You are here

After Mueller show, Democrats likely no closer to impeachment

Former special counsel Robert Mueller's reticent testimony to Congress likely confirmed what many Democrats had feared: if they want to end Donald Trump's presidency, their best bet is through next year's election, not impeachment.

[WASHINGTON] Former special counsel Robert Mueller's reticent testimony to Congress likely confirmed what many Democrats had feared: if they want to end Donald Trump's presidency, their best bet is through next year's election, not impeachment.

Mr Mueller's highly anticipated appearance Wednesday at back-to-back House hearings delivered neither the viral moments nor the bombshell soundbites that the anti-Trump crowd hoped would persuade skeptics or overwhelmingly reshape public opinion.

The contents of Mr Mueller's remarks were damning, several Democrats said, noting the former FBI director's statements that the two-year investigation of Russian election interference was "not a witch hunt," and indeed found substantial evidence of obstruction of justice.

But after Mr Mueller's flat one-word answers, seeming confusion about questions and refusal to produce new information, hopes that the performance would launch lawmakers on a path to impeachment had dimmed.

The 2020 election "is unquestionably the only way he gets removed from office, so we can never lose sight of that," House Intelligence Committee chairman Adam Schiff, who presided over one of Mr Mueller's hearings, said on Thursday.

Your feedback is important to us

Tell us what you think. Email us at

Even Democrat Al Green, who forced an unsuccessful House vote on articles of impeachment last week following Trump's racially charged attacks on four liberal congresswomen, acknowledged Mr Mueller's appearance fell short of expectations.

"There was no 'aha' moment because we've had the report and watched or discussed the President's impeachable actions ad nauseum," Mr Green said on Twitter.

Ninety-five of the House's 235 Democrats voted for Mr Green's measure. While pro-impeachment legislators were hoping dozens would shift to their position, just two more lawmakers publicly announced they now backed impeachment proceedings.

House Democrat Lisa Blunt Rochester said she supports impeachment after listening to Mr Mueller declare that Mr Trump stonewalled his investigation, failed to tell the truth in written answers to questions, and likely could have been charged with a crime without the Justice Department's policy against indicting a sitting president.

"Director Mueller has done his job. Now it's time for Congress to do ours," she said.

House Democrat Karen Bass, an impeachment skeptic, said the hearing "didn't change me," and that she wanted to proceed with ongoing House investigations.

"I also think that all of our leaders need to be on the same page," she said.


They aren't. According to Politico, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, the top Democrat in Congress, rebuffed an impeachment push by House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerry Nadler, telling a closed-door meeting after Ms Mueller's testimony that it was premature.

For months, Ms Pelosi has tamped down impeachment calls, aware of how dangerous such a vote would be for centrist Democrats in Republican-leaning districts.

She has argued that the case should be ironclad before lawmakers launch such a divisive process, especially given the likelihood it would die in the Republican-led Senate.

Several 2020 presidential hopefuls support impeachment, including Senators Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders, Kamala Harris and Kirsten Gillibrand.

But Ms Pelosi has highlighted the need for the White House candidates to focus on the economy and health care - kitchen table issues that propelled Democrats to their House majority last year - in order to help win back working-class voters who tilted for Mr Trump in 2016.

She is also concerned about public opinion polling showing that most Americans are against impeachment, and has said unsuccessful proceedings would allow Mr Trump to claim exoneration, boosting his re-election bid.

But she made clear that she was not shutting the door, saying, "If we have a case for impeachment, that's the place we will have to go."


Meanwhile, Ms Pelosi is backing House investigations of Trump and his administration, and is monitoring several court cases which could provide potentially damning new evidence and testimony from the White House.

While Mr Mueller failed to provide Democrats with their closing argument for impeachment, he did issue a clarion call for election security, warning that Russia was preparing more interference for 2020.

Even with current administration officials like FBI director Christopher Wray recently warning lawmakers of active threats, Republicans have blocked Democratic proposals to safeguard US elections.

The Democratic-led House passed legislation requiring voting systems to use paper ballots and improve technical protections, but it has stalled in the Senate.

Senate Democrats introduced an initiative requiring political campaigns to report to federal authorities any election interference attempts by foreign entities.

But Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell blocked the measure on Thursday, calling it "a highly partisan bill" from lawmakers "hyping up a conspiracy theory about President Trump and Russia."


BT is now on Telegram!

For daily updates on weekdays and specially selected content for the weekend. Subscribe to