Rail talk: Are South-east Asia’s high-speed rail ambitions on track or running out of steam?
Asean’s long-time vision of a seamlessly connected region sounds fascinating on paper, but the stumbling blocks are plentiful
Goh Ruoxue
WHEN a bullet train aptly named Whoosh first sped off from Jakarta to Bandung last October – reaching a top speed of 350 km an hour and reducing travel time from three hours by car to just 45 minutes – Indonesia hailed the occasion as it laid claim to launching South-east Asia’s first high-speed railway (HSR).
The US$7.3 billion project – part of Beijing’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and largely funded by China – was viewed by observers as a big step towards Asean’s push for seamless integration and connectivity in the region.
This year’s Asean chair, Laos, has adopted the theme of “enhancing connectivity and resilience”, with a pledge to intensify cooperation by promoting – among many other things – infrastructure connectivity.
The concept of regional integration was formalised in 2010 with the adoption of the Master Plan on Asean Connectivity, which laid out steps for the bloc to achieve physical, institutional and people-to-people connectivity. Specific targets include the implementation of sections of the Singapore-Kunming Rail Link, and the completion of the Asean Highway Network.
On the fast track
Several South-east Asian nations have long had grand ambitions of constructing HSR networks, with varying degrees of success.
Besides Whoosh, another completed rail project in South-east Asia under the BRI is the Laos-China Railway, which was launched in December 2021.
The US$6 billion rail link – technically not quite an HSR, as its top speed is 160 kmh – connects the Chinese city of Kunming to the Laotian capital Vientiane. There are plans to expand it so the trains snake down through Thailand and Malaysia to Singapore.
For now, however, the light at the end of the tunnel remains fairly dim. While some projects in South-east Asia are finding their footing, others are faltering.
At the crossroads
Thailand’s long-in-the-making project, if brought to fruition, will see Bangkok connected to the Lao-bordering Thai province Nong Khai, where a bridge will be built over the Mekong River to connect with the Laos-China line.
First proposed in 2010, the project envisions linking Bangkok to Kunming.
Though the kingdom pledged in 2022 to complete the first stage of the project by 2026 and conduct an official launch the following year, critics have dubbed the move as a political gambit and warned of further obstacles along the way.
Meanwhile, the Kuala Lumpur-Singapore HSR has its own history of backtracking, suspensions, and cancellations, dating all the way from its inception in 2013.
In a bid to revive the project that was terminated in 2021, Malaysia called for the private sector to submit concept proposals. It has, as at Jan 16 this year, received seven.
But jaded long-term observers know to no longer get their hopes up too early on.
Over in Vietnam, the tale repeats itself with the North-South HSR project.
First proposed in the early 2000s, the US$70 billion venture that links the capital Hanoi with the southern metropolis of Ho Chi Minh City has been stalled by the project’s high costs and a lack of government consensus.
Last December, its Transport Ministry announced that Vietnam aims to start construction before 2030 and have the first trains in service by 2045.
The trouble with rail
It appears that the track to South-east Asia’s vision of a seamless rail network – while fascinating in theory – is paved with stumbling blocks.
HSRs not only break speed barriers, but are also notorious for breaking the bank, thanks to their substantial costs, budget overruns, a heavy dependence on subsidies, and lengthy project delays.
While infrastructure connectivity is a prerequisite to integration and having an HSR represents the “next level in connectivity”, such large-scale projects require regional coordination, said Professor Ruth Banomyong, an academic from Thailand. This is challenging as each Asean member state has its own national agenda, he added.
“It would be easier to focus on those member countries that already have connectivity first,” said Prof Ruth, a former head of the department of international business logistics and transport at Thammasat University’s business school.
Tomoo Kikuchi, a professor at Waseda University’s Graduate School of Asia-Pacific Studies in Japan, also believes that conflicts of national interests are unavoidable.
“As in any kind of network, not all the nodes in a rail network will benefit equally,” he said. “There must (be) a consensus among all parties that the efficiency gains from a rail network across South-east Asia will trickle down to all the major cities and areas that will be connected to the network.”
For the HSR projects of Vietnam, Singapore and Malaysia to turn a profit, they have to be embedded in a wider regional rail network, he added.
“The potential population that utilises the high-speed rail is too small if any of the projects are a standalone project.”
Light at the end of the tunnel
Despite these challenges, observers said that Asean’s ambitions have not been completely derailed.
KE Seetha Ram, a senior consulting specialist for capacity building and training projects at the Asian Development Bank Institute, feels it is possible to have several Asean cities connected via HSR.
Transport connectivity for the movement of people and goods within Asean is crucial, he said. And although overcoming the heterogeneity of the 10 member states poses a challenge, it also serves as “an opportunity that envisages Asia to be an integrated market”, he added.
“Active dialogue, debates and sound cooperation across governments in devising comprehensive action plans and far-sighted strategies (are) pivotal in determining the trajectory of (HSR projects) in Asean,” said the special adviser to East Japan Railways Company for India’s HSR project.
Experts said the benefits that HSR links bring in urban agglomeration, alleviating traffic congestion, boosting tourism, and facilitating a smooth transition to clean energy should not be understated.
But intentions matter too, they said.
Prof Kikuchi warned that infrastructure export has become a geopolitical contest for countries aiming to gain influence in the region. He pointed out that Japan, China and several European countries often compete to win bids for HSR projects in South-east Asia.
“It’s important for countries in South-east Asia to implement projects that are sustainable and benefit the people, and not to use them for winning short-term political bargains,” he said.