Riding out the storm

THIS WEEK'S TOPIC: Will Singapore's S$60 billion response to Covid-19 help businesses tide over the crisis? What else might be needed to save jobs and livelihoods?

Published Sun, Apr 12, 2020 · 09:50 PM

    THIS WEEK'S TOPIC: Will Singapore's S$60 billion response to Covid-19 help businesses tide over the crisis? What else might be needed to save jobs and livelihoods?

    Yeoh Oon Jin Executive Chairman PwC Singapore

    THE three Budgets have already covered many Cs: costs, credit, cash, capacity, capability, cash in hand and cost of living. As to what else is needed, there are three other Cs that we can focus on. 1) Calibrate - there is a new normal emerging for the global supply chain. Hence predicting and preparing for this ensures Singapore's continued relevance as a major hub. 2) Coffers & Community - can we shore up our national reserves by getting capital/cash-rich enterprises and individuals to co-share the burden, for example through issuance of social bonds? 3) Confidence - consumption will rebound and local businesses must be ready, relevant and able to be activated quickly to give the economy the boost it needs; in this regard, government agencies can offer targeted interventions to support businesses to catch the rebound. When the economy thrives, so will jobs and livelihoods.

    Victor Mills Chief Executive Singapore International Chamber of Commerce

    A transformational, attitudinal change coupled with innovative collaboration is what is needed to save jobs and livelihoods. Covid-19 strips away the false complacencies which have been by-products of our success since 1965. Now we know again no one owes any one of us a living. We have to earn it and keep earning it. Employers and employees need each other like never before to rebuild and sustain businesses. Entrepreneurs need banks which lend because they know the difference between risk management and risk aversion. Private sector landlords need to sign fair tenancy agreements with their tenants. We are responsible for our future and that of Singapore.

    Max Loh Managing Partner, Singapore and Brunei Ernst & Young LLP

    THERE must be a dual focus on ''response'' and ''reboot''. The almost-S$60 billion response, focused on cost, credit and cash flow, is significant, comprehensive and inclusive. While it leaves no one behind, it behooves everyone to comply with the circuit-breaker measures and help flatten the infection curve as much and as soon as possible. Continual government stimulus and assistance is, however, not sustainable. Ultimately, the aim must be to help businesses to reboot quickly and readily when the window of recovery opens, and get back on the path of achieving market demand and growth to sustain the economy, jobs and the community. To that end, businesses must recognise that they should retain their talent - and help protect jobs now - whilst upskilling and retraining them in preparing everyone for a resilient future.

    Cheung Pui Yuen Chief Executive Officer Deloitte Singapore

    THIS landmark package, when used in the way it is intended, helps protect and sustain workers and businesses in our fight against Covid-19. With the government playing a bigger role to rebuild and transform our economy, businesses must also be open to radical reinvention to find new, significant and sustainable sources of revenue.

    The key to preserving jobs and livelihoods outside of the government's support is for Singaporeans to strictly heed the advice on safe distancing and hygiene protocols. This will significantly help shorten the closure period, lessen the impact and bring normalcy back. We must unite, stay resilient and stand in solidarity as a country to ride out the storm.

    Ong Pang Thye Managing Partner KPMG in Singapore

    THESE are extraordinary times with the overall economy taking the hit. One major impact is a potential decline in retail trade of at least 50 per cent, including associated services such as hotels, F&B, air transport and the like, due to reduced spending resulting from the ''circuit breaker'' and the loss of tourists and visitors. This alone could result in a fall in contributions to GDP of around S$8 billion over the next three months, equivalent to 6-7 per cent of GDP in the same period and possibly impact some 400,000 jobs. The three Budget packages provided will immediately support businesses and their employees to manage this impact.

    While the government's measures will definitely help preserve the lives and the livelihoods of the Singapore workforce, as a community, we must stand united to overcome this crisis together.

    Anneliese Schulz President, Asia Pacific, Japan Software AG

    THE Singapore government is doing a fantastic job of aiding businesses and the larger economy to navigate this turbulent period. In times such as these, it is also important that the public and private sectors come together, more than ever before, to drive a pragmatic societal response to this unfolding crisis. There is also the need to alleviate the strains of business continuity and move towards accelerated economic recovery, when the situation eases out. Analysing risks, planning for the future, building a solid infrastructure, enabling innovation at speed, creating agile business processes, and future-proofing supply chains will help ensure we are more resilient to such volatile situations in future.

    Callum Laing Chief Executive Officer MBH Corporation PLC

    WE'RE in new territory and there is no question that the government's response has been swift, well communicated and, hopefully, effective in minimising the damage. However, it can't replace a fully functioning market and it is the responsibility of individuals and companies to try and adapt, innovate and evolve where possible. Those that can will come out of this stronger and will have a responsibility to help those less able where possible. Let's hope we continue to see empathy and leadership from all corners of society.

    Veronica Shim Founder and CEO Envysion Wealth Management

    WHILE this is a much-needed government injection, it is only a temporary measure to tide businesses over. If the crisis prolongs and, with no cure in sight, business failure may be inevitable. Moreover, with social distancing still likely to be in place, this will continue to affect companies' and consumers' behaviour.

    Whilst we have to be realistic that not all jobs and companies can be saved, a robust strategy is needed to maintain livelihoods. We have to learn from the crisis and adapt to the new 'normal', and when the curve is flattened, gradually return the workforce to normalcy. In this time, it'll be key to strengthen infrastructure and expedite the 5G network rollout, continue financial support for SMEs, startups and individuals who have lost their jobs. Most importantly, financial institutions must be assured that they are able to hit liquidity requirements in order to ensure that the stimulus efforts rolled out by the government serve their purpose and are translated to the wider market.

    Dileep Nair Independent Director Thakral Corporation Limited

    THE Covid-19 crisis is far from over, especially as we experience a third wave of infections. The government's package to help businesses has been bold and timely. However, more is likely to be needed. Getting support to SMEs is said to be the litmus test of how well the economic fallout is handled. The Job Support Scheme may have to cover a larger percentage of payroll, and for a longer period. There should also be some form of rental relief since rental costs are just as critical to an SME as labour costs. While the cost of business loans to SMEs has been lowered, interest rates can be brought down even to zero, and the loans fully guaranteed by Government. We can also follow the Swiss government's example of reducing paperwork for SME loans to a single form and getting approval within a day or two. For many of our SMEs, revenues have already plummeted. The government's package, especially if enhanced, should throw them a lifeline.

    Jayaprakash Jagateesan Chief Executive Officer RHT Fintech Holdings

    SINGAPORE is doing its best under difficult circumstances. However, domestic support measures have their limits when facing a global issue. Prolonged travel restrictions in major economies prevent economic normalcy and the situation in our close neighbours have a significant impact on many local companies and the supply of labour. These are out of our control.

    A long road to recovery will severely affect vulnerable groups. Private sector and charity organisations will need to step up and work closely with the government to find ways to reach out and ensure lower-income families continue to have a roof over their heads and food on their table.

    Chua Soon Ghee Partner, Head of Southeast Asia AT Kearney

    WHETHER the S$60billion Covid-19 response is sufficient will depend on how long the virus situation drags out. Our best guess is that, even with a tampering of the spikes and relaxation of distancing rules, Singapore and most countries will still practise some restrictions until a vaccine is widely available probably next year. This will mean continued pain especially for the aviation, hospitality, F&B and retail industries. Some further targeted assistance (eg extension of wage support, fees rebate/deferral, loan support) may be required to help workers and companies in those sectors.

    Jeffery Tan Group General Counsel Jardine Cycle & Carriage Ltd

    THE names assigned to the three support packages - Unity, Resilience and Solidarity - highlight the need for the building of a new mindset in the Singaporean ethos that is critical to see the country through this Covid-19 crisis and beyond. Even as we continue this ''world war'' against Covid-19, let us also take a cue from the late Winston Churchill who was involved in the last world war: ''The true guide of life is to do what is right.''

    Walter de Oude Chief Executive Officer Singapore Life Pte Ltd

    WHILE government is doing everything possible to flatten the curve, I think there is more that the private sector can do. Landlords in particular hold a significant amount of the wealth of Singapore, and I think that they could do more to ensure the continuity and sustainability of our communities and lifestyles. The best landlords are those that work in partnership with their tenants, and at times like these, landlords should go further by linking rentals to revenue. If shops and restaurants close, the whole economy suffers, and landlords should be equally accountable for those jobs.

    Benjamin Tan Vice President Ultimaker Asia Pacific

    A complex, all-round solution is required to save jobs. I think the Singapore government has done a good job in delivering swift, decisive measures to save the economy.

    With the grants that landlords receive, they now need to suspend rent or peg it to a percentage of revenue; processes for eligible companies to apply for grants to be made as smooth and as easily as possible. We have seen our ministers lead by example by taking a three-month pay cut, and top management who have sacrificed bonuses and taken pay cuts to save the livelihoods of their rank and file.

    Under such extenuating circumstances, a lot more can be done but it has to be a concerted effort.

    Matthew Lim Group Managing Director WE! Interactive

    WHILE it's great to see the government putting in effort to aid businesses and individuals, we can't expect the government to have answers to everything. We have to be aware that these are only support measures; a springboard for us to bounce back.

    Businesses and individuals need to step up to help themselves and others. Transform the way we think and work. Help others if they have the capability to do so.

    While sure, everyone has families to feed, bills and loans to pay, and some remuneration is still expected, this is not the time to be calculative. Everyone wants good profit from the services and goods they provide but if we don't get through this together, who else is there left to earn money from when this is over?

    We can only tide through this crisis if we stand united together.

    Lance Ng Group CEO Searix Solutions International

    WE used to operate with heavy focus in the events industry, providing interactive technology to MICE and corporate events.

    I believe we're in one of the few industries (apart from airlines and China tour companies) that have received absolutely $0 income since late January. Not just ''reduced income'' like the F&B sector, taxi or private hire services, etc, but absolutely zilch, nothing.

    My company has received cancellations of over S$350,000 worth of projects since then. Our business is still (at time of writing) not exactly considered part of MICE. We're not eligible for Tier 1 of the Jobs Support Scheme (JSS). Directors and shareholders are also exempted from JSS. Many owners of numerous small-event and event-support firms receive little to no support. In any case, my company is heavily invested in technology and tech assets rather than manpower so JSS doesn't help either.

    What would help is the government committing to some events later on in the year so that deposits can be paid upon award. That, and for the events industry and its freelancers to be considered among the groups that need the highest tier of support in the JSS and Self-Employed Persons schemes.

    Sebastian Mueller COO & Co-Founder MING Labs

    THE government's efforts are laudable, yet they will not be enough by themselves. Supporting businesses and households with cash when cash flow is tight is essential. But what happens with that cash?

    Without confidence, neither businesses nor households will spend. Instead of seizing opportunities, companies start to hibernate. Coming out of the global crisis, they will not be in a better place than before.

    What we need, in addition to government stimulus, are business leaders who dare to invest. With a vision for the future, they need to start exploring new territory and place strategic bets. The winners of tomorrow are forged today.

    Axel Berkling Executive VP, Asia-Pacific KONE Corporation

    THE Covid-19 pandemic has brought about unexpected and unprecedented changes to the way we live and work, which have caused significant economic and social impact globally. I believe that the measures announced by the Singapore government will help businesses tide through this critical trying period. It's crucial for companies, both large and small, to play their role of being a responsible employer and protect the livelihoods of their employees. Enhancements to existing measures such as the Jobs Support Scheme and Wage Credit Scheme may be required to help employers mitigate retrenchments should the economic situation worsen as a result of the ripple effects of Covid-19.

    Luigi La Tona Chief Operating Officer Storhub

    THE circuit breaker measures have created a unique problem for Singapore. Space at home is now a premium especially in our high density environment. The government's S$60billion response will save jobs and livelihoods, but we feel the real challenge is helping Singaporeans adjust to working from home in spaces that hitherto were not built for work.

    The mental adjustment needed to de-clutter and create the environment that enables us to be productive is a far deeper concern than previously understood. We feel training to help parents adjust to working from home where children are learning from home is going to become a trending issue at all community levels. The Covid-19 crisis can be the defining moment where businesses go to another level and permanently change Singaporeans' working practices. Today, however, Singaporeans need the help in adjusting to this new reality.

    Damian Tan Managing Director Vickers Venture Partners

    THE government's support measures will surely help soften the pain of the crisis. It's a share of the burden businesses are facing. However, we are at war with an invisible deadly enemy and the world has ground to almost a standstill. This leads to a deflation of the global economy. A deflation is much worse than a recession. Businesses are on the brink of bankruptcy and prices are tumbling. It's an artificial deflation because there is usually demand but it's locked up amidst the freeze.

    The most important thing is to find a cure and be able to detect the virus. Only then can we see the enemy and fight.

    Takehiko Ryu Managing Director Panasonic Asia Pacific Pte Ltd

    THE Singapore government's efforts to support businesses and the workforce will go a long way towards helping them tide over the economic fallout from Covid-19. At the same time, business leaders should also play a role in setting the tone for employees under their charge. This can be done by ensuring the safety and the stability of their workforce by prioritising health and safety as well as long-term business sustainability, or even by taking the lead in innovating on existing capabilities to address both changing business requirements and the needs of society. Hand-in-hand with other businesses doing the same, this will create a more resilient and loyal workforce that will serve as the bedrock of a stronger economy for the future.

    Pierre-Jean Châlon Senior VP, Asia Pacific Poly

    TODAY, there is no doubt that how we work, educate, govern and live is no longer ''business as usual''. Instead, adaptability and agility are the new norms. The Singapore government has implemented unprecedented measures to stabilise the workforce, but the way forward is on business leaders to show even greater leadership during this uncertainty. Whether ''thinking out of the building'' in enabling employees to stay productive through the judicious use of remote-work technology solutions and services, or r-eimagining how technology can redefine what it means to be productive, this is a prime opportunity to envision a new future, grounded in learnings from this challenging time.

    Thomas Holenia President Henkel Singapore

    ON many fronts, the Singapore government has handled the Covid-19 crisis really well. For the business community, the Solidarity Budget provides not only significant financial relief, but also tremendous encouragement to unite as #ONESG, collaborate and persevere through this crisis. At Henkel, our employees are our top priority. We will do whatever we can to protect our employees, while doing our utmost to support our customers and enable business continuity. In tandem, we must prepare for the future and be ready to seize the opportunities when the crisis ends. With people as Singapore's critical asset and competitive advantage, this means putting a priority on upskilling our workforce across technical competences, leadership skills and cultivating an entrepreneurial spirit. In line with this, Henkel offers a comprehensive digital learning platform and we strongly encourage all our employees to embrace continuous learning and development and to be equipped with the skills for the future.

    Svend Janssen Head of Asia Western Union Business Solutions

    THE Singapore government's swift response to Covid-19 is laudable, and its supplementary budget is decisive and well-rounded. The effects of Covid-19 will be long-lasting and businesses must be prepared for a new normal. While daily meetings will remain intact, businesses will begin operating with leaner teams and more activities will naturally be moved online. Preceding the pandemic, Singapore has already done a great job in facilitating the digital transformation of many SMEs. Businesses must be proactive in doing more, and fast.

    They must take advantage of the tools already provided to them to digitalise further, restructure current business models and transform strategies to futureproof the business. Currently, Covid-19 has unified the world in the fight against a common enemy, putting globalisation on the fast track. Fortifying businesses for increased global trade and global competition is a natural next step for survival and Western Union Business Solutions is committed to supporting our clients and helping them navigate and hedge against current market uncertainties.

    Vikas Nahata Co Founder and Executive Chairman Validus Capital

    BUSINESSES around the world are facing a massive liquidity crunch, especially SMEs with limited resources. The S$60 billion response by the government to counter the effects of the outbreak is timely and much needed. The Jobs Support Scheme especially comes in as a huge relief to business owners as it helps them retain their local staff during this period of economic uncertainty. The measures providing short-term liquidity will give businesses some breathing space, enabling them to make calculated decisions. As SMEs react to the economic downturn by cutting costs and preserving cash reserves, they can also turn to financing platforms for their operational expenses.

    Adrian Jones Executive VP, Asia Pacific & Japan Automation Anywhere

    WE are in full support of the government's initiatives to help businesses cope during this crisis. Apart from financial imperatives, businesses need to move toward sustainability and recovery. This begins with adopting intelligent automation to navigate constrained resources and augment workers' efficiencies. It will, ultimately, help companies to navigate the new normal, with workplaces requiring streamlined efficiencies, and employees redeployed to business-critical tasks. In addition to empowering productive workforce redeployments, employees need to be equipped to be future-ready, with digital skills and competencies in automation and bot development. This will enable workers to improve their skills and relevance to their industries and take advantage of future opportunities in a tech-enabled workplace.

    Stephen McNulty President, Asia Pacific and Japan Micro Focus

    THE government's approach to tackling the social and business implications of Covid-19 is a strong and laudable step in the right direction. This spirit of solidarity, coupled with practical measures, will be critical in helping the nation stay united and focused on its recovery journey.

    It was particularly assuring to see local organisations nimbly move their entire operations online almost overnight, a level of preparedness that was a long time in the making. Going one step further, we must leverage this strong technological foundation to mitigate disruptions within the workforce, allowing citizens to continue contributing to the economy while protecting their livelihoods.

    Rayhan Perera Founder One Dash

    HAVING cut its teeth during the Sars outbreak, Singapore has proactively built a response model that takes into consideration economic and societal impact. It is a measure of the country's foresight that is worth emulating. There are also the softer aspects of effectively dealing with this pandemic, apart from the financial stimulus - current open information exchange, preparedness plans in action, seamless inter-play between agencies. Apart from a whole-of-government approach, it is also critical that private organisations and people follow guidelines and act sensibly and sensitively. Everyone needs to play their individual and collective parts well to ensure we pull through this.

    Marjet Andriesse Managing Director, Asia Pacific Telstra

    THE Singapore government's response to Covid-19 is encouraging and will do much to help businesses. At the same time. businesses have a role to help enable and equip workers during this crisis. Where possible, organisations need to ensure that remote work arrangements are sound. Technology is essential in making this happen. This means having the right equipment along with the necessary infrastructure to maintain normalcy and connectivity which will be key for business survival.

    At this time, essential service providers like telcos must continue to do their part in helping businesses and the larger communities around them. To support the increased demand for connectivity, efforts should be made to increase network capacity while supporting the digital enablement of business operations.

    Looking ahead, businesses should also keep their eye on the future - the changes that we are seeing now will become permanent features of our lives. Technology and the increased demand for connectivity and flexibility will determine the future of our business environment and create opportunities for the digital economy.

    Andie Rees Managing Partner - South East Asia Odgers Berndtson

    THE government's three budgets address the pressing financial needs of organisations (and individuals) hardest hit by Covid-19. A main focus of the support measures is to help businesses in the immediate term to preserve cash, continue operations and, most importantly, protect jobs. The government's generous support does address some of the financial concerns particularly of SMEs. The Jobs Support Scheme will go a long way towards alleviating the financial constraints of keeping the workforce and minimising layoffs. Nevertheless, there are other manpower issues regarding job protection and skillsets. In our webinars with clients to share best practices and to discuss ideas, issues raised included ensuring employees remain engaged via ongoing engagement strategies such as virtual learning and job training and re-skilling. This is in line with the government's plan for the future of work, which will be very different post-pandemic. We would need to ensure our people are well-prepared for the future business and work landscape. Companies should ''over-communicate'' with employees to keep them abreast of developments and to enable them to be prepared, both mentally and skills-wise for future initiatives. Companies can even offer remote social interaction opportunities where people meet in virtual spaces to maintain a sense of community. It is vital to look after not just the financial aspects of our people but their mental and physical well-being as social distancing can lead to mental distancing in addition to physical isolation.

    Chia Ngiang Hong President Real Estate Developers' Association of Singapore (REDAS)

    GIVEN the Singapore economy is largely dependent on SMEs, the government's S$60 billion support package is critical in cushioning the immediate economic blow brought about by Covid-19 to support jobs and ensuring that businesses and the financial markets continue to function properly. However, one cannot rule out the possibility of a prolonged crisis, causing more extensive damage to businesses small and big, especially in the face of a pandemic that limits physical mobility and disrupt demand and supply.

    We are also seeing significant changes in our workplace and business practices and these will likely be the norm in the aftermath of this pandemic. A growth strategy embracing transformational digital technology and innovative approaches as well as multilateral efforts to help one another will go a long way toward boosting economic resilience and ensuring business sustainability to support jobs and livelihoods. Coordinated efforts by world governments to stem the contagion and mitigate the economic repercussions are also very vital.

    Kartik Krishnamurthy Managing Director Cornerstone OnDemand Asia

    THE S$60billion package released by Singapore is focussed on putting money into the pockets of people who need it the most - those in retail, SMEs and other businesses, to help them ride out this unprecedented time. In my opinion. this is a great display of support by the government. However, we all play a role to make sure businesses can be back on their feet to do what they do - provide a service. The one-month circuit breaker requires all of us to stay home and not venture out unless it's for essentials. We all have a part to flatten the curve and while this one-month will be hard for many, I believe it's our obligation to be responsible for the greater good.

    This is also a time for leading with empathy and compassion. While top and bottom lines at businesses will take a hit, the #1 reason most of the businesses did well all these years was because of their talent. If a business has been run well and cost-effectively, they should have a cushion to help their staff tide through, on top of what the government has extended. Which means senior leadership should make a pledge to cut their bonuses and salaries and pass them through the firm to ensure no staff layoffs. These are unprecedented times so we all - government, individuals and business leaders - have a role to play to bring the nation and economy back on track.

    Toby Koh Group MD Ademco Security Group

    LET'S create jobs now. As I suggested to DPM Heng Swee Keat during the ST-BT Budget 2020 Roundtable last month, aside from financial aid, we must encourage job creation now. There are viable Singaporean-owned SMEs that can hire and tap the growing pool of talent available in the job market now, but are holding back because of the economic uncertainty. I suggest a longer-term wage support scheme to accelerate job creation. Government can co-pay 60 per cent of new hires' salary for 12 months. Parameters will include a minimum hire period of 12 months and the new hires must be over and above the average headcount for last six months. The longer-term wage support will help pave the way for viable companies to hire now and not later.

    Tomas O' Farrell Co-founder Workana

    SINGAPORE'S commitment to supporting businesses is indeed commendable. Whether or not it is sufficient to tide over the crisis is all dependent on uncertain circumstances that keep surprising us. One of the things that this time has taught us is that it is imperative for businesses to remain versatile and transparent. In order to continue and survive, businesses will likely trim down to the fullest extent their expenses and retain only the most essential. Companies, together with their employees, must also be open to the potential shift of working arrangements, from full time to project base, to ensure that livelihoods are still guaranteed.

    Maren Schweizer Director Schweizer World Pte Ltd

    SINGAPORE'S swift, effective action in the early days of the crisis helped to skirt a humanitarian and economic disaster.

    Some moments during the crisis call for immediate action, with little to assess or anticipate; I believe in the importance of finding occasions to stop, reflect, and think ahead before making further moves.

    While navigating the downturn and positioning ourselves for recovery, additional measures that aid in remaining liquid - both for businesses and individual livelihoods - will become necessary.

    To cope with a jamais vu - never seen - it's time now to collect information as the crisis unfolds and observe how well the responses work before deciding on further support packages.

    Rob Bryson Managing Director Robert Walters Singapore

    I'VE lived in several different countries and I feel fortunate to be in Singapore during these challenging times. This situation is unprecedented and the Singapore government has managed to be proactive and forward-thinking in helping businesses and its people. As employers, we must similarly take the initiative in protecting our employees.

    Companies should take long-term approach to this and look at how to manage costs so we can best protect the jobs of our people. In addition to the typical cost-cutting reviews and measures, companies can consider asking their employees to volunteer to take annual leave, unpaid leave, sabbaticals, training days, tuition days and more. These should, ideally, be on a voluntary basis so employees have the option of taking these up based on their personal situations to help the company save costs, and protect their jobs.

    Linus Lim Chief Executive Officer Phillip Capital Management

    THE government has unveiled support across all levels of the economy. We can divide companies into two broad categories - those that are fundamentally sound but facing external shocks, and firms that are facing difficulties because of an over optimistic business model and would face distress even in normal times. In the short term , liquidity and credit is key for companies as we don't know how long the follow-on effects will be. I do have concerns about companies that have not built sufficient buffers against economic shocks. The reality is we cannot save every company and the natural order of business is that water will find its own level.

    The mid-term focus on getting businesses back on their feet is also important as, if it's a V-shaped recovery, we need all hands on deck. Skills training, getting our managers equipped to expand beyond our shores. Job creation subsidies can be supplemented by preparing business leaders and job seekers to better understand mutual expectations so that trainees can be translated to permanent hires.

    Henry Tan Group CEO Nexia TS Group

    THE huge Budget support will help but it may not cure. It's akin to pain killers that ease the pain but do not help us to recover from the illness. We need our immunity system to fight it. This requires businesses to be resolute and have a clear strategy to fight and to survive. Simply relying on government help will not sustain businesses as this crisis will last a while. We have to restructure, reposition, prepare and progress from where we are. The Jobs Support Scheme (JSS), for example, covers only up to S$4,600 of salary. It also applies only to Singaporeans and PRs. Foreign staff on employment passes comprise up to 40 per cent of many SMEs' workforce.

    We need to generate work and generate demand. Government can advance projects to create work and jobs. If the conditions are not conducive, then more online projects should be created. Creating business and demand is more important than providing support as the former is a sustainable solution. The ''lockdown'' must be lifted as soon as possible as the danger of the virus versus danger of impact on livelihoods needs to be balanced.

    Zakir Ahmed Senior VP and GM, Asia Pacific and Japan Kofax

    ORGANISATIONS need automation more than ever due to unprecedented workforce and operational disruption. The government's S$60 billion package is much needed and will help keep the lights on for businesses during these challenging times. However, there's an opportunity for enterprises to utilise the package for business transformation through technology.

    Organisations can take advantage of the economic downturn to upgrade infrastructure and systems for the rebound. They can increase agility and responsiveness with Intelligent Automation software platforms. To mitigate some of the pressure, enterprises should look at technology to evaluate tools that extend capabilities to meet challenges presented by the Covid-19 global health crisis.

    Neville Vincent VP, South Asia Pacific Nutanix

    SINGAPORE'S response to Covid-19 is a vital step in cushioning the impact on businesses and the economy and will likely be part of a staged package of measures as we adapt to the emerging new world. Covid-19 has brought about a new business reality and accelerated the shift to a multi-cloud world. Businesses that survive will emerge leaner, more productive, more efficient, and much more adaptable. Our workforce will also be required to adapt, as new skills and ways of thinking become fundamental for survival.

    The good news is the government has already allocated S$8.3 billion over the next three years to support 3,800 technology startups, and there are 150 VC funds to help insulate the economy. Singapore is well placed to rebound with a world-leading infrastructure, education and workforce and a focus on collective prosperity for all.

    Abhishek Deshmukh VP of Engineering & MD, Singapore Zendesk

    SINGAPORE'S response shows a strong sense of urgency to cushion the impact of Covid-19 on businesses and their employees, and will help mitigate the ongoing economic impact. It's obvious that this pandemic has forced us to fast-track virtual alternatives in all aspects of our lives - from managing entirely remote workforces and hosting virtual events, to buying groceries and balancing school work with conference calls. I am constantly reminded of how privileged we are to have access to technologies that make this easier than ever. The two most important things to any business, regardless of what is happening in the world around us, are its employees and its customers. When it comes to protecting our long-term outlook during moments of crisis, it's the companies that double down on taking care of employees and customers that survive.

    Leonard Cheong Managing Director AdNovum Singapore Pte Ltd

    SINGAPORE'S S$60 billion measures will help businesses overcome the near-term challenges, but may not be sufficient if the crisis stretches beyond 2020.

    Additional post-measures must be in place to help businesses rebound from the economic impact of the crisis in order to save jobs and livelihoods. Impacts arising from the crisis would reshape certain industries, creating new business models and changes in the financial and social behaviour patterns, as more people will become prudent.

    Businesses should take this opportunity to restructure their business models by leveraging on technology as an enabler of effective operations, optimised costs and enhanced customer experiences.

    Mario Singh Chief Executive Officer Fullerton Markets

    THE Unity, Resilience and Solidarity budgets have been rolled out because of the unprecedented situation caused by the Covid-19 pandemic. With a total S$59.9 billion set aside to help workers, businesses and families, the entire package will see a record budget deficit of S$44.3 billion in financial year 2020 for Singapore.

    As a Singaporean, I am deeply grateful that the government has taken proactive, determined action at this time. At the end of his Solidarity Budget speech, Finance Minister Heng Swee Keat said that the situation remains highly fluid and uncertain, but the government stands ready to provide further support should it become necessary.

    While the government takes these steps to protect and preserve jobs and livelihoods, it is equally important for affected businesses to start thinking about pivoting. As a business, the mission may be important but the method is not. This is the time to explore and experiment with different strategies to both survive and thrive.

    Jay Ng Managing Director STACS

    THE S$60 billion response from the government is laudable and can help ease the pain currently afflicting companies and individuals.

    However, for many companies it may not be enough for them to recover fully, depending on how long this Covid-19 situation drags. Many firms will feel greater distress now as they have not transformed early enough by adopting digital technologies. If they had embraced e-commerce, AI, blockchain and robotics, the negative impact may not be so great.

    At STACS, we help financial institutions to transform their business by using blockchain technology. For example, they can remove reconciliation work using our suite of technology. This allows cumbersome operational processes to be done more efficiently, securely and with less manpower. When Covid-19 is finally behind us, hopefully, it will be a reminder to all businesses to adopt technology to stay relevant.

    Elisa Mallis MD and VP, Asia-Pacific Center for Creative Leadership

    COMPARED to many countries in Asia-Pacific and globally, Singapore has demonstrated a more proactive and comprehensive management of Covid-19 from the start. The latest measures have also helped put Singapore in a good position to rejuvenate its economy sooner than others. However, given uncertainty, leaders must work extra hard during the next phase of the outbreak to minimise job loss. They must prioritise health and safety, adopt a measured approach to a restart and have clear, detailed protocols when work resumes to minimise further transmission. They should also look at digital services and expertise that Singapore can provide to the world as other countries seek to recover.

    Mark Weaser Vice President, Asia-Pacific OutSystems

    WITH the escalating Covid-19 situation hitting the economy hard, the recently announced third round of support measures will definitely help further cushion the impact it has on businesses and employees. However, given the economic uncertainties, future initiatives that focus on longer-term strategic goals are needed to help businesses recover from the aftermath. With the shift to remote working for next month, it is critical for businesses to adapt quickly and embrace the changes by utilising technology effectively in order to achieve greater business agility and ensure minimum business disruption. Organisations would also have to innovate their services and digital strategies to ensure that they are never exposed to such vulnerabilities again.

    Ronak Shah Chief Executive Officer QBE Singapore

    MEASURES already announced by the government will provide needed relief to the economy and its workers in the immediate to mid-term. However, more support may be required down the road as Covid-19's true economic impact becomes clearer. We can never lose sight of the importance of protecting workers' livelihoods during this uncertain time, and the government has already announced strong measures in this area. Companies can play their part by reskilling workers whose jobs have been made redundant by the virus and by creating new opportunities for employees to add value. Covid-19 calls for an empathetic and concerted effort by the public and private sectors to ensure citizens can go back to ''business-as-usual'' as quickly as possible.

    Lee Fook Chiew Chief Executive Officer Institute of Singapore Chartered Accountants (ISCA)

    THE government has acted swiftly with the two supplementary budgets and rendered significant financial support to businesses and individuals to help them tide over this challenging period when businesses are disrupted and jobs are at risk. The support measures are bold and address the pain points directly, and we believe they will go a long way towards alleviating the difficulties faced by both businesses and households. To help those affected by the Covid-19 pandemic, navigate the wide array of assistance schemes and resources ISCA has produced the Covid-19 Navigator, a guide that directs individuals and businesses to relevant resources from the government and ISCA, at a glance. Having said that, to save lives and livelihoods, a change in mindset is equally critical. We must all take the circuit-breaker measures seriously so that life in Singapore can return to normalcy as soon as possible.

    Saikrishnan Ranganathan CEO & Co-Founder SensorFlow

    SINGAPORE'S response to Covid-19 is unprecedented and will help sustain businesses and the gig economy in the short term. However, businesses can do more by minimising their operational costs and adopting technology to support operational continuity and employee retention. The hotel industry, in particular, is in a precarious position and needs to adopt automated technology solutions that can help hoteliers identify operational areas that can be cut down. With fewer resources needed to be allocated during this crisis, the operators can use savings through technology to retain their staff and offer better employee benefits.

    Sudhir Agarwal Chief Executive Officer Everise

    BEING a global leader in managing the Covid-19 pandemic, Singapore has rolled out one of the most comprehensive support packages that will lead its people and the economy through these uncertain times. The strict measures the government has taken will ensure that the country will be one of the few that will be least affected when all of this passes. We all have our part to play, Everise included. We successfully migrated our entire organisation into a work-at-home model within a matter of weeks, while hiring thousands more to support the enterprise business continuity plans. We are projecting to hire 500 Singaporean work-at-home support staff by year-end.

    Simon Lee Vice President Gigamon APAC

    THE financial support provided to local businesses can help tide them over the duration of the circuit breaker. However, their ability to survive through this really depends on how quickly they are able to adapt their business models, adjust their infrastructures and reconnect with their customers. It is a race to digitally transform their relationships in the shortest possible time. This, in turn, will help keep employment rates up and sustain livelihoods locally. Similarly, large global enterprises are widely impacted and need to start looking at how they expedite their digital transformation and leverage partnerships with technology vendors to help them lower costs while maintaining their business continuity - essentially doing more with less resources.

    Kunalan Chakravarthy Chief Executive Priority Consultants Group

    THE government has acted proactively, recognising the challenges businesses are facing in these unprecedented global times. The programmes are focused on ensuring jobs and livelihoods are secure. Will they help? Yes, I think they will.

    However, it is imperative to note that our world has changed fundamentally. We will not return completely to our old ways. Changes will take root especially at grassroots levels of business and society. We will make adjustments and these will become the new norm. We will learn to work and learn from home, be more aware of our spatial needs and adopt communications technologies with even greater zeal.

    While it is not entirely a revolution, we will evolve and change as a society.

    Andrew Seow Regional GM, SE Asia and Greater China Rimini Street

    THE monetary incentives provided by the government in light of the Covid-19 outbreak are essential in ensuring that businesses can continue to operate. In addition, it is important for CEOs and CIOs to evaluate cost-effective and efficient options for technology solutions to sustain these challenging times. Leveraging the right technology solutions can help to slash operational costs and redirect those savings to keep the business running, without having to take drastic measures such as retrenchment or pay cuts for employees.

    Sandeep Bhargava MD, Asia Pacific and Japan Rackspace

    THE monetary support provided by the government in these challenging and uncertain times is very welcome to help cushion the impact that businesses are facing. It is also important for businesses to ensure that, as much as possible, there is minimal or no disruption in business operations even with the circuit breaker rules in place.

    Rackspace has implemented work- from-home (WFH) policies; almost all our employees (except those needed to manage data centres) have been working from home using video conferencing and collaboration technologies to connect with customers and partners. This keeps our employees safe, ensures we deliver our promise to our customers and meet financial commitments to our shareholders - all needed to protect jobs.

    We believe that organisations will need to leverage technology investments and augment them where required (especially WFH capability and securing their environment). This will help businesses to remain efficient in terms of operations and minimise disruption in workflow that can lead to financial losses.

    Geoff Soon Managing Director, South Asia Snowflake

    WE are engaged in a collective fight against Covid-19 and applaud the Singapore government's move to support businesses in this crucial time. Organisations need to streamline processes and provide the platforms to enable their employees to work remotely and securely. Access to information must be seamless so employees can get on with their work. They need to look at technology such as the cloud as an enabler to support their workforce to collaborate, communicate effectively and analyse business data for faster decision-making. This, in turn, will help keep businesses afloat.

    Vincent Tang Regional Vice President, Asia Epicor

    WE welcome the government's support for businesses to help them keep going, as we adapt to extraordinary changes taking place. The New Now is the current state of our economy, industries, businesses and operating procedures, and the government's support for firms' immediate needs is greatly appreciated.

    Ensuring that companies remain in business requires staying connected to vendors, suppliers and customers. It's vital that there is connectivity and agility in the way we operate our businesses. Government encouragement of a more agile way of work, leveraging systems to streamline, automate and scale business processes throughout the supply chain, will help companies stay viable

    Sumir Bhatia President, Asia Pacific, Data Center Group Lenovo

    THE government's support packages provide vital short-term aid measures to help businesses tide over the Covid-19 crisis - but given the uncertainties ahead, further relief may be required to help sustain businesses in the long term.

    With the national 'circuit breaker' mandating remote working arrangements as much as possible for the next month, it is even more crucial for businesses to re-evaluate their IT infrastructure. Technology will play a key role in successfully adjusting to this 'new normal'. Amid the pressures of the Covid-19 pandemic, businesses will need to ensure that work remains undisrupted and their remote employees remain productive. By promptly implementing the right technology - be it video conferencing or virtual desktop solutions - businesses can ensure operational continuity to seamlessly deliver value to customers and the wider community.

    Edmund Lee Managing Director Singapore TMF Group

    SINGAPORE'S series of Unity, Resilience and Solidarity budgets have provided increasingly high levels of support to the local economy. However, these are largely relief measures for businesses to batten down the hatches and weather the storm.

    Once the immediate Covid-19 outbreak eases, a further series of stimulus measures may be required to facilitate a faster economic recovery. With the fuzzy outlook on the post-Covid-19 scenario, stimulus measures would not be appropriate now, as they would not be able to overcome the current weak consumer and business sentiment.

    In the wise words of the late Australian Prime Minister Gough Whitlam (1972-1975), ''we're going to either crash, or crash through''. As long as the underlying fundamentals of Singapore's economy remain strong, a recovery will be forthcoming.

    Nick Lim General Manager, Asia Pacific & Japan TIBCO

    WHILE TIBCO's business continuity and disaster recovery plans remain robust, we welcome the government's response to businesses as remarkable support. In light of recent global challenges stemming from Covid-19, companies must take their own streamlining initiatives to endure the circumstances that are fast changing. We believe that facilitating an acceleration in connecting to seamless access to information and the adoption of data-driven solutions to appropriately support business needs is essential. Companies must make efficient use of the insightful data this will generate, and predict data-driven decisions at a real-time scale.

    Malina Platon MD, Strategic Accounts, APAC UiPath

    I very much see the Solidarity Budget as a bridge for businesses that should allow them to get through this period of heightened restrictions. It is important that the government continues to work closely and collaboratively with the private sector - from SMEs to larger enterprises - to understand workforce realities. This will allow them to adjust overall digital transformation strategies to improve workforce productivity, service innovation and workforce enablement (for example, career paths redesigned according to the new global and local economical situations).

    Everyone in Singapore and beyond is looking to the recovery so businesses should use this period to prepare. Things will not be the same moving forward and even with lockdowns lifted there will be more health protocols, more distancing and more remote working. Firms should work towards a digital transformation strategy that allows working from home in a seamless manner. They should also work towards more employee upskilling especially in the fields of automation technologies, Robotic Process Automation and Artificial Intelligence. These technologies will be pivotal to rebuilding business and economic growth in a sustainable manner.

    Deborah Ho Head, Singapore and SEAsia BlackRock

    SINGAPORE'S fiscal response of about 12 per cent of GDP is a record. We have every confidence that the government is doing all it can to help businesses and our people, but given we are a very open economy, our recovery will depend on how the rest of the world manages this crisis. This pandemic is unprecedented in our lifetime and it accelerates some of the pre-existing trends in the world. As my colleague Ben Powell from the BlackRock Investment Institute notes, we see rising nationalism, with larger economies becoming inward-looking, resulting in reduced reliance on global supply chains.

    We also see an increased focus on the 'S' in ESG - where the relationship between firms and their employees has become paramount to the recovery of both the economy and society as we know it. To echo the words of our CEO and chairman Larry Fink, ''the importance of serving stakeholders and embracing purpose is becoming increasingly central to the way that companies understand their role in society''. Now, more than ever, businesses serve a critical role in ensuring the jobs and livelihoods of their people. Businesses that are anchored by compassionate leadership and prioritise the physical, psychological and financial well-being of employees will be remembered and rewarded once the recovery takes hold.

    Francis Thangasamy VP, Product Management CenturyLink Asia Pacific

    THE Covid-19 situation has changed the way businesses are operating, and organisations need to be prepared for it. Companies need to balance the current and long-term vision of their business model to ensure they continue to drive cost efficiencies during this period and raise productivity of their employees to sustain business growth without compromising the safety of their employees. Organisations can take this opportunity to tap on the Budget to embrace digital transformation and get closer to their end customers, while continuing to upskill/reskill their employees to value-add in this digital age. Technology will continue to be a key enabler for industries, while also supporting businesses in retaining their competitive edge in the digital economy

    Andrew Chan Founder and CEO ACI HR Solutions (ACI)

    IN these trying times, all subsidies given by the Singapore government will act as a great cushion to most businesses. This said, ultimately, this may not save jobs or any business if their fundamentals aren't strong and Covid-19 is further protracted. We're in precarious times now, and when businesses emerge from this tunnel, they could be very different from when they entered it. This should force many CEOs to innovate or risk not surviving to take advantage of the inevitable upturn. Employees also need to ensure their readiness by taking this opportunity to upskill and gear up to meet the needs of a different workforce in the foreseeable future.

    Lim Soon Hock Managing Director PLAN-B ICAG

    THE Unity, Resilience, and Solidarity budgets are intended as disaster relief and are not economic stimulus measures. As such, the packages will alleviate the hardships faced by businesses, individuals and households, in varying degrees.

    As wages constitute a major cost item for businesses, it will help companies tide over the crisis, for as long as such subsidies are provided by the government. Despite this, it is inevitable that many companies that are already struggling prior to Covid-19 pandemic find it difficult to stay viable. Although the government has committed to do more if needed, which is a much welcome assurance, there is a limit to how much more the government can do, without crossing the threshold of bailing out all businesses at all costs.

    In this regard, the ball is in the court of companies to exploit this crisis to relook their business practices and models, be creative and innovative, to explore how technologies - even simple ones - can help them to stay intact and be prepared to resume activity much stronger when the circuit breaker is lifted. It is also a golden opportunity for companies to train, retrain or re-skill employees to deepen their skills and knowledge not only to save jobs and livelihoods but, equally important, to better prepare the business for the future.

    Eryk Lee Chief Executive Officer AAM Advisory

    OUR government has provided a generous package to save jobs and businesses and aim to restore normality as soon as possible. While the multi-billion dollar budget has provided immediate financial assistance for many, we need to be mindful that the root cause of all these is the spread of a virus. Until we can contain and stop the virus from spreading further, we are not out of the woods. We should also consider what is needed during the recovery phase of the economy. Four key points to note:

    (i) Everyone must continue to play our part to curb further spread by observing social distancing and stay at home.

    (ii) Once the spread is contained, there will be a recovery phase for many businesses, especially retailers. Cashflow, key to survival for these businesses, can be depleted very quickly. The government may need to continue providing them further cashflow support.

    (iii) Our SME sector is particularly vulnerable. The government must ensure it continues to help SMEs before and during the recovery phase.

    (iv) It is inevitable that jobs will be lost so a robust programme to help redeploy affected workers will also help with economic recovery, not forgetting the new graduates looking to enter the workforce too.

    P Ramakrishna Chief Executive Officer CIO Academy Asia

    THE government's economic response to the still evolving Covid-19 pandemic has been exemplary - a whole-of-government approach, agile in mobilising financial resources (three Budgets in seven weeks) and rapid (and at-scale) implementation to save jobs and companies.

    Yet, given that this pandemic may last beyond 12 months, the government may need to do more in the medium term to ensure that our workforce, including gig economy workers, can continue to put food on the table for their families. Unlike previous crises, the government now has to mandate the non-essential workforce to stay home rather than stimulate the economy through consumer spending. While the government is putting cash into the hands of Singaporeans, it will still not sustain them especially if this crisis draws on and retrenchments become inevitable as markets crash. The government may need to ensure that Singaporeans can continue to have their basic needs met even if they lose their jobs.

    Our national drive for digital transformation has also been given an unexpected boost by this pandemic. Let's continue to have our foot on this pedal, leveraging all the support we are getting to thrive in the digital world!

    Rathakrishnan Govind Chief Executive Officer London School of Business and Finance

    THE government's Resilience and Solidarity budgets to address the economic and social impact of Covid-19 are more than exceptional! As DPM Heng Swee Keat said, 'extraordinary times require extraordinary measures'. This is exactly what businesses and the people need to ride out these unprecedented circumstances. These are also opportunities for business transformation. Businesses should also take necessary creative initiatives to re-model their business operations. One thing we learn from this crisis is that going forward, things have changed permanently, and for the better. While no one can predict how long this crisis will last, the transformed businesses must strategise for contingencies on a worst-case scenario. It is not realistic for the government to continue dishing out support measures in the long run. Unfortunately, some businesses and jobs will be lost, but new ones will be created post-Covid-19.

    Dora Hoan CEO Best World International Ltd

    THE Solidarity Budget that was newly announced aims to further address the negative impacts on businesses and jobs following the announcement of the one-month ''circuit breaker'', including office closures. The budget is generous and timely.

    Together with the Unity Budget and Resilience Budget, this big total response of the government to Covid-19 is a great effort to help businesses cushion losses and survive the crisis through comprehensive strategies and appropriate measures covering the three key Cs (cash, credit, cost). On the whole, the compassion of the government to save jobs and businesses, and its determination to overcome this epidemic, should be recognised fully. If there is anything else that's needed, it must be that we must all do our part to be socially responsible and stay united in fighting the Covid-19 crisis.

    David Leong Managing Director PeopleWorldwide Consulting Pte Ltd

    THE government's S$60 billion response to Covid-19 comprising financial assistance to individuals and financial easing for businesses has one specific purpose - fluidity. Covid-19 has disrupted global supply chains and movement of capital, people, goods and services. Put simply, every day norms and regularity have been severely impacted. Movement of funds has slowed and people cannot earn their keep. Livelihoods are impacted. Without financial assistance and quantitative easing, getting about is hard.

    Businesses that are structurally weak may not survive and this is the harsh reality. This current pandemic is likely to knock down thousands of companies and many workers will lose their jobs. When the body crumples, it is hard to hold the pieces together. The only way is to deep freeze, to conserve and go into deep hibernation cutting expenses, wages and costs. Government must enforce a moratorium on all loans and mortgages for a period of three to six months and make all banks comply to ensure that businesses and individuals do not collapse with debt loads as that can cause a domino effect of falling cards and a quick spiral into a scary black hole.

    Zaheer Merchant Regional Director (Singapore & Europe) QI Group of Companies

    IN my view, the budgets will definitely help in some form. But the overall scale of the crisis is too large to be dependent on one (albeit strong) factor of safety. We are too dependent on the globalised economy to even know the exact impact of Covid-19 at this stage, and with estimates in the ''trillions'' in financial losses and ''millions'' in job losses, it's early days yet. Jobs and livelihoods are separate elements, yet interdependent conceptually. The key is placing money in people's hands to enable subsistence and survival for those at the lower rungs of the scale all the way to capex/opex needs for businesses. Drastic measures such as significant tax cuts and benefits, complete waivers and rebates on interest and financing, capital and operational expenditure, loans and ''free money'' to businesses (that are viable of course) have to be doled out and for an extended period of at least 18 months. Think Fanny Mae/Freddy Mac in the 2008 crisis. I believe there are limited options otherwise.

    George Lee VP, Asia Pacific & Japan RSA

    WHILE Singapore's supplementary budgets are laudable in supporting the nation to weather the storm, it is important to not overlook the need for cyber resilience during this crisis. In fact, cyber criminals are taking advantage of this period to conduct malicious activities such as phishing scams and ransomware attacks. Singapore as a nation can be vulnerable due to the highly interconnected nature of the city-state, where one tiny ''crack'' in the intricate digital network that links everyone together can result in serious damage. It is therefore necessary for the nation, businesses and people alike to strengthen their cyber readiness, with clear guidelines and measures provided, to ensure a strong, total defence in these worrying times. As a people, as a society, we are in this together. We need to be resilient and each do our part to get through this.

    READ MORE: S$9b injection for businesses, households in April: DPM Heng