Exodus of F&B tenants from National Gallery after leases not renewed in major museum refresh
Several restaurant owners say they were blindsided when they were told to leave after their tenancies expired
THREE-MICHELIN-STARRED Odette and heritage eatery National Kitchen by Violet Oon are the only restaurants that survived a major shake-up of food and beverage (F&B) tenants at the National Gallery Singapore, in which seven out of the nine restaurants and bars were told to leave after their leases expired last September.
After negotiating for extensions, the first to close were the one-Michelin-starred Art di Daniele Sperindio and Gemma Steakhouse. Both were operated by Italian chef Daniele Sperindio and shuttered in November.
In the last week, Chinese restaurant Yan and rooftop bar Smoke & Mirrors announced that they would close on Mar 15. The remaining eateries that are set to shut are Hachi Restaurant, Courtyard Cafe and The Great Mischief.
Several restaurant owners who spoke to The Business Times felt that they should have been consulted earlier about the National Gallery’s plans, and said they were blindsided when they were informed in April 2024 that their tenancies would not be renewed.
With their leases expiring in September, they were left with little time to plan their next move, especially since most of them were longstanding tenants. Some had been at the museum since its opening in 2015.
The restaurants reported that their businesses were stable and they had planned to stay on.
“We had stuck together through thick and thin during the Covid years and continued to invest in our operations,” said one operator. “If we had known that there were plans to revamp the museum, we would have left during the pandemic.”
A statement from the National Gallery said that the move was part of a “holistic refresh of our F&B offerings” after nearly a decade with the existing tenants. “Recognising the evolving preferences of our audiences, the Gallery aims to introduce a more diverse, inclusive, and sustainable mix of offerings that better reflect our role as a public museum.”
It added that the tenants were given notice of the refresh in line with industry norms, and they had been invited to submit proposals aligned with the plans. However, BT understands that the proposals submitted were either rejected or not considered.
Tenants also reported that they were not able to communicate with the management, except through an appointed real estate agent. Several of them have also reached out to the Fair Tenancy Industry Committee to “raise concerns about the negotiation process and the absence of good faith”, according to one tenant.
For now, only Hachi Restaurant has a solid plan for its future after it leaves the National Gallery on Apr 12.
Fabian Koh, managing director of Hachi Group, which also owns the Public Izakaya brands, said that the restaurant will move to the new Keppel South Central business centre in Tanjong Pagar in July.
As for Sperindio, he has shortlisted a location to reopen Art and a new bakery, targeted to open in the third quarter of this year. A spokesman for Smoke & Mirrors said that the group was actively exploring new locations for a future reopening.
The National Gallery noted that it “worked collaboratively with existing tenants to agree on exact transition dates, reviewing lease extensions where needed”. It added that the extensions ranged from six months to a year, unless the tenants decided to exit earlier.
Chris Lee, the museum’s assistant chief executive of operations, said: “We deeply appreciate the contributions of our existing tenants, who have played an integral role in shaping the Gallery’s museum experience thus far.”
He added that the refresh would make the museum more accessible to a wider audience, and reinforce its role as a node for Singapore and South-east Asian art history.
The National Gallery also said that it would announce its new tenants in the second quarter of 2025, with openings planned for the second half of the year onwards.