Taking shelter from a potential negative convergence

It would likely be prudent for investors to reduce exposure to US equities and look towards capital preservation

Published Fri, Nov 23, 2018 · 09:50 PM

A year ago, the world was talking about a convergence in economic growth amid a "goldilocks" period of low inflation that would see benign monetary policy help sustain moderate economic growth. It was the view that such conditions would help earnings growth.

This consensus expectation has failed to pan out. Most of the world has seen growth decelerate, alongside declining earnings growth and higher bond yields, a cocktail that has seen most stock markets post losses on a year-to-date basis, with the US equity market one of the few exceptions.

While the rest of the world has shown a decline in business activity, economic and earnings growth, the US has continued to outperform thus far in 2018 on the back of a temporary boost via the tax cuts implemented late last year.

I believe that we will indeed see a convergence, but one that sees the US converge negatively with the rest of the world, given the list of potential global issues that are increasing as well as what I think are peak earnings growth rates.

Sugar rush not likely to last

One of the key reasons for the outperformance of the US relative to its peers in 2018 has been the fiscal stimulus in the form of temporary tax cuts implemented late last year. While this has provided a sugar rush for business activity and corporate earnings, the effects are not expected to last beyond this year. A quick look at the difference in growth between earnings before and after taxes in 2018 highlights the positive impact the tax cuts have had.

Looking to the future, as we ought to do when investing, earnings growth is expected to decelerate from the estimated 22 per cent pace in 2018 to just below 10 per cent in 2019, a figure that is more in-line with estimates of earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation (Ebitda).

The deceleration in earnings growth is likely to be caused partly by the expiry of the tax breaks, but also due to a general deceleration in the US economy. With several forward looking indicators such as the purchasing manager indices and consumer confidence at or close to peaking, combined with a weak housing market (that is typically seen as a leading indicator), there is room for the US economy to take a step back and cool down from its tax cut-fuelled pace seen in 2018.

Based on the popular price-to-earnings valuation metric, US equities look inexpensive at 15.3 times price-to-earnings based on 2019's estimated earnings, compared to its historical average of about 15-16 times earnings. However, a look at price-to-Ebitda shows that US equities are broadly trading at levels that really warrant caution.

Compounding the issues above are the current equity risk premium of US equities as well as the current yield of US Treasuries. The current equity risk premium of US equities is estimated to be around 3.1 per cent, a figure that is low relative to its historical average of about 3.8 per cent. The US 10-year Treasury currently yields about 3.1 per cent. For US equities to maintain the same relative valuation to the US 10-year Treasury, it will need to be priced lower to absorb the higher yields.

Look to safety of fixed income

Based on the assumption of a 3.5 per cent equity risk premium as well as a 3.2 per cent US 10-year Treasury yield, the S&P 500 should see a contraction of the valuation multiple and should be looking at the 2200 price region, close to minus 20 per cent from where we are today in the 2750 region as of the time of writing.

Given the potential sizeable decline from the 2750 region, investors looking to shield themselves from the possible convergence of the US to the rest of the world could reduce their exposure to US equities and look to the safety of fixed income, particularly US Treasuries or a short duration bond fund for capital preservation.

The Nikko AM Shenton Short Term Bond fund is one of the short duration bond funds that investors could consider. Sporting a yield-to-maturity of 3.51 per cent and a duration of just 1.16 years as at Oct 26, 2018, the fund is well-shielded from interest rate risk while providing a really decent yield of over 3 per cent.

With 113 holdings and an average portfolio credit rating of A-, the fund does not appear to take on much concentration or credit risk, a position which should stand it in good stead in the face of downgrades to global earnings estimates that could affect weak borrowers, particularly in the non-investment grade space.

While a yield of just over 3 per cent might sound unattractive and perhaps boring, in the face of a potential minus 20 per cent decline in US equities and potential spill-over effects on other stock markets, investors could look to reduce their exposure to US equities and look towards capital preservation and not expose oneself to too much risk.