CIO CORNER

China is an oasis of clarity with upside for stocks

China equities are expected to outperform, thanks to a confluence of the policy environment and economic cycle

    • China's data on key economic activity, including retail sales, industrial production and fixed asset investment, all show modest improvement with clear room for further growth.
    • China's data on key economic activity, including retail sales, industrial production and fixed asset investment, all show modest improvement with clear room for further growth. PHOTO: EPA-EFE
    John Woods
    Published Tue, Mar 28, 2023 · 06:41 PM

    AS GLOBAL risk assets continue to struggle with uncertainty and falling risk appetite, one key determinant of the attractiveness of any market is the level of confidence as to where an economy is headed, and the respective policy environment.

    This is where China equities may be underappreciated – the confluence of the policy environment and the economic cycle provides a rare instance of clarity in this moment of acute uncertainty in developed markets.

    This underpins our expectation that China equities will outperform global equities in the coming months.

    Fed repricing to continue

    The only thing certain about the US Federal Reserve is that uncertainty will remain elevated in the coming weeks, if not months. Global risk markets, especially equities, will remain in thrall to the Fed’s policy moves (and to those of the European Central Bank, to a lesser extent).

    But the economic and market conditions do not allow for any amount of clarity – or certainty – anytime soon.

    Key among these conditions is inflation. While disinflation looks to be firmly entrenched, its pace has been halting. With inflation still some distance from the Fed’s official target of 2 per cent, this is a major concern as it threatens to cement inflation expectations at an elevated level.

    This, in turn, has implications for how much more the Fed might need to hike; how long it needs to hold rates at the terminal level; and subsequently, how sharply it can cut rates.

    A related fact, which raises the stakes of policy error for the Fed, is that economic growth in the US remains robust, as proxied by the tightness in the labour market. Insufficient hawkishness can easily lead to a rebound in inflation, and risks further damage to the Fed’s already bruised credibility.

    Adding to the murkiness is stress in the banking sector, which has led markets down a path of an aggressively dovish repricing of Fed expectations. It is clear that the stress is likely to tighten credit conditions somewhat, in turn slowing growth and raising recession risks.

    However, market indicators still do not suggest that a rapid, major credit crunch should be the base case. The market’s preoccupation with the banking sector’s concerns might well lead it to mistakenly ignore the Fed’s hawkish signals, only to later require another round of repricing.

    China’s clear path

    China’s surprise 25-basis-point (bps) cut in its reserve requirement ratio (RRR) earlier this month could not have provided a clearer contrast with monetary uncertainty elsewhere. Although more controlled than in 2008, China’s policymakers face a far simpler picture, at least in terms of policy direction: Support a gradual but sustained economic recovery.

    In fact, our China economist believes that the surprise move was in response to the growth momentum thus far being weaker than expected, and the additional risk of banking stress in developed markets hurting liquidity and external demand.

    The willingness of policymakers to act early suggests that an additional 25-bps RRR cut is likely later this year, in addition to a 5-bps to 10-bps reduction in the loan prime rate.

    A key underpinning of our confidence in this outlook is the fact that China’s policymakers are completely unconstrained by inflation, which remains low at the moment.

    Headline inflation declined to 1 per cent year on year (yoy) in February from 2.1 per cent in January, with core inflation (excluding food and energy) falling to 0.6 per cent yoy in February from 1 per cent in January.

    We still see limited inflation pressure in China this year, and expect inflation at a benign 2.5 per cent, on account of a muted consumption recovery.

    The overall economic recovery meanwhile is still in its early stages, with the Covid-19 wave having subsided in January. The key economic activity data for January to February – retail sales, industrial production and fixed asset investment – all showed modest improvement, with clear room for further improvement, especially in private investment.

    Additionally, sentiment in the real estate sector appears to be stabilising, which should provide important psychological (at least) support for broader consumption and investment going forward.

    The improving sentiment is corroborated by the key forward-looking Purchasing Managers Index (PMI) new-orders component for the manufacturing and non-manufacturing sectors at 54.1 and 55.8 respectively in February, with the expectations components for both even higher at 57.5 and 64.9, respectively.

    We thus continue to expect China’s economic growth to accelerate from 3 per cent last year to 5.1 per cent in 2023.

    Earning our confidence

    The positive policy tone underpins our expectation of earnings growth accelerating to 15 per cent for 2023. This is impressive considering the backdrop of a mere 1 per cent earnings-per-share growth expected for global equities.

    Additionally, China equities continue to be inexpensively priced, trading 0.7 standard deviations below their 10-year average on a forward price-to-earnings basis. Moreover, with the central bank adding liquidity to the economy, we think valuations are bound to improve.

    The improving economic outlook will likely translate into growing risk appetite among domestic investors. In February 2023, 167.3 million new individual stock investor accounts opened, a 98 per cent increase over January’s 842,000.

    However, the January-February total is still the lowest since 2020, which is in line with the economic picture of strong improvement at the margins from a low base.

    Notwithstanding the ongoing consolidation of the MSCI China Index, the technical picture points to ongoing price support at around 4 per cent lower at 61.7.

    The writer is chief investment officer for the Asia-Pacific in Credit Suisse.