Crypto’s retail traders hit hard as Strategy ETFs plunge 80%

[NEW YORK] Retail investors who piled into Michael Saylor’s grand Bitcoin experiment are paying a heavy price.

Strategy, the company once hailed for wrapping crypto exposure into a public stock, is scrambling to calm markets after its shares plunged more than 60 per cent from recent highs, amid a sweeping digital-currency rout.

On Monday (Dec 1), Strategy said that it had created a US$1.4 billion reserve to fund dividend and interest payments, hoping to calm fears that it may be forced to sell Bitcoin if prices fall further.

But for many investors, the damage is already done. The most popular exchange-traded funds (ETFs) tracking Strategy’s volatile stock, MSTX and MSTU, which offer double the daily return, have both dropped more than 80 per cent this year. That puts them among the 10 worst-performing funds in the entire US ETF market, out of more than 4,700 products currently trading – just behind obscure short bets against gold miners and semiconductor stocks.

A third fund, known as MSTP, launched during the crypto mania in June, is down a similar amount since its debut. Together, the trio has lost about US$1.5 billion in assets since early October.

Retail investors had poured into these funds when firms such as Defiance and Tuttle Capital Management launched the high-octane products tracking one of Wall Street’s most prominent Bitcoin-proxy trades.

But what began as an easy way to supercharge bets on crypto has become a cautionary tale of how leverage, volatility and sentiment can spiral. Strategy shares lost 34 per cent in November. Bitcoin has also dropped about 30 per cent from October highs and now trades near US$85,000. Strategy closed down 3.3 per cent on Monday, after slumping as much as 12 per cent earlier in the day.

“The recent pullback in Bitcoin has hit Strategy’s stock hard, and 2x leveraged plays like MSTX and MSTU turn that into even larger losses,” said Roxanna Islam, head of sector and industry research at ETF shop TMX VettaFi. “It’s a reminder that leveraged single-stock ETFs can look great on the way up, but can erase gains very quickly when the underlying trade goes the other way.”

Defiance declined to comment. Tuttle Capital and GraniteShares, which is behind MSTP, did not immediately respond to e-mails asking for comment.

SEE ALSO

Crypto downturn wipes out nearly US$1 billion in levered bets

Hong Kong stablecoin stocks slump after PBOC vows cryptocurrency crackdown

Crypto players find safe haven in Vietnam’s dual-city IFC

At the centre of concern is a valuation metric known as mNAV, or market net asset value, which compares Strategy’s enterprise value to its Bitcoin holdings. That premium has largely vanished, bringing the ratio to around 1.17, a level executives have flagged as a warning zone. CEO Phong Le said on a podcast that slipping below 1.0 could force the company to sell Bitcoin to meet payout obligations, albeit only as a last resort.

The newly announced reserve, funded by recent equity sales, is designed to head off that risk. It covers at least 21 months of dividend and interest payments. But the announcement did little to stop the broader slide – or address concerns about Strategy’s exposure to leverage, its dependence on retail appetite, and the mounting strain on its funding model.

To finance its Bitcoin buying spree, Strategy has repeatedly sold common stock, a controversial strategy that dilutes existing shareholders. As its valuation premium has eroded, the company has turned to issuing preferred shares and other costlier forms of capital to keep buying crypto.

Meanwhile, the ETF complex built around the Strategy is struggling. At least 15 such products tied to its shares in various ways are now trading, many down double digits this year, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Combined assets for MSTX, MSTU and MSTP have fallen from over US$2.3 billion in early October to around US$830 million today.

Crypto’s downturn, despite greater institutional participation and political support from the Trump White House, has triggered sharp drawdowns across miners, altcoins, and token-heavy corporate treasuries. Leveraged ETFs, which gained traction among at-home traders earlier this year, are now among the hardest hit.

The funds are built to double Strategy’s daily move, a structure that can backfire fast. In volatile markets, compounding gains and losses can chip away at returns even if the stock ends flat, a dynamic known as volatility decay. When Strategy shares tumbled and whipsawed, the ETFs did not just track the decline – they magnified it.

“Leveraged ETFs are generally a dangerous investment. A leveraged ETF on shares of a stock that levers up to buy a highly speculative asset is a risk profile of its own,” said Michael O’Rourke, chief market strategist at Jonestrading.

Now, even Strategy’s place in major stock indexes is under threat. Analysts at JPMorgan warned the company could be removed from benchmarks such as the MSCI USA and Nasdaq 100, a shift that might trigger billions in passive outflows. For a firm once floated as a potential S&P 500 candidate, the reversal is stark. BLOOMBERG