Questions raised over new unemployment insurance platform

How does Bandboo ensure consumer protection? How is it accountable?

Published Mon, Jun 5, 2017 · 09:50 PM

    Singapore

    THE business model of new peer-to-peer (P2P) insurance platform Bandboo has come under the spotlight, with insurance players and observers having raised questions about consumer protection and accountability.

    Founded last year, the startup launched its blockchain-enabled unemployment insurance platform - Singapore's first - in May.

    Bandboo works on the basis of individuals coming together to insure one another against job loss. The startup had said that premiums and payout records would be transparent, a situation "made possible through the open blockchain ledger".

    A blockchain is a digital ledger of economic transactions that distributes information but which cannot be copied or corrupted.

    To be covered under Bandboo's unemployment insurance contract lasting a year, a consumer pays a monthly membership fee on top of a monthly premium of S$35.

    Those who are retrenched will receive three months' salary capped at a total of S$18,000, spread over five months.

    But there are conditions attached. For example, there has to be a no-claim period and a minimum employment period before the job loss.

    Based on the interest of applicants, Ashley Kee, Bandboo's co-founder and chief executive, said he expects to successfully get 1,000 customers on board by next month.

    But, as enterprising as some observers think the concept is, they are asking how Bandboo will manage the payouts if there is massive retrenchment and most of its customers make claims.

    These observers say unemployment is a risk that is difficult to assess and quantify, so insurers typically do not provide such coverage; they add that when retrenchment hits, it can affect a good number of workers.

    A senior executive pointed out that the challenge for Bandboo is to "gain enough scale to sustain liabilities", given that those who paid for the claims made would likely feel "short-changed".

    When asked, Bandboo said the yearly premium of S$420 "is forecasted to sustain a claim rate that is approximately three times the national average retrenchment figures".

    If the retrenchment rate rises, Bandboo will seek to revise the premiums on a quarterly basis. For example, the current retrenchment rate is one per cent, but if it rises to two per cent, Bandboo would have to raise the premiums accordingly, in relation to the risk.

    Mr Kee said: "We on-board customers through a proprietary algorithm which takes into account many factors to determine their risk profiles. Our role as platform administrator is to ensure that the platform takes in users across multiple industries to balance out the risk. If we have too many applicants from a certain industry or a particular applicant is flagged to be high-risk, we may, at our discretion, delay on-boarding these customers till we have more applicants from other industries. This is not a new concept and is a common practice across the insurance industry."

    The platform is running on a flat-fee model for the first year, but there are plans to turn to dynamic pricing, similar to that of the Uber and Grab private-hire car services. This will mean that premiums would be adjusted according to a customer's risk profile, for instance.

    As an additional safety net, Bandboo said it would insure itself and is now in talks with two European reinsurers.

    Another key issue raised was regulation and accountability of the firm.

    Bandboo states clearly on its website that it is not regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) as an insurer; therefore, its members are not covered under the Policy Owners' Protection (PPF) Scheme.

    In Singapore, insurers are licensed and supervised by MAS, which requires them to have sound risk-management systems and adequate internal controls. For example, insurers must set aside mandatory capital as a buffer, in case they wind up.

    The PPF scheme, which is on top of the capital-adequacy requirement, essentially protects existing and future policyowners, in case a life or general insurer, which is a member of this scheme, fails. For example, policyowners receive 100 per cent protection for the guaranteed benefits of their life insurance policies, subject to maximum caps where applicable.

    Asked about accountability, Bandboo told The Business Times that the premiums collected are placed in an escrow account held by a trust. Mr Kee and Ou Zhiqi, co-founder and chief operating officer, said: "Funds held in the client trust account are not able to be withdrawn unless the proper authorisations have been granted, with joint signatories and a third-party trust administrator."

    Asked why Bandboo, which uses insurance terms to market itself, was not assessed to be an insurer, MAS replied that the P2P platform does not "assume the insurance risks of individuals by making good any shortfall when claims exceed pooled contributions; nor does it arrange for contracts of insurance between the individuals and external insurers".

    "A P2P platform that chooses to additionally undertake either of these two types of activities will have to be licensed as an insurer or as an insurance intermediary respectively," MAS said. It added that this regulatory approach is similar that in other jurisdictions.

    The regulator said it expects platforms like Bandboo to disclose "clearly and prominently" their unregulated status and their consumers' lack of access to safeguards such as the Financial Industry Dispute Resolution Centre (Fidrec) and PPF.

    MAS said it is planning in the coming months to raise consumer awareness of P2P models through its financial-education arm, MoneySense.

    READ MORE: P2P insurance does not make one an insurer