As recession fears loom large, can the Fed finesse a ‘soft landing’?
WALL Street strategists are increasingly sceptical that the US Federal Reserve can finesse a “soft landing”, and return the soaring hot-air balloon of inflation back to earth without bringing the US economy crashing down with it.
The landing process has already begun. According to Automated Data Processing, a payroll processing company, companies slowed the pace of hiring in August amid mounting fears of an economic slowdown. Private payrolls grew by 132,000 last month, down sharply from the gain of 268,000 in July.
It was always going to be a tricky piece of piloting. When prices are as elevated as is currently the case, it’s almost impossible to keep the flame of demand lit while bringing inflation down to comfortable levels.
Central bankers are also cognisant that the longer inflation is allowed to stick around, the more ingrained it becomes in the system. That’s why the Fed would prefer to pop the balloon, and risk recessionary free fall than to move more. At some stage, corporations become locked in a cycle of hiking prices to keep up with worker wage demands, triggering more demands.
In the late 1970s and 1980s, it took then-Fed chair Paul Volcker not one recession, but two to finally take down the inflation scourge. Current Fed chair Jerome Powell has begun comparing our own era to the one that Volcker navigated, which could be a subtle way of saying he’s determined a similar take-no-prisoners course. It was Powell’s stern warning last week that a hard landing was a growing possibility that triggered the latest slide in global stocks.
“Powell implied the Fed would likely end up inducing a recession as a necessary evil in its war on inflation,” said Nick Reece, a portfolio manager with money manager Merk Investments.
Since then, Powell’s tone has been echoed by other Fed officials. Fed Bank of Cleveland president Loretta Mester recently warned that market hopes of a shift to rate cutting in 2023 were likely in vain.
So far, mixed economic data is more consistent with a slowdown than a recession. While there were 2 negative readings in a row on quarterly gross-domestic product growth, that was belied by strength in other areas like retail sales and consumer confidence.
The slowdown may already be turning into a recession, however. Home prices have already turned around in some of the hottest pandemic markets such as Seattle and Florida, according to analysts at brokerage Goldman Sachs. Every jobs data point is weaker than the last.
Some metrics, such as new-home sales, are pointing downward at an angle that’s starting to look like a crash landing.
One money manager said it was no longer a question of whether it would take a recession to tame inflation, but how deep of a recession would be required.
Strategists at Schroders identified occasions when the US went into recession – in 1973-75 and in 1990 – without diminishing inflation at all. Even more sobering is the fact that the most successful anti-inflation campaign was also one of the deepest recessions - during the second “Volcker” recession of 1981-82 when fross domestic product (GDP) fell 2.5 per cent and inflation came down by 6.2 per cent, according to Schroders. As during the Volcker recessions, some of the factors will be out of the central bank’s control, such as agricultural products, oil and natural gas.
The Fed today is more nimble than in Volcker’s time, which could allow it to manage the economy’s landing much more precisely than it’s advertising, said Oliver Pursche, senior vice-president at financial advisory Wealthspire.
“The Fed has gotten very good at telegraphing what it’s going to do, all the while being committed to changing course if data suggests it should,” he said.
With signs already emerging of slowing inflation, the Fed will soon have more leeway in its decisions. Even if the Fed stopped hiking rates after its September meeting, the effects of recent rate increases will continue to ripple through the economy. Economists say any recession is likely to continue for months.
“Look we are going to have a recession, there’s no question. But I don’t think we need to ring alarm bells and expect it to be a deep or bad recession,” said Pursche. “If the unemployment rate goes up to 4.2 per cent or 4.3 per cent, and inflation comes down to the 3 per cent range, and there are a couple quarters of minus-0.5 per cent or minus-1 per cent growth - to me, that’s a soft landing.”