A tale of two infections
CAN you contain Covid with cash? Or is it contained with better health measures? The United States and many Western countries seem to believe they have little to learn from China or Singapore so their response is that you can contain Covid with a trillion-dollar rescue package. Singapore believes Covid containment is achieved through strict contact tracing, isolation and quarantine measures and a rapid public health response.
Fiscal support is essential, but it works more effectively if it is combined with effective public health measures.
The economic consequences of these two approaches are vastly different and this shapes the investment decisions we need to make. It also has a substantial impact on the way markets recover. Covid is pushing us towards an isolated world with locked down borders so one of the collateral impacts is a severe reduction in international trade. That has particular economic consequences for Singapore as a logistics hub and for countries like China with a large export sector.
China has a choice and we expect to see that choice to be exercised in coming months. China can choose to reduce its dependency on export markets and substitute it with increased domestic demand and a faster move towards an e-community based on superior 5G services and AI developments.
Singapore has less choice as its economy will remain anchored in its role as a logistics hub. Singapore Airlines and Port of Singapore Authority and associated logistics frameworks will recover but the speed and nature of the recovery is dependent upon European and American recovery trajectories.
A disturbing narrative has developed in American media which suggests that China is responsible for Covid and should be punished in some way. This narrative continues with the idea that China is using Covid as a covert means of extending its soft power influence. China aid to Italy and elsewhere is treated with suspicion.
That narrative suggests a potential hardening of global investment flows, with Chinese investment in particular, being less welcome. Investors may need to make a choice of quite separate investment spheres, so we assess the outlook of each.
Last month the focus was on the potential to develop a head-and-shoulder reversal pattern in the Dow. That potential depended upon a sustained rebound from near 24,500. This did not develop as the Dow continued to plunge to a low of 18,000. The speed and extreme nature of this plunge has invalidated the application of many technical and charting analysis techniques. It is unreasonable to assess the recent rebound rally as a right-hand shoulder in an extended head-and-shoulder pattern. The ground has shifted so these analysis tools are put to one side.
Two analysis constants remain. The first is the historical support and resistance levels. The second is the nature of this mother-of-all dead cat bounces. The long-term chart shows strong resistance near 18,500 for the two years 2015 to 2016. The breakout above 18,500 in November 2016 was the start of the two-year bull run. This strong resistance level acted as a support level for the current market fall and the current rebound behaviour has developed from this level.
The long-term chart also shows a strong resistance level near 23,500. This acted as a support level for most of 2018, although it was dramatically broken this year. These two levels - 18,500 and 23,500 - define a very broad trading band that constrains future activity.
This is the context for the current rally rebound and what we might call a dead-cat bounce. These are temporary rallies within the context of a downtrend. They presage the continuation of the downtrend, although they cannot be used to set a downside target. The recent bounce is very large, but this is also consistent with the extreme volatility of the market fall.
The best bullish outcome is a retreat and retest of previous lows to develop a double bottom trend reversal pattern. To see just how this may develop we shift attention to the next most significant global market in Shanghai. The Covid economic recovery has been recorded in the market as a double bottom.
The February rally collapsed in March and quickly retested the lows made on Feb 4. This pattern may provide a template for future Dow activity but now it's more significant for the evidence it provides of a China market rebound. The double-bottom pattern, where the market makes two equal lows separated by weeks, is a much anticipated and reliable trend reversal signal. It sets up a W pattern reversal. In the short term, the peak of the W is the first rebound target. In the longer term, the W is used to project a further upside target that may take many months to a year to achieve.
The double-bottom pattern in the Shanghai index is less than perfect because the two low points are not equal lows. The Feb 4 low is at 2685. The March 23 low is at 2657 but it is followed by two days of consolidation activity in this area, making this a strong, although not textbook perfect, example of a double bottom.
The first target for this W pattern is a retest of the pattern peak near 3060. There are two major resistance features to overcome in reaching this target. The first is historical resistance created by the lower edge of the trading band near 2850. The second is the value of the resistance level near 2980.
The initial rally behaviour has been supplanted by the beginning of retreat and rebound behaviour that potentially turns this into a longer-term uptrend. This is confirmed when a reliable trend line can be plotted. This requires three anchor points for the trend line, each created by a low following a clear retreat and rebound pattern. The low of these patterns is used as the anchor points for the trend line.
The Shanghai Index has a more bullish pattern development than the Dow with its potential for an extended dead-cat bounce. Currently each offers good trading opportunities, but investment opportunities are only for the brave. There is no rush in the Covid recovery so investors can wait for confirmation of new uptrend patterns.
TRENDING NOW
Ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang carried a secret for more than a year. It led to his downfall
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
Jensen Huang discusses comeback as Nvidia CEO with allies: report