HOCK LOCK SIEW

Companies’ climate reporting must go beyond measuring numbers for reporting’s sake

Kenneth Lim

Kenneth Lim

Published Wed, Mar 13, 2024 · 05:00 AM
    • Some companies may see climate reporting merely as a compliance burden, with little incentive to do better.
    • Some companies may see climate reporting merely as a compliance burden, with little incentive to do better. PHOTO: BT FILE

    AS CLIMATE reporting appears inevitable for Singapore’s listed and large non-listed companies, one challenge will be getting companies to go beyond measuring the numbers simply for reporting’s sake.

    Climate reporting ultimately exists to facilitate climate action, but that connection relies on companies taking steps to improve their numbers. Instead, some may see it merely as a compliance burden, with little incentive to do better.

    EY’s 2023 edition of its annual Global Climate Risk Barometer had mixed findings for the large Singapore-listed companies included in the study. Singapore companies scored 41 per cent for the quality of their climate disclosures. While this was better than the South-east Asia average of 35 per cent, it lagged the global average of 50 per cent.

    EY partner Praveen Tekchandani, who is Singapore climate change and sustainability services leader at the firm, highlighted the role that regulations and policy had in driving disclosure improvements, noting that “progressive regulators” in Singapore had a role in pushing disclosures in the country ahead of the regional average.

    That driving force is about to get stronger.

    Singapore has said all listed companies will have to report their Scope 1 and 2 emissions from fiscal 2025 onwards, and include Scope 3 emissions from FY26. External limited assurance for Scope 1 and 2 emissions will be required for listed companies from FY27. Singapore Exchange (SGX) has just launched a public consultation to put this in effect.

    Climate reporting also becomes mandatory for large non-listed companies beginning FY27, with external limited assurance required from FY29. Large non-listed companies will not have to report on Scope 3 emissions before FY29.

    Scope 1 emissions refer to greenhouse gases directly generated by a company’s activities, while Scope 2 emissions are generated from the company’s power consumption. Scope 3 emissions are generated along the supply chain as a result of the company’s activities, and are more difficult to measure accurately.

    The new rules will probably help keep Singapore near the front of the pack when it comes to climate reporting. Whether that reporting will translate into enough climate action is less certain.

    A big test will lie in the requirement, under the relatively new IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards adopted by the foremost global accounting standards body, for companies to disclose their climate transition plans as part of their strategy.

    Only 53 per cent of all companies in the EY Barometer study reported some kind of transition plan, which suggests the corporate world has yet to fully embrace climate reporting for progress as opposed to climate reporting for compliance.

    The world is producing significantly more greenhouse gases than it can afford if catastrophic warming is to be averted. Companies that face material climate risk – such as banking, energy, agriculture and transport businesses – need to be addressing elevated transition risk, so a credible transition plan has become key information that stakeholders need to have.

    Some of that transition risk is regulatory in nature as rulemakers step up efforts to drive progress. Already, the Monetary Authority of Singapore has consulted the public on transition planning guidelines for banks, insurers and asset managers.

    SGX Regulation (SGX RegCo) chief executive Tan Boon Gin in September 2023 also urged listed companies to start and improve on transition planning, explaining that “companies with robust transition plans that are well disclosed will stand a better chance of maintaining access to capital markets, including benefiting from green and transition finance”.

    “Companies will also find it easier to plug into global supply chains if they are able to meet international supplier due diligence requirements,” Tan wrote in SGX RegCo’s Regulator’s Column.

    Singapore companies will need to catch up with the regulators when it comes to transition planning. SGX and the Centre for Governance and Sustainability at the National University of Singapore published a review in 2023 of sustainability reporting among Singapore-listed companies. The review found only 12 per cent, or 65 companies, out of 535 reviewed companies produced “reasonably detailed climate transition plans”.

    One challenge is that consensus about what constitutes a good transition plan is still a work in progress. The forward edge of that effort comes from the United Kingdom, where the Transition Plan Taskforce (TPT) published a disclosure framework in October 2023.

    The IFRS standard defines a transition plan as “an aspect of an entity’s overall strategy that lays out the entity’s targets, actions or resources for its transition towards a lower-carbon economy, including actions such as reducing its greenhouse gas emissions”.

    The TPT built upon that definition with the concept of a “strategic ambition”, which includes consideration for capturing opportunities and avoiding adverse impacts. Based on that, TPT described five elements of a good transition plan:

    • Foundations, or explaining the plan;
    • Implementation strategy, or explaining how the plan is put into action;
    • Engagement strategy, or explaining how stakeholders are engaged;
    • Metrics and targets, or measuring and disclosing progress; and
    • Governance, or explaining how the plan is embedded in governance structures.

    In his column, Tan identified three key attributes common to credible transition plans:

    • Comprehensive understanding of material climate-related risks;
    • Strong governance structures; and
    • Monitoring of actionable, science-based near and long-term decarbonisation targets.

    Tan acknowledged that it will not be easy to come up with a good transition plan, especially if it is a new experience for a company. His message was, nevertheless, to begin anyway.

    “As developing and executing a credible transition plan will be challenging, companies are not expected to have sophisticated transition plans from day one,” he wrote.

    “Like other aspects of business strategy, transition planning is an iterative process. Yet, it is imperative that companies start strategising as soon as possible and work towards a sustainable future.”