Compass, SingNet in copyright fight over alleged Singtel TV infringement
Collecting society Compass is seeking 1.5% of SingNet's annual pay-TV "net revenue" from April 2013 to March 2019
Singapore
MAINBOARD-LISTED telco Singtel is involved in a legal dispute over the use of music in programmes that are broadcast on its pay-television service.
Subsidiary SingNet, which operates Singtel TV, was sued in March last year by the Composers and Authors Society of Singapore Ltd (Compass).
A collecting society that represents the owners of copyrighted works in handling licences and collecting royalties on behalf of members, Compass offers an annual licence for pay-TV services in Singapore from April 1 to March 31.
Compass, which has also sued cinema operators over music rights, has sought 1.5 per cent of SingNet's annual pay-TV "net revenue" from April 2013 to March 2019. This net revenue comprises subscription fees and advertising revenue but excludes set-top box rental and some other fees.
SingNet has argued it should not have to pay licence fees based on all revenue, according to an application to the Copyright Tribunal. It also said sports programmes make up a larger share of Singtel TV revenue and do not feature much music.
According to court documents, fee negotiations for the currently disputed rights period had been going on from at least 2012.
SingNet eventually applied to the Copyright Tribunal on Jan 31, 2019. It asked for, among other things, an order to fix "a reasonable sum" for the charges Compass might demand and an order that the charges demanded are "unreasonable and arbitrary".
Five-and-a-half weeks later, Compass sued SingNet over alleged copyright infringement involving musical works whose owners are represented by the collecting society.
It claimed that SingNet has screened programmes on Singtel TV using those works since April 2013 without making any application to the Copyright Tribunal, and denied that its charges, terms and conditions were unreasonable and arbitrary.
The High Court ordered a limited stay of Compass's suit in July last year, pending the outcome of the Copyright Tribunal proceedings. The Business Times understands that proceedings are still ongoing.
Compass also filed an originating summons for the High Court to determine whether the tribunal is able to make retrospective orders.
Compass had argued that SingNet ought to have made an application to the tribunal before it made use of the copyrighted works, and that the tribunal is not able to make retrospective orders for works already used.
The court most recently ruled in favour of Compass on Oct 13, saying in its decision that the tribunal has no power to grant a retrospective order.
Singtel disclosed in its last annual report that it was "contingently liable for claims arising in the ordinary course of business", including legal proceedings, as at March 31, 2019.
"The group is vigorously defending all these claims," it noted then, without specifying.
When contacted, a Singtel spokesperson told BT that the company could not comment further as the matter is before the courts.
The ongoing SingNet case comes amid a wider review of the role of collecting societies, or collective management organisations (CMOs), in Singapore's copyright regulatory regime.
The Ministry of Law and the Intellectual Property Office of Singapore (Ipos) launched a public consultation in June, on a proposed licensing scheme for such organisations.
The scheme would bring CMOs, which are not regulated in Singapore, under the supervision of Ipos.
Media law veteran Adrian Tan told BT that while CMOs can serve a need in society, they "have been operating in an unregulated ecosystem" here.
"Virtually anyone could set up a CMO, and start asking for money from pubs, shopping malls, cinemas, broadcasters and the like, under the guise of collecting copyright licence fees," said Mr Tan, a partner at TSMP Law Corporation.
"As Singapore solidifies its position as an intellectual property hub, there is a need to put rules in place. It will reduce litigation, and improve certainty."
TRENDING NOW
Peter Kwee’s Ridley Park bungalow on the market with S$100 million asking price
Motoring tycoon Peter Kwee is back in court: Here are his previous legal battles
Demand, tech capabilities position Apac and AI as Skyscanner’s next growth frontiers: CEO Bryan Batista
South-east Asia has lost Nvidia’s best salesman