Singapore’s venture boom falters as industry ponders future

Claudia Chong
Published Thu, Mar 30, 2023 · 05:50 AM
    • A global slowdown has thwarted the venture industry's meteoric rise.
    • A global slowdown has thwarted the venture industry's meteoric rise. PHOTO: PIXABAY

    INCREASING market volatility has cast a chill over the once-booming venture capital (VC) industry in Singapore, with players bracing for more collapses and challenges in the year ahead.

    In a bid to pump the budding startup scene with much-needed capital, Singapore regulators in October 2017 significantly relaxed the regime to allow even those with no prior fund management experience to become venture capitalists.

    The change, along with tax policies and aggressive efforts to promote entrepreneurship, created a VC boom in the following years that propelled Singapore ahead of its regional peers as a destination for startup fundraising.

    But a global economic slowdown has thwarted the industry’s meteoric rise. VCs are now scrambling to assess the impact on their portfolios, while questions are being asked of their ability to generate returns as valuations slump and write-offs mount.

    “Over the last few years, everything pointed up and to the right. So it didn’t really matter so much where you participated or which companies you backed – it was more a question of just being in the market. Kind of like how a (rising) tide raises all ships,” said Ben Balzer, partner at Bain & Co.

    “Now that the tide’s going out a little, we will see who’s been (swimming naked),” said Balzer, referencing a quote from investor Warren Buffett.

    For years, VCs enjoyed a flourishing ecosystem driven by the rapid rise of South-east Asian tech. Assets under management in Singapore grew an average of 54.8 per cent each year, from S$4 billion in 2017 to S$24 billion in 2021, according to the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS).

    Since the start of the simplified regime in 2017, MAS has issued an average of about 40 VC fund manager licences each year. There are currently 160 active licence holders.

    “The pressure is going to be high for fund managers (in South-east Asia) that started deploying during the Covid years,” said Balzer.

    “These are the funds that were launched in 2019 or 2020, and deployed between 2020 and 2022. They will have a very concentrated portfolio that was deployed in the period when valuations were relatively hot,” he said, adding that many are first-time fund managers.

    Balzer believes most who set up five years ago might fare better. But these VCs are likely to receive more scrutiny, with a few struggling to raise follow-on funds because of a lack of track record.

    Lofty valuations

    South-east Asian startup valuations had stayed stubbornly bloated up till very recently, thanks to an influx of capital over the past few years.

    Rising valuations have contributed to attractive internal rates of return in VC funds, but the real gold lies in cash distributions – a point of uncertainty in the current environment.

    Startup ecosystems worldwide have embraced Silicon Valley’s “growth at all costs” approach that created some of the biggest companies today, such as Facebook.

    But the approach is now backfiring as institutional investors get tired of loss-making ventures without a firm grip on fundamentals.

    In the US, analysts are expecting more scrutiny of VCs as macroeconomic conditions turn sour. Excess capital over the years has led to valuation anomalies and ethical transgressions, said Bloomberg Intelligence analyst Gaurav Patankar.

    “After the failure of Silicon Valley Bank, we expect greater valuation scrutiny and disclosure, especially as a large chunk of fiduciary capital from pension funds has flowed into these markets – and unlike endowments and family offices, there are no avenues to extend and pretend,” Patankar wrote in a research note on Mar 24.

    He noted that fund managers have various means of masking zombie business models. For instance, a manager could roll over assets within a fund that is approaching the end of its life into a new fund – with some influence over valuations.

    South-east Asia has not had the same sort of impact, though the industry is hunkering down for a tough road ahead and focusing on quality companies. The region’s startups raised US$17.8 billion in equity and debt funding in 2022, down 31 per cent from an unprecedented 2021, DealStreetAsia data showed.

    VCs globally are facing challenges in raising funds, too. “We think a lot of funds that are raising in the market now may not end up being able to close. Some of them might (abandon their fundraising effort),” said Angela Lai, a senior research analyst at Preqin.

    Preqin’s global investor outlook report released in March showed the exit environment has become a key concern for VC investors. About 75 per cent of respondents said this poses a challenge to generating returns, up from 25 per cent a year ago.

    Most founders and their investors are delaying exits via a public listing by another one to three years, said Huang Shao-Ning, partner at angel network AngelCentral. Sentiment for trade sales has weakened as well.

    “So the issue of poor DPI (distribution to paid-in capital) for Asean VC funds will only continue for another few years. This is bad as capital cannot get recycled,” she said.

    “I definitely see fund managers asking for fund extensions over the next few years.”

    Bright spots

    That said, the market turmoil has shone a spotlight on early-stage deals in South-east Asia. “People are still interested in VC, but they’ve started to further modify their strategy,” said Preqin’s Lai.

    Early-stage deals have been favoured for their smaller ticket sizes and longer runway for development. And with a shift towards emerging markets, “South-east Asia is one that comes out on top in terms of attractiveness”, said Lai.

    She added that South-east Asian funds might fare better at fundraising than their global peers, given investor-interest in the underlying fundamentals of the market. The region boasts a rapidly rising middle class and a sizeable population rivalling those of other top economies.

    Not all VCs are holding back. Some fund managers are preparing to charge ahead and deploy capital during a bear market.

    These investors are motivated by the outsized returns made by venture capitalists that began investing shortly after the dot-com boom and 2008 financial crisis, when valuations were depressed.

    Singapore could benefit from the recovery. More global managers are viewing the city-state as an ideal place to set up their Asia-focused management platforms, said Jason Nelms, a partner at law firm Morrison Foerster.

    The Variable Capital Company (VCC) scheme, which was launched in 2020 to give managers more flexibility in structuring their funds, has gained popularity among such investors. MAS said 91 VC fund managers have used the VCC structure, with 19 setting up more than one VCC.

    “Some managers that have successfully managed the recent downturn (such as by selling at the top of the market, or helping portfolio companies to adjust to changing circumstances) are drawing positive attention from investors,” said Nelms.

    “These ‘battle-tested’ managers are best positioned to raise funds successfully as the market begins to turn more positive.”