The Business Times

Diverse allies rally for Microsoft in overseas data fight

Published Mon, Dec 15, 2014 · 11:08 PM
Share this article.

[NEW YORK] Corporate lobbyists, news organisations and academics joined forces with Microsoft Corp on Monday in the software company's legal battle with the US government over access to customer data stored overseas.

The diverse set of interests filed briefs with a federal appeals court in New York, urging it to reverse a judge's order that Microsoft turn over emails from a data center in Ireland. They argued that turning them over would jeopardize the future of international cloud computing.

The case has taken on urgency for tech and media companies in the wake of revelations about bulk electronic data collection by the US National Security Agency from former NSA contractor Edward Snowden.

Technology companies including and AT&T Inc and even rival Apple Inc also filed briefs supporting Microsoft's bid to fend off a government search warrant for the emails.

Microsoft began fighting the warrant in 2013, saying that US prosecutors were overreaching by demanding data held in a foreign country without the assistance of local authorities.

It is not known whose emails are sought, but prosecutors said they wanted them for a drug investigation.

The prosecutors said their demand did not violate Irish sovereignty because Microsoft's US employees had control of the emails and could retrieve them without going to Ireland. In July, US District Judge Loretta Preska agreed and ordered Microsoft to comply.

The ruling could wreak havoc in cloud computing for both businesses and individuals if countries regularly begin to claim authority over data stored elsewhere, said Andrew Pincus, a lawyer who filed a brief for groups including the US Chamber of Commerce, the largest US business lobby.

Businesses want to be sure their legal records, intellectual property and merger plans are generally private from authorities worldwide, Pincus said. "If by putting them in the cloud, you lose control over them and the government just gets access whenever it wants, nobody's going to do that," Pincus said at a conference at Microsoft's New York office.

The security of data centers is critical to journalists, said Bruce Brown, executive director of the US-based Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press. "We have stuff governments around the world want," Brown said at the conference.

Others supporting Microsoft in court briefs included the American Civil Liberties Union and 35 computer science and engineering professors.

A ruling by the appeals court is likely months away. A Justice Department spokesman declined to comment on Monday.


BT is now on Telegram!

For daily updates on weekdays and specially selected content for the weekend. Subscribe to



Get the latest coverage and full access to all BT premium content.


Browse corporate subscription here