Investors question valuation and liquidity of private equity holdings, says MSCI executive

Summarise
Genevieve Cua
Published Tue, Sep 30, 2025 · 06:50 PM
阅读简体中文版 (beta)
    • MSCI's chief research and development officer Ashley Lester says the rate of distributions of private equity funds has fallen to around 7 per cent in the first quarter of 2025.
    • MSCI's chief research and development officer Ashley Lester says the rate of distributions of private equity funds has fallen to around 7 per cent in the first quarter of 2025. PHOTO: MSCI

    [SINGAPORE] Sophisticated asset owners are raising urgent questions on the valuation and liquidity of their private-asset holdings, particularly private equity (PE), where the pressure for exits remains intense, said MSCI chief research and development officer Ashley Lester.

    “The rate of distributions of PE funds has fallen from a low-20 per cent rate in 2022 to 2024, to around 7 per cent in the first quarter,” he said. “That makes liquidity questions much more pressing and also raises questions about the valuation of those companies,” he added, also noting that liquidity in PE has fallen.

    In addition, PE funds also grapple with a leverage squeeze – that is, buyouts funded via higher debt loads face elevated coupon costs that threaten their ability to cover interest expenses.

    Typically, exits in the buyout strategy tend to heavily correlate with the last 12 months of stock market performance, but that relationship appears to have broken.

    One explanation, Lester said, could be that the relationship takes time to emerge.

    A second reason, he said, may be that public equity returns “have been very concentrated in a few mega-cap stocks”. “With the exception of a couple of private companies like OpenAI, most private companies are not in the mega-cap range.”

    He also observed that valuation multiples of sold assets of PE funds are less than those held in portfolios. This is an inversion of the model that typically drives value creation in PE, where companies are bought at a certain earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (Ebitda) multiple, and then sold at a higher multiple.

    “Typically GPs (general partners) sell their best companies fastest. Maybe GPs are saying, ‘I don’t want to sell anything. I’ll sell a bad company to raise some money and hold onto my good stuff for when times are better’,” said Lester.

    “But that doesn’t seem to be true because if we look at earnings growth, margins and leverage of sold assets versus held, it looks like the small number of companies GPs are selling are very much their best companies.”

    For more than a decade until 2021, except in 2009, buyout GPs have exited assets at a higher median multiple than those held in portfolios, with premiums ranging from 0.1 to 1.1 times.

    But from 2022 through Q3 2024, exited assets were sold at lower median multiples than those still remaining in the portfolio – by 0.5 to 1.1 times.

    Abdulla Zaid, vice-president of MSCI research and development, noted in a blog post: “This reversal has raised questions about the resilience of the held assets’ valuations, especially in the face of ongoing macro headwinds…

    “Held assets are grappling with contracting profitability and rising leverage. These conditions not only signal deeper valuation risks for future exits but also raise questions about the underlying sources of value creation amid downward pressure on valuation multiples.”

    Still, based on MSCI’s global closed-end fund indexes, PE generated a Q2 return of 4.2 per cent, its strongest quarterly return since 2021. But the firm also noted: “With exit activity still limited, translating paper gains into actual distributions continues to be the key challenge for investors.”

    Separately, Adeline Tan, partner and head of investments (Asia) at Mercer, expressed caution on the rise of continuation funds and secondaries that are seeking investments from capital owners.

    Continuation funds are set up by GPs and involve the transfer of assets from an existing fund which is near the end of its life cycle. Secondaries refer to the overall market of reselling existing fund holdings or assets.

    “We get pitched by so many continuation funds and secondaries because we globally advise a lot of corporate pensions, which have deployed quite a lot into private markets. But when interest rates started to rise, they started to hit a de-risking trigger where they look at their private markets allocation and say – we don’t need so much of this anymore,” said Tan.

    “Some are looking to sell. And they come to Mercer for help. This is an area Mercer is actively helping clients to resolve.”

    But she also raises concern on the quality of assets that are being transferred into continuation funds. “Sometimes things sound too good to be true. When someone is shopping an asset around, on the basis that it’s a mature portfolio with no J-curve, there are two elements there that we are cautious about. One, is this deal actually a dying effort? You could be buying into a portfolio of stranded assets, which may still have an income distribution, but its life may be finite. It’s our job to look into the income and capital implications for investors.”

    Some continuation funds, she said, are “a little bit of a refinancing play, rather than a pure PE investment looking for transformation and a (return) booster”.

    Bain’s mid-year 2025 report for PE noted that the lack of liquidity remains painful for investors and firms. Limited partners are increasingly turning to the secondaries market to rebalance their portfolios or raise cash.

    Bain said buyout fundraising remains challenged, and hope for recovery has likely been pushed out to 2026 or beyond. More than 18,000 private capital funds are collectively seeking US$3.3 trillion in investment.

    “That means there’s about US$3 of demand out there for every US$1 of supply. It remains to be seen how much the emergence of private wealth as a source of funding can ease this mismatch by boosting supply.”