Platform workers caught between autonomy and security
Singapore
DISCUSSIONS about platform workers' protection have often centred around their ability to save for retirement, with contributions to the Central Provident Fund (CPF) seen as a key piece to the solution. On one hand, the government is concerned that workers need more job security and income protection. On the other, businesses argue that the increase in costs that this will impose on companies may impact the platform workers' income.
In Singapore, platforms are not required to make any contributions since the platform workers are considered self-employed.
While the private sector can offer some value to gig workers in retirement planning, the belief is that the government may have to step in for longevity and security through boom and bust years.
"That is something that I don't think any startup can provide or guarantee to be around for the next 15 to 30 years; the core facilitator of this has to be the government," said Amerson Lin, co-founder of platform worker insurance platform, Gigacover.
Surveys and studies of platform workers show contrasting views about CPF and retirement planning.
According to a study by the Institute of Policy Studies (IPS), 84 per cent of respondents were worried about whether they had enough retirement savings. Half of the respondents which were mostly private hire drivers, did not voluntarily contribute to their CPF, while 21 per cent contributed less than 5 per cent of their income. Only 6 per cent contributed 20 per cent or more of their income voluntarily. Inflexibility of the CPF was singled out as one of the key reasons.
Another study by Blackbox Research focusing on delivery riders showed that while 55 per cent of riders contribute to their CPF Medisave account, only 22 per cent of the remaining 45 per cent would do so if compelled to. Reasons for not contributing range from not having a fixed monthly income (64 per cent), not having as much savings to directly manage (46 per cent) and reduced disposable income (33 per cent).
The study goes as far as to say caution should be taken in implementing mandatory CPF contributions which would eliminate the benefits platform workers enjoy for heavy opportunity costs. These studies raise questions about how the current employment models should be viewed.
Traditional employment models have frameworks for full-time, part-time and freelance employment, with the requisite protections and benefits prescribed for each. Platform workers have had a somewhat paradoxical existence - they rely on a platform for work while at the same time are considered as the same employment class as a freelancer, with no boss to answer to.
There is another model emerging from neighbouring Malaysia with gig worker platform GoGet, which provides gig workers for a range of jobs from logistics, administration, operations, sales and household chores. GoGet recently announced an integration with Employee Provident Fund (EPF), Malaysia's CPF equivalent. This allows their platform workers to contribute a part of their net income to EPF, which GoGet will then match with incentives. This means if a GoGetter decides to contribute 5 per cent of their net income to EPF, GoGet will contribute 5 per cent of their incentives to EPF as well.
"If you want to be taken as a serious option in the labour market, we have to ensure that similar employment benefits that are given to a full-time worker, are also provided to a flexible worker on a flexible basis," said GoGet founder Francesca Chia.
This new model is about meeting the motivations of both the government in covering the platform workers, while giving the platform worker the autonomy to choose how much they want to contribute.
GoGet had about 1,000 platform workers opting-in just a day after announcing the integration on Mar 4, a 50 per cent adoption rate from about 2,000 GoGetters encountering the option on the app.
Platforms in Singapore said they are collaborating with the Advisory Committee on Platform Workers on measures to deal with the issue of retirement planning and adequacy, while maintaining the same flexibility and autonomy workers have today.
"Some considerations would include how this may affect the flexibility of gig workers' current work arrangements, the ability of platforms to invest in new earning opportunities for them, and any potential loss in demand for their services due to higher costs," said a Grab spokesperson.
Grab on its part has introduced a financial literacy programme for its platform workers to educate them on basic financial planning and retirement planning. The super-app has also been encouraging its platform workers to contribute to their Medisave accounts by matching contributions up to S$100 monthly.
Market players agree that there is no one-size-fits-all solution. Whether or not a new type of employment category is created or CPF contributions are mandated, balancing the equation between platform workers, consumers and merchants is one that policymakers will have to get right.
"Ultimately, the goal is to co-create sustainable solutions that can benefit gig workers but are sustainable for all aspects of the delivery ecosystem - including merchant partners and consumers - in the long run," said a foodpanda spokesperson.
TRENDING NOW
Motoring tycoon Peter Kwee is back in court: Here are his previous legal battles
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Beyond the greenback, Vietnam’s big borrowers turn to Asian-currency bonds
Nvidia’s outlook cut to stable by Moody’s on governance concerns