US stock market, economy on tenterhooks as Trump, Harris enter final stretch of campaign
The US’ creditworthiness will face problems if the peaceful transfer of power is jeopardised by violence after the election
IN ALL likelihood, the US stock market will quickly adjust to the outcome of the Nov 5 presidential election, barring a sweep by either party or another bout of civil unrest.
Analysts said that there will probably be some sort of contestation of the election results, but it would only be a shock to the market if these challenges triggered a level of violence similar to the deadly invasion of the US Capitol in January 2021.
If there is a strong red or blue “wave” as the results are tallied and either the Republican or Democratic party seizes control of both houses of Congress and the White House, the stock market and the economy could suffer.
Currently, the polls are too tight for the stock market to perform its trick of pricing in the outcome of major events even before they happen.
“Nothing is priced in, so any result will move the market,” said Tim Murray, capital market strategist in the multi-asset unit of T Rowe Price.
The stock market was once a reliable indicator of US presidential polls. For decades, stock-market gains in the year preceding an election almost guaranteed the incumbent party a victory, as recently charted by Adam Turnquist, a technical strategist at brokerage LPL Financial.
As Turnquist indicated, though, Donald Trump broke that model in 2016 when he stunned the world by defeating Hillary Clinton, who was the red-hot favourite to become the first female president in America’s history.
Fast forward eight years later, and here we are again. Trump, now 78 years old, is on the brink of a return to the White House. He faces another woman opponent in the form of Vice-President Kamala Harris, who is nearly two decades his junior and is now neck-and-neck in the polls.
It has been an eventful election campaign, especially in the last few months with two very lopsided televised debates and two assassination attempts on Trump.
Both candidates are deadlocked in the latest set of national polls, and it is still anyone’s guess as to who can mastermind one final surge to convince the voters of their ability to occupy the most powerful position in the world.
Harris enjoyed some positive momentum in the days after she replaced President Joe Biden as the Democratic nominee, but even that has faded of late as she continues to deal with complaints that she has kept too low a profile.
Trump tax cuts vs Harris handouts
A Trump win would be a short-term positive for the US stock market because he has vowed to extend the corporate tax cuts that were passed in 2017, while Harris intends to let those cuts expire, said Murray of T Rowe Price.
Harris is likely to stick to Biden’s emphasis on buttresses for the middle class, with a slight shift in emphasis from job creation to tax credits and subsidies.
Her use of tariffs would likely target China’s artificial intelligence and electric vehicle (EV) technology capabilities. Trump, on the other hand, is almost certain to go into an all-out trade war with China and to slash taxes for all Americans, regardless of the damage to the US Treasury.
“If Trump won, we’d have broad-based tariffs, which are incredibly dangerous for an economy,” said Oliver Pursche, senior vice-president at financial advisory Wealthspire.
Tariffs, which are bound to trigger reciprocal measures from the countries that Trump targets, could hurt export businesses in the United States just as much as they would their Chinese or European counterparts.
Trump has threatened to place a levy on every single item that crosses the US border. These kinds of tariffs will inevitably drive up the prices of goods, economists warned.
JD Joyce, president of Texas-based financial advisory Joyce Wealth Management, noted: “If we were to have significant tariff increases, that probably means we (would be) dealing with a higher inflation environment, which means fewer anticipated rate cuts.”
The US Federal Reserve has just waged a two-year war against inflation, succeeding in taming the beast for the most part.
A prolonged period of “Trump-enomics” could set inflation loose again. Trump is also weighing the installation of a “shadow Fed chair” in the White House in an effort to seek more influence over monetary policy. Such meddling is unlikely to improve central-bank efficacy, economists said.
Harris’ proposals, including a subsidy for first-time homebuyers, could also be inflationary. She has vowed to bring prices of food and medicine down for the middle class, but subsidising those areas could result in higher nominal prices.
Fiscal stimulus was one ingredient in the last round of inflation, though supply-chain issues and the pent-up demand resulting from a year of lockdowns were also factors, pointed out Murray.
A Harris victory could boost shares of sustainable-energy companies as Trump has hinted he may roll back incentives for EV buyers and solar-power developers included in the Inflation Reduction Act.
The tech sector may shrink from a Harris win, however.
Should the Democrats come to power on Harris’ coat-tails in the House and Senate, business leaders will start to fret about the sunsetting of the 2017 tax cuts and stricter regulation.
Murray said that the big concern for markets would be if they finally see some teeth behind the talk of Big Tech regulation. “Big Tech is a massive part of the market. If there’s finally some teeth to regulatory oversight on them, that could take down the market.”
The Justice Department recently raised the possibility of breaking up Alphabet’s Google. Shares of Alphabet barely stirred as investors played wait-and-see on a proposal that would likely be scrapped if Trump were to win.
Both Democrats and Republicans have embraced populist measures, the gung-ho use of fiscal stimulus to earn voters’ loyalty.
On Oct 10, Trump floated the idea of making interest on car loans tax-deductible. It is the kind of measure that makes a middle-class borrower sit up and pay attention, and Treasury officials who need to balance the budget scratch their heads.
By some estimates, Trump’s tax proposals would add US$7.5 trillion to the deficit, roughly double that of Harris’ proposals, according to estimates by The Wall Street Journal.
Former New York mayor Michael Bloomberg said that Trump was setting himself up to be one of the most reckless fiscal stewards in history. Bloomberg and other fiscal conservatives say the federal deficit has already reached dangerous levels, and the US cannot afford any more Trump tax cuts or Harris handouts.
According to Murray, it is unlikely that credit-ratings agencies will further cut the US debt rating because of this deficit spending. After all, fiscal discipline is seldom spoken about at the highest levels of either party these days, he noted.
The US’ creditworthiness will face problems if the peaceful transfer of power is jeopardised by violence after the election, said Murray.
There is always that chance that there will be violence following the election. That, of course, will be bad for the stock market and the global economy, and disastrous for the future of US democracy.