|
In any case, it takes all sorts to make up a market, and there’s plenty of room to do nothing, do something, or strike some sort of balance in between.
If you’re the Do-Something sort of investor
You have a whole range of Do-Somethings to choose from, depending on your risk appetite.
On the aggressive end of things, I’ve heard of a contrarian trade in Singapore Airlines (SIA) being mooted – the airline’s share price has been dinged almost 9 per cent since the US attacked Iran. Among the Asian carriers, SIA is better protected against fuel price spikes – it typically hedges almost 50 per cent of its fuel over the next three months. The longer the war lasts and the further oil prices run up and away from expectations, though, the more contrarian this trade will look.
If the conflict becomes a prolonged one, investors could go shopping in the agribusiness and capital goods stocks section. Higher energy prices and freight rates could push up earnings forecasts for firms such as Yangzijiang Shipbuilding, Sembcorp Industries and China Aviation Oil, according to CGS International analysts. The research house has “add” ratings on all three counters.
On the other hand, if you’d rather be taking cover, UOB Kay Hian has singled out Centurion Accommodation Reit, Keppel DC Reit and Parkway Life Reit as vehicles with “one-of-a-kind assets that could weather a downturn”. The research outfit also included construction players such as Pan United and Hong Leong Asia, consumer stocks DFI Retail and Sheng Siong, and Raffles Medical in healthcare as among its stock picks in defensive sectors.
If you’re the Sit-Tight sort of investor
This section, which explores doing nothing, ought to be empty by definition. But there’s a surprising amount to be said on the matter.
For better or for worse, this isn’t the market’s first time at the war-and-oil rodeo, so we have a wealth of data that shows how stock markets generally trade higher in the year after an oil shock happens.
In fact, an analysis of previous US-led attacks that lasted more than a day found that on average, the S&P 500 was 12.5 per cent higher a year after those attacks began.
Pulling cash out of your portfolio could end up costing you dearly in the long run. Research shows that investors who moved into cash in volatile times and then moved back into stocks when volatility fell would have reduced their returns by nearly 80 per cent since 1990.
“Even trying to be ‘disciplined’ with this turmoil-avoiding strategy – and moving into cash only when the Vix (a measure of volatility) was in the top 5 per cent of its historical range – wouldn’t fare much better,” said Duncan Lamont, Schroders’ head of strategic research.
“That approach would still cut nearly in half the returns that could have been realised… The most rewarding strategy was to stay fully invested and not react to the volatility.”
When it doesn’t matter what sort of investor you are
There is, however, a separate argument to be made for cash and caution. For most people, the stock market doesn’t form the bulwark of their economic welfare – their job does.
“(Oil) price spikes have a nasty habit of marking the end of the cycle or coinciding with recessions,” a CGS International note said last week.
The stock market might be able to shrug off a disruption to oil supply, but the oil market tends to carry the scars of a shock for far longer. Research has found that a year after the start of US military action, the price of Brent crude – a global benchmark for oil – has been 27 per cent higher on average.
When oil is a lot more expensive for a prolonged period, it tends to be trailed by two undesirable companions: inflation and recession.
In Singapore, an increase in the average crude oil price from US$63 per barrel to US$92 per barrel could raise 2026’s headline inflation rate from about 1.3 per cent to about 1.8 per cent year on year, by OCBC Group Research’s reckoning. Not terrible, but not fun either.
And if soaring oil prices tip the region into a recession, it won’t be investment portfolios that keep people up at night, but their pocketbooks and pay cheques as prices rise and jobs are lost. In such dire times, cash will be king.
|