US-listed active ETFs: Easier access on the cards?
Hong Kong has greenlit foreign-listed active ETFs under the master-feeder structure. Will Singapore follow suit? Read on for tax implications of direct investment in US funds
UNIT trusts are an established fixture in Singapore’s investment landscape. What’s the likelihood that they could be disrupted by the onset of actively managed exchange traded funds (ETFs)?
To date there is only one active ETF listed on the Singapore Exchange. But there are many brokerages here as well as robo platforms through which you can invest directly in an active ETF listed in New York and other jurisdictions.
Active ETFs offer advantages over traditional unit trusts, including ease of trading and transparency over the underlying holdings as well as the market price of the units. In traditional funds in Singapore, while valuation is done at the end of every business day, the net asset value price is made known only days later. Disclosure of fund holdings is even more infrequent; fact sheets are published monthly and disclose the top 10 holdings only.
Fees of active ETFs are also generally lower than unit trusts’ fees, but investors may incur transaction costs to invest, such as a brokerage fee and bid-ask spread.
Active ETFs are seeing a blistering pace of growth globally, even though their share of the overall ETF market as at end-March is relatively small at 6.7 per cent. But in terms of annual compounded growth rate, they punch far above their asset size – growing at two to three times the rate of the overall ETF market. At end-March, total assets in global ETFs is estimated at US$12.5 trillion, and active ETFs account for US$838 billion.
In the US, some of the largest and best known asset managers are piling onto the active ETF cart and reaping the benefits of size. Dimensional Fund Advisors (DFA) is the largest in active ETFs with assets under management (AUM) of US$133 billion, giving it a market share of 20 per cent.
JP Morgan Asset Management (JPMAM) is the second largest with AUM of US$113 billion, and a share of 17 per cent. As at end-2023, JPMAM boasts 113 ETFs globally. Of these, 27 ETFs have crossed the US$1 billion asset threshold. The largest is the S&P EPI (Equity Premium Income) ETF, managed with an options strategy, with US$32.5 billion in assets.
In the US, there is also a growing trend of conversions of mutual funds into active ETFs. BlackRock filed to convert its US$700 million BlackRock International Dividend Fund into an ETF. Bloomberg reported that around 70 mutual funds have been converted into ETFs, representing about US$100 billion in assets.
Citing data from the Investment Company Institute, Bloomberg reported that over US$65 billion exited mutual funds so far in 2024, while ETFs absorbed more than US$250 billion. Last year outflows from mutual funds came to US$656 billion, while ETFs raked in US$578 billion. BT understands demand is also driven by fee-based advisory firms.
US-listed ETFs: tax implications
JPMAM has designs on Asia, where Philippe El-Asmar, head of Apac ETF, digital and direct, is speaking to regulators in efforts to “streamline” the approval process in various jurisdictions. He hopes that fund offerors of US ETFs may at least be allowed to offer investor education through intermediaries such as brokerages, even if direct selling remains off-limits.
Today, the biggest hurdle is that US-listed ETFs are typically not recognised by regulators in Asia, and not allowed to be marketed directly in jurisdictions including Singapore.
Many regulators in Asia recognise the European fund passport, which is the UCITS (Undertaking for Collective Investment in Transferable Securities) structure, where funds are typically domiciled in Luxembourg and/or Dublin. But the US fund structure is seen as incompatible in Asia, due to concerns about comparable investor protection, among others.
There are also tax implications of a direct investment in a US fund, which can significantly raise the cost of investment, which most individuals may not be aware of. Depending on whether there is a tax treaty with the investor’s country of residence, payouts of dividends or income may be subject to a withholding tax of up to 30 per cent. For Singapore, the withholding tax on US funds’ payouts is 30 per cent. Withholding tax does not apply to accumulation ETFs which don’t distribute dividends.
In addition, the US has a global tax system and will subject investments in US assets to estate duty, even if the investor is neither a US citizen nor resident.
Some Asian jurisdictions do allow the master-feeder structure for ETFs, where assets in the feeder fund are invested in the master fund which is set up in a recognised or accepted fund jurisdiction, where such tax issues do not arise. The feeder fund would be listed in the domestic stock exchange.
But this process requires separate registrations of individual US ETFs as UCITS schemes by the fund manager, in addition to maintaining a cross-listing. Cross-listings, says El-Asmar, have been consolidating.
“If you were to locally list an ETF, the disadvantage is that there’s no natural flow until the product grows locally. So that’s why actually very little, almost no ETF issuers now cross-list their products. They incur costs as well. In Australia, 10 years ago, a couple of US issuers cross-listed 20 or 30 ETFs; they’ve delisted all of them. In Hong Kong, there were cross-listings of many European ETFs from European issuers; they’ve delisted. So it’s not really a viable proposition.”
Shifting landscape
The landscape, however, is shifting. Japan has allowed registration of US-listed ETFs. Hong Kong also broadened the master-feeder offerings to overseas-listed master ETFs – including active ETFs – “provided that they have satisfactory safeguards in place and demonstrable benefits to the Hong Kong market”.
El-Asmar says: “The ETF industry needs to have a dialogue. And in my opinion, opening up the US ETF market might be the key to the success of ETFs in this market. I think it has to happen by step because in order to do this master-feeder structure, you still need to approve the US ETFs. You cannot do this in Singapore today under the master-feeder structure because (US funds) are not recognised yet.”
In Singapore, the master-feeder model applies to the ETFs linked with Chinese exchanges. Under this scheme, the master ETFs are listed on the Shenzhen Stock Exchange or Shanghai Stock Exchange.
El-Asmar is hoping that Singapore would allow a “notification” regime similar to Japan, where US ETFs can be simply lodged and information on them can be disseminated by intermediaries including banks and brokers.
“We’re potentially having conversations with the Monetary Authority of Singapore to have a possibility of (being allowed) to talk about our US or UCITS ETFs in Singapore. Today, we’re not allowed to advertise those products because they’re not (recognised).” He believes a notification regime which allows investor education efforts will go a long way to expand the ETF market in Asia.
“Singapore accepts UCITS as an equivalent regime, but they don’t yet accept the US as it is. This may be a big area that could open up the biggest market for ETFs, which is the US.” The US has a share of almost 70 per cent of the global overall ETF market of US$12.5 trillion.
Meanwhile, an article on Endowus.com explains the cost impact of the 30 per cent withholding tax on ETF dividends and estate tax imposed by the US. Using Vanguard’s US-listed VWO, an emerging markets ETF, as an example, the VWO has an expense ratio of 0.08 per cent and a dividend yield of about 3.5 per cent.
A dividend withholding tax of 30 per cent would raise the effective cost of the fund from 0.08 per cent to 1.1 per cent, “and these costs would compound over the long term due to your choice of funds with inappropriate domiciliation for you”.
As for estate taxes, US-listed assets (ETFs included) are subject to up to 40 per cent US estate tax rate. This is equivalent to US$400,000 if your US investments are worth US$1 million.
TRENDING NOW
Motoring tycoon Peter Kwee is back in court: Here are his previous legal battles
Peter Kwee’s Ridley Park bungalow on the market with S$100 million asking price
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman