Pimco fund hit by pullouts, infighting

Clients withdrawing for 10 months running, feud between co-founder and partner results in latter's quitting, reports ALEXIS LEONDIS

Published Tue, Mar 11, 2014 · 10:00 PM

    [NEW YORK] BILL Gross, in an investment outlook in April entitled Man in the Mirror, questioned whether he was truly a great investor as he pondered his legacy in a new era of shrinking bond returns.

    Almost a year later, his largest fund, the US$236 billion Pimco Total Return, is trailing rivals, prompting clients to pull money for 10 straight months, and the 69-year-old is entangled in an ugly split from his former heir apparent Mohamed El-Erian, 55, with allegations of phone surveillance and public humiliations - painting a picture of Mr Gross as an autocratic leader struggling to maintain his composure.

    The departure of Mr El-Erian and other top executives in the past year has become a distraction at a critical time for Pacific Investment Management Co (Pimco's full name), the Newport Beach, California firm he co-founded in 1971 and built into the world's largest fixed-income manager amid a three-decade rally in bonds. As rising interest rates worldwide have prompted investors to flee bond strategies this past year, Mr Gross's ability to improve returns is crucial for Pimco to reverse client redemptions.

    Mr Gross's Pimco Total Return Fund fell 0.6 per cent in the past year, trailing 76 per cent of rivals and underperforming the Barclays US Aggregate Index, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. This year, the fund has advanced 1.45 per cent, ahead of 56 per cent of peers.

    "No distractions here - just long-term performance satisfaction - working hard as always for clients," Mr Gross wrote in a message on micro-blogging site Twitter.com.

    In April, he wrote an investment outlook where he examined his legacy as an investor, and said his returns and those of investors such as Warren Buffett, Dan Fuss and George Soros were helped by investing in an era of expanding credit that started in the early 1970s, when gold was de-linked from the dollar.

    The billionaire's introspection came just as bond markets entered a period of turmoil after then Fed chairman Ben Bernanke signalled in May that the central bank would start unwinding its asset purchases. Investors then pulled out a record US$9.6 billion from Pimco Total Return in June, according to data from Morningstar Inc.

    Tensions between Mr Gross and Mr El-Erian mounted around that time as performance stumbled and withdrawals continued, according to two people familiar with the firm who asked not to be identified.

    In front of more than a dozen of the firm's top investment executives in an investment committee meeting in June, Mr Gross said he had a 41-year track record of investing excellence, then turned to Mr El-Erian and asked what he could point to, said the people. Mr El-Erian announced his resignation from Pimco on Jan 21 and declined to comment on the meeting.

    "Well, I think Mohamed's investment record stands for itself as does mine and I would invite any reader to draw their own individual comparisons through publicly released performance numbers," Mr Gross said in an e-mailed statement on March 2. "Collectively, however, we are world class, winners of more Morningstar Manager of the Year awards than any other firm by far."

    The Wall Street Journal first reported details of the June meeting on Feb 25. The newspaper, citing unnamed people, said the two gentlemen disagreed over trading strategy, personnel decisions, new products and Mr Gross's treatment of employees.

    Mr Gross later told Reuters he had evidence that Mr El-Erian is trying to "undermine" him by talking to the media about conflicts at Pimco, according to a March 6 story published on the news organisation's website. Mr Gross said Mr El-Erian "wrote" the article published in the Wall Street Journal and "indicated" he had been monitoring Mr El-Erian's phone calls, Reuters reported.

    A Pimco spokesman told Reuters that Mr Gross didn't make those statements, and that he "categorically denies" that his firm listened in on Mr El-Erian's phone calls.

    Pimco suffered record redemptions of US$41.1 billion in the Total Return Fund last year, based on data from Morningstar. Clients pulled a net US$1.6 billion from the fund in February, Pimco said, even as investors put US$3.5 billion into all bond mutual funds last month, according to estimates from Investment Company Institute.

    The redemptions don't include institutional accounts. Pimco's assets under management fell to US$1.91 trillion as at Dec 31, from a peak of US$2.04 trillion (March 31).

    Mr Gross's returns are still among the best in the industry over the long run. Pimco Total Return Fund beat 96 per cent of peers over the past 15 years, according to Morningstar. By his own standards, that may not be enough unless he can adapt to a changing market.

    "Am I a great investor?" Mr Gross wrote in his April investment outlook. "No, not yet." - Bloomberg