Lower trough, deeper cuts
The US-China trade war could see Asia ex-Japan slowing further and reaching a trough by 1Q20.
AS US-CHINA trade tensions have oscillated between de-escalation and escalation, the growth slowdown in the Asia-ex-Japan region has unfolded in slow motion. Indeed, the prior nascent recovery has given way to a double-dip, with regional growth having eased to the lowest quarterly pace since the second quarter of 2009 during the Global Financial Crisis.
The outcome of trade tensions is key to the timing and pace of recovery. Our base case assumes that the US implements the announced tariffs in October and December, which will keep global growth, as well as the region's growth, weak over the near term.
In recent weeks, we have had goodwill gestures from both sides, such as China's resumption of agriculture purchases and the US delaying the next round of tariffs by two weeks. Talks are set to resume, raising expectations for a goodwill agreement that brings a pause in escalation.
If it were to happen, a goodwill agreement where the US postpones the October and December rounds of tariffs for longer due to progress in negotiations, would be a positive, and we could see a modest pace of recovery.
However, a durable pause, which embodies a comprehensive resolution of trade tensions, is essential for a robust and durable rebound.
On the back of our assumptions in our base case, we think Asia-ex-Japan's growth is likely to slow further from here before reaching a trough in 1Q20.
This is as the tariff tensions spill over via the direct channel of trade and supply chains, as well as via the indirect channel of corporate confidence and capex cutbacks.
As it stands, recent trade data points and domestic demand indicators in the region have mostly stayed soft or weakened further over the third quarter of 2019. To that point, Korea's first 20 days' export numbers in September have continued to stay weak.
Overall, we think that in an environment in which the global economy faces sub-par growth, Asia-ex-Japan economies that run a current account surplus and have higher trade linkages are likely more exposed compared to the economies with a current account deficit and an endogenous domestic demand base. In particular, the latter group also benefits more from the US Fed easing.
In this context, we see three groups in Asia-ex-Japan, with China, Hong Kong, Korea, Taiwan and Singapore as the most exposed economies to trade tensions. Malaysia and Thailand are moderately exposed, while India, Indonesia and the Philippines are less exposed.
There have been questions about whether a shift in trade and FDI patterns driven by US-China tension and the Japan-Korea trade dispute could benefit some exporters and provide a growth cushion.
We think some economies could benefit on a relative basis in the medium term. However in the near term, trade uncertainty will likely continue to weigh on sentiment, causing companies to delay or cancel capex plans.
Ultimately, we think the speed and scale at which any of these economies gain export share and FDI share in a shrinking pie is unlikely to offset the negative spillover from trade tensions and avert the double-dip in the near term.
With growth uncertainty continuing to linger, more easing should be in the offing. We expect further rate cuts by central banks in China, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, Korea, the Philippines and Thailand.
Meanwhile, we also expect Singapore to reduce the S$NEER appreciation slope at the October 2019 review, and potentially lower the slope to zero at the following April 2020 review. The sole exception is Taiwan, where we see the central bank standing pat. Between monetary and fiscal policy, we think fiscal policy is likely the more effective policy tool in this cycle.
This is because there has not been material deleveraging since the global financial crisis and private sector balance sheets in several economies still look over-extended.
Moreover, policy rates for some central banks in the region are also not far off the post-global financial crisis lows, which further limits the space for rate cuts.
In other words, the public sector is the sector which can still afford to lever up and we see scope for more active fiscal policy. So far, the biggest fiscal pump-priming has been in China; and India has recently announced significant cuts to the corporate income tax rate, which we think will help to support private sector confidence and private sector capex.
A comprehensive resolution to trade tension and a more aggressive fiscal policy stance are needed to drive a stronger recovery in the region.
The writer is Asia economist with Morgan Stanley.
TRENDING NOW
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman
Higher rates, weaker spending: Is the Philippines entering stagflation?
Who is Leo KoGuan, the Singapore-based billionaire backing Nvidia’s Jensen Huang?
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista