Decoding greenwashing in climate investing
An approach that combines corporate engagement, carbon pricing mechanisms and Just Transition principles can help to fend off greenwashing
At a recent press conference, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong remarked that climate change is the existential challenge of our time. This perspective is widely shared. Asian families increasingly tell us that they want to preserve wealth, and to do so in a way that ensures that future generations have a livable planet. As a result, many have turned to Environmental, Social and Governance (“ESG”) investing, in particular, climate-themed investments – or climate investing.
The proliferation of climate investing, however, presents the issue of greenwashing - the over-representation of an investment’s impact towards an environmental agenda. Unsurprisingly, this has now become a top-of-mind issue for families and wealth owners who demand that their capital drives real, positive impact and targets competitive financial returns. For managers of capital, the answer to decoding greenwashing can be found in an approach that combines corporate engagement, carbon pricing mechanisms and Just Transition principles.
Actions speak louder than words: active engagement with companies
Some investors traditionally relied on a relatively simplistic way of responsible investing by investing in sustainability leaders, or divesting from high-emitting sectors, such as fossil fuels. On the surface, these appear to be an effective way to “vote with their wallets”. In reality, this model only decarbonises an investment portfolio, but not the world. Investors that pull investments out of high-emitting sectors will be simply replaced by investors who do not have a climate agenda. Carbon emissions carry on, business as usual.
To avoid this, investors should make it a point to engage with companies in their portfolios, holding boards and management teams accountable for setting and meeting climate targets. Taking reference from the Net Zero Investment Framework, engagement should be the primary tool while divestment is the last resort, should companies fail to meet interim milestones over a pre-determined period of time. For smaller-size managers of capital, such as family offices, company engagement can be a labour-intensive exercise and technical knowledge on climate change might be limited. Participating in collective investor consortia, such as the Asia Investor Group on Climate Change (“AIGCC”), not only gives them strength in numbers, but also serves as a platform to share experiences among like-minded investors. Such collective investor action could renew the sense of urgency for businesses to decarbonise.
Putting a price on carbon
To create real impact, an increasing number of responsible investors are encouraging corporates to adopt internal carbon pricing (“ICP”), a mechanism to make carbon emissions a financial reality, nudging corporates towards a low-carbon choice. A 2021 survey found that more than 2,000 companies are disclosing or are planning to use an ICP, which includes half of the world’s 500 biggest companies.
Within this space, corporates are progressively using a “shadow pricing” policy, which puts a theoretical cost of carbon emissions from business activities, from R&D to procurement. Some businesses take a further step to charge an “internal fee”- carbon-emission costs on operational decisions – which can then be used to fund low-carbon projects.
To ensure real impact, investors should rigorously evaluate companies’ ICP methodologies, and weigh their actual impact on operations and business decisions, making sure companies are not just applying a token price to tick the box. In fact, the same survey found the median ICP set by companies was US$25 per metric ton of carbon emissions, which is significantly lower than expert calculations that it should be at least US$100.
Buying carbon credits remains one of the most familiar instruments to companies to offset their emissions. The system presents unique challenges due to a mixture of varied carbon standards, and decentralized management of voluntary carbon credits registries, among other issues. Investors’ role here is to advocate for companies to purchase credits only from standards which adhere to strict and consistent levels of the principles, such as those recommended by the Taskforce on Scaling Voluntary Carbon Markets (“TSVCM”). Ultimately, carbon offsets should be used only as a short-term strategy for companies where there is currently no technologically or financially viable alternative to their emissions, such as in aviation or steel manufacturing.
Just Transition principles are crucial to climate investing in Asia
Being rooted in Asia, home to some of the world’s largest emerging economies, we witness first-hand how climate change affects emerging countries disproportionately relative to developed ones, despite the latter accounting for most of the historical emissions in the atmosphere. Without nuanced and contextualised understanding of local conditions, the expectation of sustainability best practices or the pace of adoption by companies may be misguided or unrealistic. Asia also houses the majority of the world’s new wealth, with many in the population having benefitted from cheap and stable energy. Hence, Asian families are ideally placed to engage with companies on Just Transition principles, as they better understand the balance between achieving climate change and social development goals.
The concept of Just Transition is critical to Asia’s low-carbon transition. Therefore, investors and corporates, in meeting emissions goals, must give due consideration to the transition of the whole ecosystem. For example, high-emission industries, such as coal, remain amongst the biggest employers (in formal and informal sectors) in some Asian cities, and are the largest tax-revenue contributors. A “blanket” shutdown of coal plants without consideration for the people working in them severely impacts the livelihoods and communities, as well as state subsidies within the economy. In fact, this principle is enshrined in global initiatives such as Climate Action 100+, which includes commitment to Just Transition principles as an indicator of a net-zero company. A number of well-established platforms exist to help investors better grasp the local context, and adopt strategies that ensure that climate investing does not inadvertently undermine the long-term sustainability of the business and the communities it operates in, such as the AIGCC Asian Utilities Engagement Program.
The way forward
Overcoming greenwashing can seem to be an impossible hill to climb, but complexity is not a reason for inaction. If humanity is ultimately looking to limit our planet’s temperature rise to 1.5°C by 2050, we cannot circumvent the financing of the decarbonisation process. We have to bite the bullet and forge ahead with open eyes and a strong will.
The cart (climate change) is already before the horse (financing pathways). We cannot wait until the stars are aligned before we take the plunge – we have to figure it out as we go. The time to take action on climate change was yesterday.
The writer is head of ESG Research, Maitri Asset Management.
TRENDING NOW
Who is Leo KoGuan, the Singapore-based billionaire backing Nvidia’s Jensen Huang?
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Higher rates, weaker spending: Is the Philippines entering stagflation?
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman