DINING OUT

What the fish? Diving for flavour at Fysh – Aussie chef Josh Niland’s Singapore debut

Good intentions of this sustainability-focused restaurant aside, how does the food taste? 

Published Thu, Nov 23, 2023 · 10:48 PM
    • Fysh's botanical surroundings.
    • The Fysh egg tart.
    • Aged swordfish belly in calamansi juice.
    • Tuna fillet steaks are served steakhouse style.
    • Roast turbot head is paired with chunky olive tapenade.
    • The valrhona chocolate macaron is sandwiched with fish eye ice cream.
    • Fysh's botanical surroundings. PHOTO: FYSH
    • The Fysh egg tart. PHOTO: JAIME EE, BT
    • Aged swordfish belly in calamansi juice. PHOTO: JAIME EE, BT
    • Tuna fillet steaks are served steakhouse style. PHOTO: JAIME EE, BT
    • Roast turbot head is paired with chunky olive tapenade. PHOTO: JAIME EE, BT
    • The valrhona chocolate macaron is sandwiched with fish eye ice cream. PHOTO: FYSH

    NEW RESTAURANT

    Fysh at Edition 38 Cuscaden Road Singapore 249731 Tel: 6329-5096 Open daily. Lunch: 12 pm to 2.30 pm. Dinner: 6 pm to 10 pm (10.30 pm from Fri to Sun)

    DEAR Fish,

    I feel bad. No, it’s not the nauseous feeling I get thinking about the vanilla-ish ice cream I ate that was made from your eyeballs.

    I feel bad that I’m not the enlightened diner you want me to be. The kind that jumps on the “end food waste” bandwagon and has an appetite for amuse bouche fashioned out of scraps, stalks and peels. Or who worships at your beautiful new temple of sustainability – green, velvety, posh – that glorifies the sacrifice you made by getting caught and ensures every part of your beautiful species is swallowed by all who enter.

    Fysh’s botanical surroundings. PHOTO: FYSH

    Maybe it’s the way they put you on such a high pedestal, I don’t know whether I’m here to eat or receive your blessings. I tell a man in a suit that we’ve been waiting really long for our food. He doesn’t apologise. He makes a waiting gesture, as if gently chastising an impatient child. “The kitchen wants to make sure everything is perfect, so please bear with us.” Huh.

    BT Short Logo

    THE BUSINESS TIMES INSIGHTS

    Powering Asean's Future 2026

    Find out how enterprises are navigating power constraints and sustainability targets

    ACCESS THE INSIGHTS

    It’s not like we haven’t already swallowed your head priest Josh Niland’s scale-to-tail theology hook, line and sinker. Or seen how good your yellowfin tuna cousin looks from afar – all that muscly, deep-ruby flesh and neatly chiselled bones mimicking a hunk of prime rib. We say “afar” because the tuna is proudly paraded in front of another table. We don’t get so much as a peep at a fin, nor the attention of staff who are positioned so that their eyes never make contact with ours.

    But there’s ideology, and there’s dinner, and that’s where I feel short-changed.

    They’re not serving the tuna ribeye that evening, apparently because it hasn’t been aged long enough. It’s a curious ethos for a restaurant which doesn’t seem to like serving anything fresh. Or hot, for that matter. Anything that tries to stay above room temperature is immediately chilled into submission by an unforgiving air conditioner.

    The surroundings are quite lovely, though, in the new hotel Edition, where a mini Botanic Gardens starts in the lobby and extends to the main restaurant without any announcement. Anyone can have breakfast and lunch here, too, since it also does all-day-dining duty. 

    There are some “safe” things to eat, like quail, roast chicken and beef steak, but otherwise Fysh has two objectives: one is to apply butchering skills to turn tuna into dry-aged cows of the sea; the other is to turn everything else that can’t be a fillet into something else to eat. 

    There is some good bread to start off with – thick slabs of sourdough smeared with butter from a scallop shell. Bring a book, so there’s something to do during the long wait besides sighing and fidgeting. Eventually, some oysters arrive (S$48 for six); some are fresh, some may have been held hostage for a spell. They’re French perle noir – slightly minerally, fairly fleshy and almost crisp in texture. 

    Fysh’s egg tart sounded a promising note during the meal. PHOTO: JAIME EE, BT

    Fysh egg tart (S$32) is the first promising note, except for the price. It’s not a very big tart, but it has an enviable crust that manages to be flaky and crunchy simultaneously, filled with a creamy egg-salad mixture and covered with salmon roe. It’s not too salty, and egg salad never fails to please.

    Aged swordfish belly in calamansi juice. PHOTO: JAIME EE, BT

    We’ve had aged fish before. We’ve had fish scraps before. The kind we’re used to lend silky mouthfeel to pan-fried fillets, a suppleness to sushi and are great baked in piping hot pies. They’re aged for the sake of deliciousness, versus being aged as a mission statement. Here, off-menu aged swordfish belly (S$36) manages a pleasant smokiness from a light char and a firm bite, doused in calamansi juice to add some life. But it’s bland, and borders on funky. 

    Roast turbot head is paired with chunky olive tapenade. PHOTO: JAIME EE, BT

    Turbot chop (S$82) isn’t a chop, but half a head and is described by the restaurant’s only hardworking server as “fresh”. But we need more proof. It shows signs of being chargrilled at one point, but it is cool when it arrives, with meaty cheeks and gelatinous parts that would taste better if less congealed. A smothering of chunky green olive tapenade does it no favours.

    Tuna fillet steaks are served steakhouse style. PHOTO: JAIME EE, BT

    Neither does a trio of steakhouse condiments – harissa, bearnaise sauce and a chilli vinaigrette – do anything for room-temperature pink tuna fillet steaks (S$68), which identify as spongy and dry at the same time.

    Even a roast hispi cabbage (S$18) doesn’t seem to have escaped the clutches of a mad ageing professor. Served in an awkward buttery chickpea sauce, its soft charred leaves leave you with an odd chemical aftertaste like someone tried to embalm it before it managed to escape. But that said, the kombu fries (S$12) are pretty good.

    The valrhona chocolate macaron is sandwiched with fish eye ice cream. PHOTO: FYSH

    The fish-eye ice cream is the kind of dessert you have to be dared to try. It goes by a more neutral name of a valrhona chocolate macaron (S$14), and is a very decent, intense, chewy macaron that does its best to mask the filling, which is a bit like eating ice cream from the inside of a sardine tin. It’s almost tolerable, but we don’t want a scoop of it in our waffle cone.

    So, Fish, you know there’s an issue if we like everything but the fish. But you’re still new, and things can be relooked. You have really good intentions, but it’ll take a bit more to reel us in.

    Rating: 6

    Decoding Asia newsletter: your guide to navigating Asia in a new global order. Sign up here to get Decoding Asia newsletter. Delivered to your inbox. Free.

    Copyright SPH Media. All rights reserved.