Profiting by going against bullish market

Hedge fund Universa Investments has been set up to make money in an economic and financial collapse

Published Tue, Nov 25, 2014 · 09:50 PM

New York

THE stock market has been rising for years, hitting new highs almost every week. So how is it that one of Wall Street's most bearish investors can claim to have profited strongly over this period?

Universa Investments, a hedge fund founded by Mark Spitznagel, is one of the few firms that is set up with the aim of making money in an economic and financial collapse. In the market turmoil of 2008, Mr Spitznagel earned large returns. Large pessimistic bets usually lose a lot of money when stocks are rising, as they have ever since 2009. But Universa is saying that its investment strategy has been able to produce consistent gains since then, including a 30 per cent return last year, according to firm materials that were reviewed by The New York Times. In comparison, the benchmark Standard & Poor's 500 stock index in 2013 had a return of 32 per cent with dividends reinvested.

Insurance policies that pay out after disasters do not produce big returns when the catastrophe fails to occur. But since 2008, some investors have been looking for ways to ride the market higher while having bets in place that will notch up huge gains if the system teeters on the brink once again. At Universa, Mr Spitznagel's strategy stems from his scepticism towards government efforts to revive the economy. He acknowledges that the stimulus policies of the Federal Reserve and other central banks have the power to drive stocks higher. But they will ultimately be self-defeating, he contends.

This theory holds that another crash will occur when the Fed stops being able to stoke the economy. Universa's strategy seeks to profit when confidence in the central banks is strong - and when it evaporates. "The Fed has created a trap in this yield-chasing environment," Mr Spitznagel said. "It allows you to be long, but it gets you in position to be short when it's all over," he said.

Ups and downs

On Wall Street, being long means holding stocks and betting they will rise, while being short means wagering that they will fall. The news that Universa has been producing strong returns since 2009 will surprise many on Wall Street. In previous media reports, Mr Spitznagel seemed content with descriptions that his fund had small losses each year as he wagered against the market. The recent fund materials that contain the positive numbers may be marketing materials aimed at selling a type of financial catastrophe insurance to investors who are getting jittery about the stock markets' gravity-defying rise.

The materials show how bearish bets could be paired with broad holdings of stocks - and still produce gains. The Universa strategy has produced gains of 10 per cent this year, slightly less than the stock market overall. It's been up every year since 2008, according to the materials. The footnotes state that the performance numbers are hypothetical - and may differ from actual results.

Universa is not alone in saying that it can make money in good times and bad. Other firms also offer bearish bets that clients can use to hedge their stock portfolios. Such bets often cost so much that they have to be used sparingly.

Yet, Universa seems to be saying that its catastrophe insurance is comparatively cheap. The Universa marketing materials say that its strategy would theoretically result in a 16 per cent gain if the S&P 500 fell 30 per cent. A Wall Street hedging specialist said that adding such a bearish bet to a big holding of stocks could erase as much as 8 per cent from the value of the portfolio each year.

Mr Spitznagel, however, contends that Universa's hedge costs far less than that. Universa, he said, has been able to buy protection against a stock market crash at a price that makes the firm's overall strategy viable. But doing so has not been easy, he contended.

Mr Spitznagel is certain that another collapse will come. He hails from the Austrian school of economics that believes great harm can result when a central bank holds interest rates at low levels for a long time. The cheap money prompts investments across the economy that will later prove uneconomical and go sour, the Austrians say.

But Paul Kasriel, an economist at the Legacy Private Trust Co, who is sympathetic to the Austrian school, does not share that pessimism. Fed policies, he notes, have influenced the economy for a hundred years and they do not always lead to disaster.

"The real issue is whether we are going to have the sort of collapse that followed the housing bubble," Mr Kasriel said. "I don't see that right now." NYT