Singapore exports slide deepens in January; economists mixed on recovery

Elysia Tan

Elysia Tan

Published Fri, Feb 17, 2023 · 07:05 PM
    • Economists agree that the trade outlook remains cloudy for at least the first quarter of the year, weighed down by economic uncertainties and geopolitical tensions.
    • Economists agree that the trade outlook remains cloudy for at least the first quarter of the year, weighed down by economic uncertainties and geopolitical tensions. PHOTO: YEN MENG JIIN, BT

    AS SINGAPORE’S non-oil domestic exports (NODX) dropped 25 per cent in January, declining for the fourth consecutive month amid weak global demand, some economists say that the worst is over, while others believe the trade situation could deteriorate.

    January’s fall, deepening from December 2022’s 20.6 per cent decline on the year, marked the worst start to the year since January 2009 during the Global Financial Crisis period, OCBC chief economist Selena Ling said. It also outstripped the median 21.9 per cent decline forecast by economists in a Bloomberg poll.

    The plunge to just S$13.3 billion, the lowest NODX value since June 2019, also marked the worst pace of decline in a decade, said Maybank economists Chua Hak Bin and Lee Ju Ye. Still, the weakness is “consistent with performance in other export-oriented countries”, they added.

    In addition to high-base prints, the earlier Chinese New Year (CNY) timing this year (compared to early February in 2022) likely contributed to sharp contraction, economists noted. “January and February numbers combined would provide a more meaningful assessment of global demand and the impact from China’s reopening,” said the Maybank economists.

    Both electronics and non-electronics fared poorly last month. Other than a strong rebound in pharmaceutical exports, January’s figures were “a sea of red”, said UOB senior economist Alvin Liew. Electronics exports in particular marked the sixth consecutive month of year-on-year contraction, with its nominal value falling below S$3 billion for the first time since March 2020.

    Oxford Economics senior Asia economist Alex Holmes said: “A turn in the semiconductor cycle continues to hurt exports. In January, the value of domestically produced chip exports fell further below their March 2020 pandemic low and to almost half of their recent peak in May 2022.”

    Of Singapore’s top 10 export markets, only the European Union (EU) and Japan reported growth in January. Shipments to China, in particular, hit a seven-year low in value terms despite the reopening, said the Maybank team, though they noted this is likely because of the early CNY timing in 2023.

    Economists agreed that the trade outlook remains cloudy for at least the first quarter of the year, weighed down by economic uncertainties and geopolitical tensions.

    Ling said: “Given that Q1 2023 demand and growth conditions are likely to remain soft, Singapore’s NODX prospects may remain soft in the next few months, until there are clearer signs of Chinese confidence and demand picking up more speed post-reopening.”

    However, they were divided over whether the contractions will worsen.

    UOB’s Liew expects year-on-year contractions up to April, with rough estimates projecting a 16 per cent loss in February NODX, which will worsen to shrink more than 20 per cent in March.

    According to Ling, January’s contraction is “likely the trough for the year”, partly due to the CNY period, with February and March likely seeing less severe double-digit contractions.

    Maybank’s Lee thinks that the worst year-on-year decline may be over in January, with the rest of H1 2023 seeing “a double-digit contraction in the teens”, as China and Hong Kong may help to fill gaps left by other major markets.

    Furthermore, RHB senior economist Barnabas Gan sees the monthly, seasonally-adjusted 0.9 per cent expansion in January’s NODX as a sign of recovering momentum.

    “On a momentum basis, NODX has troughed in Q4 2022,” he said. “Year-on-year numbers may still decline, but sequential growth may improve”, suggesting that “the worst may be over”, Gan noted, adding that the improving sequential growth reinforces RHB’s view for Singapore to avoid a technical recession in 2023.

    Brian Tan, senior economist at Barclays, however, was more cautious. The month’s rise is “almost completely due to a jump in usually volatile shipments of pharmaceuticals that offset the decline in the electronics segment”, he said, adding the NODX “would have been much worse” without the pharmaceuticals boost.

    “This segment is so volatile that we really can’t rule out a quick reversion in coming months that sinks NODX even deeper into negative territory,” he warned. “It’s probably too soon to say the worst is behind us.” 

    Meanwhile, Oxford Economics’ Holmes was more pessimistic: “Singapore’s external sector had another very tough month in January, and we doubt this marks the bottom.” He expects a global recession in the first half of the year, with further falls in demand. This is even as “downside risks to global growth have reduced recently, with the strong labour market in the US, the avoidance of a major energy crunch in Europe, and an earlier-than-expected reopening in China”.

    In contrast, Gan reiterated his belief that “market fears over a global recession are overdone”. “Rather than for us to adhere to ‘herding behaviour’, we expect the analyst community to gradually shift towards a more positive outlook for Singapore’s economy towards H2 2023,” he pointed out. “We noticed that this is already materialising: market risk appetite has shifted considerably since the year started, led by expectations for a slower pace of rate appreciation across both developed and developing economies and the recent reopening of China’s borders.”

    Ling added: “Fortunately, the US and EU have avoided a growth contraction in Q4 2022 and the recent signs appear to be pointing to a soft landing rather than a hard landing ahead.”