Ex-Foodpanda CEO speaks out after abrupt exit from firm
Edmund Loh FC &
Melissa Goh
JAKOB Angele worked at Foodpanda for nearly a decade, leading the food delivery firm in the last six years of his nine-year stint.
But in October 2023, he abruptly stepped down as CEO and left the Delivery Hero-owned firm. Around that time, news about how he had allegedly leaked details about confidential talks with Grab on the potential sale of Foodpanda’s South-east Asia business came to light.
Angele is speaking out for the first time after the incident and admits his blunder. “As the CEO of Foodpanda, I was exposed to confidential information. At that point in time, I chose to share this … with somebody who was very close to me and who I trusted a lot,” he tells Tech in Asia.
“Unfortunately, that was a big mistake,” Angele admits.
That somebody was his former girlfriend, Rebekah Rankine. Days before the news broke, Angele had obtained a court order that prohibited her from speaking out publicly about him.
However, Rankine violated the court order by leaking the information via Instagram posts. “The person used that information against me to threaten and harass me,” Angele says.
An earlier Tech in Asia investigation found that police reports and court cases have been filed against Rankine since 2021, and that she had involved another party’s employer in a dispute.
With the way things had unfolded, leaving Foodpanda was the “only logical choice,” Angele explains. He describes the move as a mutual decision, as “the core objective was to protect the company and the team.”
In February, Delivery Hero said talks with its “main negotiating counterpart” fell through, though it remained open to dealmaking.
Angele is putting last year’s troubles behind him, and is pursuing personal projects as well as advisory and consulting work on the side.
He sat down with Tech in Asia to share his views on a range of topics, including what he’s learned from running the region’s second-largest food delivery firm, his views on the future of food delivery, and the potential for further growth.
Resisting the temptation to diversify
With the easing of the Covid-19 pandemic, many have returned to dining out. As a result, growth in food delivery is tapering in most South-east Asian markets.
Between 2022 and 2023, overall food delivery gross merchandise value (GMV) across the region grew 5 per cent to US$17.1 billion, according to a Momentum Works report. Apart from Vietnam, most markets posted “modest, low single-digit growth.” This was a significant drop from the 30 per cent and 183 per cent year-on-year growth logged by the region in 2021 and 2020, respectively.
Being the dominant player comes with the advantages of superior cost structures and better profitability, but Foodpanda has not been able to fully tap into these benefits. In most of its markets, the firm has been a consistent runner-up in the now decades-long food delivery race except in Taiwan, where its business is set to be bought over by UberEats.
Delivery Hero CEO Niklas Östberg himself said in November 2023 that Asia was holding the firm back, and that business has stagnated since Covid-19 lockdowns were relaxed. The company’s GMV from Asia fell 6.2 per cent year on year to US$6.9 billion in the third quarter of 2023.
Would diversifying into adjacent businesses have changed this trend?
“Over the years, there was a lot of temptation to diversify, go into ride-hailing … but we wanted to be focused on food,” Angele says.
Foodpanda’s DNA as a food delivery company fundamentally differs from Grab, which has its roots in ride-hailing. “In ride-hailing, when a driver cancels, it’s not such a big deal – you just get the next one. But for food, when you order and after 15 minutes your order is cancelled, that’s quite problematic because you’re already very hungry the moment you placed the order,” he explains.
According to Angele, zeroing in on a single vertical allowed Foodpanda to concentrate on improving the reliability and customer experience around that one service.
To reduce the likelihood of a cancellation, for instance, the company focused on matching orders to the right drivers and estimating when a restaurant is running out of stock on some items.
When Foodpanda did expand, it went into the adjacent grocery delivery business. Angele says both use “the same technology,” from order flow to logistics. And unlike ride-hailing firms that have a large fleet of four-wheel vehicles, food delivery firms can deliver groceries using the same fleet of two-wheelers.
This is a “massive advantage,” as a logistics fleet only gets efficient once there are a lot of orders in an area, he explains.
In addition, when a customer is already using a food delivery app, getting them to also use the grocery delivery feature is “much easier” than persuading them to try livestreaming or fintech services, for instance.
While food delivery is a high-frequency use case that can drive traffic into other businesses, Angele thinks that firms operating multiple business lines need to find synergies beyond a “shared customer base” and a “thin loyalty program” that isn’t financially lucrative or relevant to the customer.
“If the actual payback of such a loyalty program is only 0.5 per cent of what the customer spends and the program does not provide any other benefits, the customer will very quickly stop caring about it,” he notes.
Potential Foodpanda suitors
Singapore-based Grab and Chinese food delivery firm Meituan may have left the negotiating table, but there are still plenty of potential acquirers for Foodpanda’s South-east Asia business.
Aside from direct regional competitors and overseas players planning to enter South-east Asia, a food delivery firm could also look attractive to ecommerce or payments companies seeking a high-frequency use case, according to Angele.
Brick and mortar grocery stores planning to expand their online ecommerce reach are another possibility.
It wouldn’t be the first time that a major ecommerce firm has attempted to make this work. In 2019, South Korean online retailer Coupang launched a food delivery service called Coupang Eats and later rolled out a quick commerce service.
In November 2023, the firm said it expected the market share for Coupang Eats to reach close to 20 per cent by the end of that year.
However, building a food delivery business organically and from scratch can be challenging. That’s because of operational complexities such as signing up “a couple of thousand” restaurants and riders, negotiating commissions, and managing each of these stakeholders, Angele says.
He cites ShopeeFood as an example. Ecommerce giant Shopee “put in a lot of money” to launch the service via a combination of organic growth and an acquisition in Vietnam, but it hasn’t “come so far yet,” he observes.
An opening for TikTok?
ByteDance, the parent firm of short-video app TikTok, has experimented in food delivery via its Douyin service in China. This could make ByteDance a potential suitor for Foodpanda’s Southeast Asia business – or any food delivery firm in the region – assuming the Chinese tech titan decides to double down on food delivery in other Asia markets.
Douyin has been offering food and grocery delivery in China since 2022.
Through a partnership, Douyin users can stream videos from merchants on Ele.me – Alibaba’s food delivery arm – then browse their food offerings and place orders. Users can also purchase dine-in vouchers from restaurants and cafes via the Douyin app.
“What TikTok Shop is good at is small-ticket items and impulsive buys,” Angele observes, adding that food delivery could be a good extension of the app’s ecommerce unit. As he points out, “Food is a small-ticket item and it’s definitely impulsive – you’re hungry now so you want food.”
However, that may not necessarily be a strategy that TikTok wants to take. “The only question is, TikTok has a lot on its plate and they’re just gaining traction on the ecommerce side. So how much is their commitment to that space?” Angele asks.
In the first six months of 2023, Douyin generated 100 billion yuan (US$138 million) of sales in local services including food and beverage, but mostly from hotel and travel-related orders.
“Whether this is considered doing well or not depends on whether it has met the expectations of ByteDance and whether the efficiency of traffic monetization through local services is good and competitive compared to other verticals of Douyin such as ecommerce,” Jianggan Li, founder and CEO of venture builder Momentum Works, tells Tech in Asia.
That said, ByteDance could also choose to do so via partnerships or build its own food delivery business from ground up.
However, running a food delivery business in multiple countries is “more complex” than ecommerce, Li notes. For the endeavor to be worthwhile for ByteDance, it needs to first arrive at the conclusion that “local services, including and especially F&B, is an area of monetizing its massive consumer traffic that is worth trying.”
Angele agrees, noting that food delivery is more hands-on and involves managing riders and restaurants as well as putting a physical device in each store. Ensuring that food “comes in 20 minutes” is operationally much more complicated than ecommerce, where parcels can be delivered within a few days.
Space for more
Despite the consolidation taking place in the industry, Angele remains confident there is “room for multiple players.”
Assuming Uber’s acquisition of Foodpanda in Taiwan goes through without a hitch, Angele expects that a “new no. 2” would emerge given the size of the market and to respond to consumers’ demand for choice. With Uber and Foodpanda holding a duopoly in Taiwan, a merger could result in the combined entity holding close to 100% market share.
What could propel food delivery firms to their next phase of growth, however, is innovation. This has been missing in recent years due to the hard push towards profitability by the industry as a whole, he observes.
“When I started [in 2014], the average food delivery time in Singapore was about 90 minutes,” Angele recalls. “We eventually moved to something like 20 minutes to 25 minutes today.”
If any company keeps doing more of the same, then a highly diversified player will at some point catch up. He also says that people began “changing their order behavior” once delivery timings were reduced to under 45 minutes and better routing tech drove delivery costs down by 50%. “People who before, ordered once a quarter for a birthday party, all of a sudden started ordering twice a week.”
A potential area for innovation lies in the transparency of ingredients used in restaurant food, which he thinks could become more apparent in the next two years as people become more health-conscious.
Restaurant food, while tasty, tends to be high in salt, sugars, and fat. Assuming order frequency trends upward to several times a week, being transparent about food and their nutrition content “will become more important over time,” Angele says.
Still, he believes the opportunity for growth in food delivery remains “massive.”
At present, the average food delivery customer places five to 10 orders a month. This is far from the 90 meals a month that a person has on average, Angele estimates. To get people to make more online food orders per month, food delivery “has to be much more affordable than it is today, and that’s a very hard problem to solve,” he says.
Can food delivery firms specialising in one core service beat their highly diversified competitors?
“If you’re a focused player, you need to stay ahead of the game by being more innovative than your competitors,” he stresses. “If any company keeps doing more of the same, maybe [moving] the delivery time from 25 minutes to 24 minutes, then a highly diversified player will at some point catch up.” TECH IN ASIA
TRENDING NOW
Motoring tycoon Peter Kwee is back in court: Here are his previous legal battles
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Beyond the greenback, Vietnam’s big borrowers turn to Asian-currency bonds
Nvidia’s outlook cut to stable by Moody’s on governance concerns