Retirement income puzzle: How much can you withdraw from your kitty?
DBS’ new digiPortfolio fills a gap for a “decumulation” product in the market. But there is room to reduce costs further
WHEN you retire, how much can you safely withdraw from your kitty to ensure your savings last as long as possible?
A financial adviser can easily model the future value of your portfolio and map your withdrawals in just a couple of clicks, plus advise you to adjust your asset allocation as you approach retirement.
But for do-it-yourself investors, continuing to invest, rebalance periodically, and later, withdraw for expenses in retirement can be tricky.
Enter DBS’ new DBS Retirement digiPortfolio, launched in partnership with JP Morgan Asset Management (JPMAM). The digiPortfolio will sit inside DBS’ digital banking app, which has an AI-powered financial planning capability under its “plan” tab. This was formerly called NAV Planner.
The digiPortfolio gives access to a pre-set asset allocation, which is a function of a client’s current age and desired retirement age. Funds are channelled into pre-selected JPMAM funds. By itself, that’s not rocket science. Today, with modest amounts, you can easily customise your asset allocation, pick funds using a robo platform, and invest regularly.
Glide path vs target date
But the digiPortfolio is a “glide path” – that is, it is designed to dial down your risk level as you near retirement. You remain invested even in retirement when you begin to draw down an income.
This is unlike “target-date” funds where the funds do turn more conservative over time, but they mature at a target year.
When target-date funds mature, clients have to find another vehicle or fund for the maturity amount. They also need to manually redeem units for their income needs. This takes us back to the original predicament: How do you know how much to redeem so that your kitty lasts a lifetime?
With the digiPortfolio, fund units are automatically redeemed according to your desired retirement income, without you having to decide which funds to redeem. The glide path applies until your portfolio is run down.
The way I see it, the innovation lies in the combination of DBS’ “Map your Money” (MYM) feature within the digibank app, with the digiPortfolio. MYM is able to model the future value of your savings, as well as graphically project a future withdrawal rate. At a glance, you can see at what age your savings would be depleted.
MYM also allows you to make inflation assumptions. You can adjust your withdrawals. Reducing the withdrawal amount ensures your funds last longer. The capability to model future amounts for those who use a regular savings plan in digiPortfolio will be rolled out later this year.
What’s not to like? I’ll get to that later.
Decumulation challenge
The digiPortfolio fills a gap in the marketplace for a “decumulation” or withdrawal model in retirement. It is easy to access and does not need a human adviser. It is positioned as a core portfolio for you to invest in regularly.
Anyone can use MYM, which means you can also put together your own low-cost portfolio of ETFs, for instance. But in retirement, when you need to draw down funds, you would have to decide which funds to redeem and by how much.
The integration of DBS’ digibank with SGFinDex (Singapore Financial Data Exchange) gives you a comprehensive view of assets outside DBS, including deposits and loans with other banks, your CPF, Supplementary Retirement Scheme and Central Depository (CDP) accounts, as well as insurance plans. This enables a holistic view of your personal assets.
Today, there is a wealth of products and services to help individuals save for retirement, but this isn’t so for the decumulation or drawdown phase in retirement – except for insurance.
Insurers do offer retirement income products, which are typically participating plans which rely on the insurer’s investment experience. Par plans’ total returns have guaranteed and non-guaranteed components. The payout or income distribution period may be fixed at 10 or 20 years, or even for life. You may not be able to instruct a higher or lower distribution.
Interestingly, Singapore isn’t unique in the dearth of decumulation products. Even mature markets such as the US and Australia grapple with this.
BlackRock chairman Larry Fink in his latest annual letter framed retirement as a challenge not just for saving, but perhaps even more so for spending. He wrote that a 2018 study of some 1,150 American retirees found that after nearly two decades of retirement, the average person still had 80 per cent of pre-retirement savings intact. Retirees were anxious about their finances. Only 32 per cent felt comfortable spending what they saved.
Fink wrote: “Because most defined contribution accounts don’t come with instructions for how much you can take out every month, individual savers first must build up a nest egg, then spend it down at a rate that will last them the rest of their lives. But who really knows how long that will be?”
BlackRock is rolling out the LifePath Paycheck this month in the US, to be made available to 500,000 employees under 14 retirement plan sponsors. This is basically a target-date strategy where at age 55, participants have the option to use a portion of their accumulated investment value – 30 per cent, for instance – to purchase an annuity from insurers pre-selected by BlackRock. The annuities are expected to provide a “paycheck for life”.
Compared with the US, Singapore is fortunate in a few ways. First, we already have our own individual retirement savings scheme under the CPF, where the employer and employee contribution rates are high. Second, CPF is the member’s own personal account regardless of any change in employer, unlike retirement accounts in the US. And third, we already have a no-cost annuity scheme under CPF Life to provide a base level of retirement income for life.
Target-date funds aren’t new in Singapore. UOB Asset Management’s GrowthPath (GP) portfolios were the first in the market in 2002. These funds have a fixed maturity period, and the risk exposure is automatically dialled down as they near maturity.
There was a total of five GP portfolios: GP Today (which is evergreen); GP 2010; GP 2020; GP 2030 and GP 2040. Assets raised at the 2002 launch exceeded S$308 million, where the largest portfolio was GP 2020 with S$235 million. GP 2010 and GP 2020 have matured.
There is also Prudential’s Prulink Adapt series, launched around 2005 and currently invested in Schroders funds. One portfolio matured in 2015. Two others will mature in 2025 and 2035.
Wrestling with costs
The caveat that I have on DBS’ Retirement digiPortfolio is that total costs are not low in the accumulation phase. There is no sales charge. But a flat annual management fee of 0.75 per cent applies on the overall portfolio level – in addition to JPMAM funds’ fees. All the funds are retail share classes.
JPMAM receives 20 basis points of the portfolio fee of 0.75 per cent. It also shares up to 60 per cent of the funds’ annual management fees with DBS as trail fees.
In retirement when withdrawals begin, the portfolio fee has been reduced to 25 basis points, which is a welcome development. When DBS briefed me last week, the fee was still 0.75 per cent even in the withdrawal phase – too high for a conservative portfolio which is 82 per cent invested in bond funds and 15 per cent in equities.
JPMAM’s fixed income funds for the digiPortfolio have fees ranging from 0.4 per cent for a government bond fund to 1.15 per cent for emerging market bonds. All the equity funds have fees of 1.5 per cent.
At a time when the institutional share classes of funds can be purchased elsewhere, and since this is meant to be a long-term retirement account, there is ample room to further reduce fees. In the accumulation phase the total effective fee could be as much as 2.25 per cent.
After all, in investing, the mathematical impact of costs is clear. All things being equal, lower costs result in higher returns, and this should be a key criterion for retirement portfolios.