said Pang, who is also the group managing director of retailer Mothercare.

    At bar and restaurant chain Harry’s International, overall covers – that is, diner numbers – in 2023 have been 11 per cent shy of pre-Covid levels, said chief executive Nasen Thiagarajan. “It remains a struggle to get back to pre-Covid covers.”

    Demand is also down from 2022, when most Covid-19 restrictions were lifted and sales soared on pent-up demand.

    The group’s average spend per cover slipped marginally to S$36 in 2023, from S$38 last year – an indication “more people are trying to save”, he said.

    “I believe 2024 will be the same, with any sign of recovery only coming in the third quarter.”

    Trixie Khong, owner of jewellery brand By Invite Only, has seen a shift in spending patterns since mid-2023. Rather than making impulse buys, customers are taking longer to decide on purchases, she said.

    Furniture brand Castlery’s co-founder Declan Ee expects slower sales growth of 10 to 15 per cent in 2024, given economic uncertainty. This is down from 2023’s 20-per-cent rate, boosted by the opening of its flagship store at Liat Towers.

    The high cost of living remains “a significant concern for many”, said Ee. “Consumers would be more discerning about purchasing big-ticket items such as furniture and may even postpone the upgrading of their home furnishings,” he said.

    With personal budgets going towards travel, consumers may delay spending on consumer durables, said Declan Ee, co-founder of furniture brand Castlery. PHOTO: BT FILE

    In 2024, spending on essential goods and daily necessities “will be the order of the day”, while “excesses are cautiously avoided”, said SRA’s executive director Rose Tong.

    Affordable house brands – from cleaning products to cooking ingredients – in supermarkets and convenience stores could appeal to shoppers more than pricier international brands, she added.

    Going abroad, coming in

    Meanwhile, residents who are willing to spend may be heading overseas instead. A stronger Singapore dollar is fuelling outbound travel and thus hurting domestic spending, said observers and players.

    Maybank Securities’ Lee said the currency advantage encourages households to spend a larger proportion of their budgets overseas, including in neighbouring countries.

    With personal budgets being diverted to travel, consumers may in turn delay spending on consumer durables, said Castlery’s Ee.

    Declines in domestic consumer spending could be mitigated by a continued recovery in inbound tourism. Analysts are hopeful for the return of Chinese visitors in particular, with a bilateral visa-free travel agreement to kick in early next year.

    DBS’ Chua and Sim expect inbound tourism to recover to pre-pandemic levels in 2024, supported by improving flight capacity and upcoming concerts.

    This “should spill over positively and buffer consumer spending”, they said. This may especially benefit restaurants, which otherwise face headwinds such as outbound travel and softer domestic demand.

    This October, overall visitor arrivals were at 74 per cent of the pre-pandemic 2019 level for that month.

    By Invite Only’s Khong hopes higher tourist numbers will make up for lower mall footfall as Singapore shoppers head abroad. She has seen higher spending by tourists at her brand’s Orchard-based stores this year, versus 2022.

    Still, the tourism recovery could be dulled by Singapore’s strong currency and rising costs. With the stronger Singapore dollar and impending GST hike, tourists could be drawn to lower-cost competitors in the region, said SRA’s Tong.

    “Singapore is losing her shine in attracting tourists with our cookie-cutter malls, and it is evident that we are out-pricing ourselves in hospitality and retail,” she said.

    “Local and foreign consumers alike are very much psychologically affected by the media’s constant mention of how expensive Singapore is getting. This really cautions spenders – even tourists – to think twice about making dispensable purchases.”

    Retail spending remains below pre-Covid levels, and Tong does not expect a full recovery in 2024.

    “The retail outlook for 2024 is still unstable,” she said, adding that SRA expects retail sales growth of 1 to 2 per cent growth.